Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAboutHLC April 2021 PacketHISTORIC LANDMARK COMMISSION April 12, 2021 REGULAR MEETING HISTORIC LANDMARK COMMISSION Council Chambers, City Hall, 801 Main St. - 3:30 n. m. The meeting will also be broadcast on the City's YouTube channel: https://www.youtube.com/channel[UCnY6nNk8zfXZulMglzbwEBg *AGENDA* ROLL CALL APPROVAL OF MINUTES Approval of the minutes of the Regular Meeting held March 8, 2021. REGULAR MEETING 1) PZ2021-1: Request for a Certificate of Demolition to demolish a house and garage apartment. Applicant: City of Beaumont Location: 2355 Pecos Street 2) PZ2021-74: Request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to replace brick columns with wood columns and to reduce, replace, and add shutters to windows. Applicant: Malcolm Pryor Location: 2375 Mcfaddin Avenue 3) PZ2021-76: Request for a Certificate of Demolition to demolish a structure. Applicant: Dalip Rathore Location: 1974 Liberty Avenue 4) PZ2021-81: Request for a Certificate of Demolition to demolish a garage. Applicant: City of Beaumont Location: 2410 South Street 5) PZ2021-82: Request for a Certificate of Demolition to demolish a garage apartment. Applicant: City of Beaumont Location: 2449 Broadway Street 6) PZ2021-87: Request for a Certificate of Demolition to demolish a house and shed. Applicant: City of Beaumont Location: 2555 Mcfaddin Avenue 7) PZ2021-96: Request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to install solar panels on a roof. Applicant: Gage Mueller Location: 2349 Calder Avenue 8) Historic District Code Enforcement Report OTHER BUSINESS ADJOURN `To protect, enhance and perpetuate historic landmarks which represent or reflect distinctive and important elements of the City'? and State's architectural, archaeological, cultural, social, economic, ethnic and political history and to develop appropriate settings for such places. " Persons with disabilities who plan to attend this meeting and who may need auxiliary aids or services are requested to contact Kaltrina Minick at 409-880-3777. *MINUTES* HISTORIC LANDMARK COMMISSION March 8, 2021 City Hall, 801 Main Street, Beaumont, Texas A Regular Meeting of the Historic Landmark Commission was held on March 8, 2021 and called to order at 3:36 p.m. with the following members present: Commission Members absent: Councilmembers present: Chairman Paula Blazek Vice -Chairman Dohn LaBiche Commissioner Hester Bell Commissioner Marty Craig Commissioner Christina Crawford Commissioner Theresa Goodness Commissioner Lynda Kay Makin Commissioner Thomas Sigee Commissioner Terry Hallemann Commissioner Janelle Templeton Councilmember Taylor Neild Also present: Demi Laney, Senior Planner Elayna Luckey, Oaks Historic Code Enforcement Officer Lindsey Gilbreath, Permit Processing Coordinator Catherine Allen, Recording Secretary APPROVAL OF MINUTES Commissioner Craig moved to approve the minutes of the Regular Meeting held on December 14, 2020. Commissioner Sigee seconded the motion. The motion to approve carried 8:0. REGULAR MEETING 1) PZ2021-0: Request for a Certificate of Demolition to demolish a house. Applicant: City of Beaumont Location: 2354 Laurel Street Ms. Laney presented the staff report. Boyd Meier, Building Official, requests a certificate of demolition for the second house located at 2354 Laurel Street. According to the inspection report, this structure was originally tagged on August 2, 2019. The structure has signs of transients residing inside the substandard structure. The electrical wiring of the structure would Historic Landmark Commission March 8, 2021 need to be in compliance with the 2014 National Electric Codes. The roof has several missing shingles. The siding of the house and eaves are rotting in several places. Based on the extensive repairs needed for this stricture, the Building Codes staff is recommending a raze order. Slides of the subject property were shown. Notices were mailed to property owners within two hundred (200) feet of the subject property. No responses were received in opposition or in favor. Staff recommended approval of the request. Chairman Blazek asked staff if there had been any contact with the last known owner. Ms. Gilbreath stated that the property owner had spoken with the demolitions coordinator, but had not come in about the property. Commissioner Sigee moved to approve the request for Certificate of Demolition to demolish a house, for the property at 2354 Laurel Street, as requested in file PZ2021-0. Commissioner Bell seconded the motion. The motion to approve carried 8:0. 2) PZ2021-1: Request for a Certificate of Demolition to demolish a house and garage apartment. Applicant: City of Beaumont Location: 2355 Pecos Street Ms. Laney presented the staff report. Boyd Meier, Building Official, requests a certificate of demolition for the house and garage apartment located at 2355 Pecos Street. According to the inspection report, this structure was originally tagged on November 18, 2019. The report states the plumbing and electrical will need to be replaced and brought into compliance with Building Codes. The exterior doors and windows must be replaced because the frames are broken and rotted. The outside of the home appears to be functional; however the inside of the home requires extensive repairs. Additionally, there is evidence that transients are residing inside. The garage apartment in the rear of the property is leaning and rotted on the inside. This substandard structure may cause harm to residents due to its potential for collapsing. Based on the extensive repairs needed for these structures, the Building Codes staff is recommending a raze order. Slides of the subject property were shown. Notices were mailed to property owners within two hundred (200) feet of the subject property. Two (2) responses were received in opposition and none were received in favor. Ms. Laney summarized the responses in opposition, which stated that too many houses in the district have been torn down and asked to table the request. Staff recommended approval of the request. Discussion followed between the Commission and staff about who owned the property and any action taken by the property owner. Staff reported that the property is in foreclosure and owned by a bank that had been notified, but had not taken action to prevent the demolition. N Historic Landmark Commission March 8, 2021 Staff also presented the option of just demolishing the garage apartment and not the house, since the garage apartment is the more unsafe of the structures. The public hearing on this request was opened. James W. Stone, 2390 Pecos Street, addressed the Commission. He stated that he also owns property at 2380 and 2412 Pecos Street. Mr. Stone stated that he is totally against the proposed demolition. He stated that too many demolitions in the historic district have occurred, especially on Pecos Street. He added that many of these demolished structures had been very beautiful homes. Finally, Mr. Stone stated that he would not be opposed to demolishing just the garage apartment. James J. Russell, 2370 Pecos Street, addressed the Commission. He stated that he lives across the street from the subject property and has lived there for over fifty (50) years. He added that in that time, he has seen many beautiful homes torn down. He admitted that the subject property needs work, but felt that it could be salvaged. Mr. Russell added that the subject property has sentimental value for him as his sister and brother-in-law previously lived there and he had many fond memories of the home and garage apartment. Also, he stated that the City of Beaumont is rich in culture and history and that tearing down old structures causes the city to lose its history. He stated that he has talked with contractors who agree that the house could be saved with the right person and the right amount of money. Finally, Mr. Russell thanked the Commission for the opportunity to address his opinions at the meeting. Discussion followed about the home being in foreclosure and how any liens would affect the City's ability to demolish the structure. Chairman Blazek stated that she believed the house was salvable, that work was needed on the interior, but that it was not beyond hope and that she supported tabling the request. Commissioner Crawford moved to table the request for Certificate of Demolition to demolish a house and garage apartment, for the property at 2355 Pecos Street, as requested in file PZ2021-1. Commissioner Sigee seconded the motion. The motion to table the request carried 8:0. 3) PZ2021-14: Request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to install new a storage building. Applicant: Ashley Knerr Location: 233 N. 7th Street Ms. Laney presented the staff report. Ashley Knerr is seeking permission to install a new storage building at the rear of their property located at 233 N. 7th Street. The property is a corner lot, therefore, the proposed storage building will visible from Laurel Street. The storage building will be made of metal and have a box flame with an A -frame roof pitch. It will sit 9' in height, 31' in length and 20' in width. Two garage doors will be on the front of the building facing the street right-of-way. Additionally, the structure will be painted to match the house. 3 Historic Landmark Commission March 8, 2021 Slides of the subject property were shown. Staff recommended approval of the request with the following conditions: 1. The structure is painted to match the existing home. 2. The structure has an overhang of at least 12 inches and the roof pitch match the pitch of the house. 3. The structure meets all requirements set by Building Codes. 4. The structure is in compliance with setbacks set forth in Sec. 28.03.024 District Area and Height Regulations. Discussion followed about the request and the applicant's understanding of the conditions. The applicants, Alan Hollingsworth and Ashley Knerr, 233 N 7`' Street, addressed the Commission. Mr. Hollingsworth stated that the garage has extensive termite damage and that they would like to demolish it and replace it with a metal building to prevent further termite damage. He added that the current carport is too small for their vehicles. Chairman Blazek asked the applicants if they understood the recommended conditions from staff and they confirmed their understanding and agreement. A discussion followed concerning whether the metal structure will be a custom color from the manufacturer or will be painted by the applicants. The applicants indicated that they will attempt to have the company match the metal building to the house color, but if they are unable to than they will paint it themselves. They added that they do have the paint that would be needed and were comfortable with painting it. It was determined through discussion that there was a consensus from the Commission that if it needed to be painted, the paint color could be approved by staff without having to come back to the Commission. Staff clarified that the demolition of the existing garage had already been approved by staff and the request before them was just to install the metal building. Commissioner Craig complimented the applicants on their improvements to the home. Vice -Chairman LaBiche moved to approve the request for Certificate of Appropriateness to install new a storage building, for the property at 233 N. 7th Street, as requested in file PZ2021- 14 with the following conditions: 1. The structure is painted to match the existing home. 2. The structure has an overhang of at least 12 inches and the roof pitch match the pitch of the house. 3. The structure meets all requirements set by Building Codes. 4. The structure is in compliance with setbacks set forth in Sec. 28.03.024 District Area and Height Regulations. Commissioner Sigee seconded the motion. The motion to approve the request carried 8:0. 4) PZ2021-47: Request for a Certificate of Demolition to demolish a house and a Certificate of Appropriateness for a new construction. 4 Historic Landmark Commission March 8, 2021 Applicant: Tom Cockerill Location: 2234 Evalon Street Ms. Laney presented the staff report. Tom Cockerill has requested a Certificate of Demolition to demolish the existing structure located at 2234 Evalon Avenue. The existing structure received substantial damage from the Hurricane Harvey disaster. Additionally, Mr. Cockerill requests a Certificate of Appropriateness for a new construction that will be completed under the Texas General Land Office Harvey Program. The new house will be of the Craftsman style. The 1,354 square foot home will consist of three (3) bedrooms, two (2) baths, kitchen and living/dining room. The house will be constructed on a pier and beam foundation, wood framing, horizontal lap cement fiber siding and thirty (30) year architectural roofing shingles. The elevation drawings indicate that the windows will be of a one over one appearance. Tom is requesting the exterior body paint to be SW7039 Virtual Taupe, the trim to be SW7036 Accessible Beige, and the accent color to be SW7593 Rustic Red. Slides of the property were shown. Notices were mailed to property owners within two hundred (200) feet of the subject property. One response was received in favor and none were received in opposition. Staff recommended approval with the following conditions: 1. The structure shall be elevated on pier and beam foundation. 2. Parking and ADA access ramp shall beat the rear of the property. 3. Roof overhang minimum shall be 12". 4. Columns shall be constructed to resemble the Craftsman style. 5. Windows should be six over one in appearance. Commissioner Craig asked about the letter received by staff. Ms. Laney responded that the property owner indicated that they were in favor of the request, but did not provide any further comment. The applicant, Leeann Hawkins with DRC Homes, 6710 Eastex Freeway, addressed the Commission. She stated that DRC Homes is the contractor that will be demolishing and rebuilding the home. Chairman Blazek asked the applicant if the company understood and agreed to the conditions and she voiced agreement. Commissioner Makin asked when the project would begin and Ms. Hawkins replied that they are in the early phase and waiting on a full confirmation from the Texas General Land Office (GLO), but would be in contact with City staff. Vice -Chairman LaBiche stated that the building being torn down had richer character and better detailing than the building being proposed to replace it. Discussion followed concerning the current windows, the windows recommended and the windows on the houses on either side of the subject property. Vice -Chairman LaBiche also discussed the column details, molding and 5 Historic Landmark Commission March 8, 2021 gable pattern. He asserted that these details would not be expensive to add, but would add character to the new home. Discussion followed between the Commission and the applicant about the possibility of using any material from the existing house when constructing the new one. Ms. Hawkins stated that they would have to check with the GLO to see if that would be possible, due to their strict requirements for demolition. Further discussion followed concerning the gable in the window of the existing house not being proposed for the new structure. The applicant indicated that the home owner chose from a selection of preapproved designs and did not want the gable. Commissioners discussed that other homeowners often request things that the Commission does not approve to preserve the historical character of the district. Commissioner Sigee stated to the applicant that their concerns were not intended to inconvenience their project, but explained the Commission's role in preserving the historical character of the district. Vice -Chairman LaBiche moved to approve the request for Certificate of Demolition to demolish a house and a Certificate of Appropriateness for a new construction, for the property at 2234 Evalon Street, as requested in file PZ2021-47 with the following conditions: 1. The structure shall be elevated on pier and beam foundation. 2. Parking and ADA access ramp shall be at the rear of the property. 3. Roof overhang minimum shall be 12". 4. Columns shall be constructed to resemble the Craftsman style. 5. Windows should be six over six in appearance. 6. The round window in the gable will be installed on the new house. 7. The moldings around the windows on the exterior will match the old house. 8. The board and batten detailing in the gable will be maintained. 9. The front door will be a Craftsman style door. Commissioner Sigee seconded the motion. The motion to approve the request carried 8:0. 5) Historic District Code Enforcement Report Officer Luckey presented the Historic District Code Enforcement Report, including information about current violations and inspections. OTHER BUSINESS Spotlight on Marie Broussard. In Loving Memory (1934 — 2020). Ms. Allen presented the following tribute: Marie Broussard was appointed as a Commissioner on the City of Beaumont Historic Landmark Commission on May 2, 1995 and served on the Commission until her death on October 23, 2020. In her 25 years on the Commission, she was a very active and dedicated Commissioner. She also 6 Historic Landmark Commission March 8, 2021 served on the subcommittee to create the Historic Beaumont Tour Brochure. The brochure conunittee was formed in 1997 and completed the brochure in 2003. The completed brochure presented a driving tour guide of over forty historic buildings in Beaumont. It presented architectural details as well the historical significance of each building chosen. Mrs. Broussard's contributions to the brochure were vital to its completion. Besides being a member of the Historic Landmark Commission, Mrs. Broussard served the Beaumont community in various other capacities. The long list of organizations that she was involved with includes the Beaumont Heritage Society, Beaumont Rainbow Room, Beaumont Botanical Gardens, Nutrition and Services for Seniors, Lamar Catholic Student Center, St Jude's Bereavement Committee, Neches River Festival, PTA and Gulf Coast Historical Society. She was also, of course, involved with Broussard's Mortuary as her husband Alex and his brother James represented the third generation of the Broussard family to run the business that has served the community since the 1800's. In these ways and many others, Mrs. Broussard was devoted to her family and the Beaumont community at large. The City of Beaumont and the Historic Landmark Commission were truly blessed by the contributions of such a hardworking and selfless Commissioner. We take this time to honor her legacy and strive to remember her example in our future endeavors in serving the City of Beaumont. THERE BEING NO OTHER BUSINESS, THE MEETING WAS ADJOURNED AT 4.16 P.M. 7 DATE: April 12, 2021 TO: Historic Landmark Commission FROM: Demi Laney, Senior Planner SUBJECT: A request for a Certificate of Demolition to demolish a house and garage apartment. FILE: PZ2021-1 STAFF REPORT Boyd Meier, Building Official, requests a certificate of demolition for the house and garage apartment located at 2355 Pecos Street. According to the inspection report, this structure was originally tagged on November 18, 2019. The report states the plumbing and electrical will need to be replaced and brought into compliance with Building Codes. The exterior doors and windows must be replaced because the flames are broken and rotted. The outside of the home appears to be functional; however the inside of the home requires extensive repairs. Additionally, there is evidence that transients are residing inside. The garage apartment in the rear of the property is leaning and rotted on the inside. This substandard structure may cause harm to residents due to its potential for collapsing. Based on the extensive repairs needed for these structures the Building Codes Staff is recommending a raze order. Verdict for the demolition of the house and garage apartment was tabled to April 12, 2021 Historic Landmark Commission Meeting. Planning staff recommends approval of this request. The house is not in the 1990 SPARE Beaumont Survey. Exhibits are attached. BEAUMONT Planning & Community Development Case Type:Planning and Zoning Case Sub Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Case #: PZ2021-1 Location: 2355 PECOS ST, BEAUMONT, 77702 Individuals listed on the record: Applicanf City Of Beaumont Demolition 801 MAIN ST Beaumont, TX 77701 Reason for Request of a Certificate of Appropriateness Flood Zones Construction Type Paint New Construction Occupancy Type Demo Fire District Fencing Miscellaneous Has request been made before? If yes, date: Fees Assessed: DESCRIPTION Certificate of Appropriateness Date: 01104/2021, Waived: true Notes: Case Type: Planning and Zoning Case #: PZ2021-1 Case Status: REVIEW Tag Name: PECOS 2355 INCLUDES REAR APARTMENT/GARAGE Initiated On: 1/4/2021 11:26:49AM Home Phone: Work Phone: 4098803100 Cell Phone: E-Mail: DEMOLITION OF MAIN STRUCTURE AND REAR GARAGE STRUCTURE. Flood Zone X N N Y N N N AMOUNT_ _ _ _ PAYMENT _OUTSTANDING $20.00 $0.00` $0.00 Total Fees Due: $0.00 Page 1 of 1 Printed On: 1/22/2021 Nov 18, 2019 at 9:53:32 AN 2365 Pecos S Beaumont TX 7770'9 United State; A. :..:44-- - %a 0 t Jv l , �� ��J 9 err D,2, 2 J6J P')'-r r) p. -S, u rr, c)r,'r TX 77702 2 l 1 1\1 ov '18, 2 0'19 at 23 J�cl! 1ttlJflr r�{ 77702 rA J J J -fX 77 10 Nov 18, 2019 at 9:43:29 M 2355 Pecos Beaumont TX 7770. U n iteA S- tate FA y ANI IN Ln/ s TL L 7770- -C S , N ■ t r i 2tJJJ p / 77702 1 ✓J/J/iJ/ J� f) r r 2 United , c, -ov 18, ' 201 �9:45:16 AM 2355 Pecos St Beaumont TX 77702 ' United States a Nov 18, 2019 at 9:44:05 AM 355 Pecos St ►t`ont77702 Wink lite State ti 1 r 1 4 I � I w Nov 18 f- 20.1:9 .at 9:43:25; AM 23;55-Pecos St i -TX 77701 iLed, Sta 48._ I 1 I 1 1 l SUBSTANDARD BUILDING INSPECTION REPORT BUILDING CODES DIVISION CITY OF BEAUMONT ADDRESS OF STRUCTURE: 2355 PECOS - INCLUDES REAR GARAGE APARTMENT (2375 PECOS) OWNER: KREAMELMEYER LANA-MARIA & JOSHUA T OWNER ADDRESS: 9672 CROSSPOINTE DR HIGHLANDS RANCH, CO 80130 APPRAISAL VALUE Market Value: $75,110 Fire damaged? NO CASE CHRONOLOGY: Property was Red Tagged on: 11/18/2019 Administrative (Pre -Council) Work Program? 16 DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY: Re -inspection was completed on 1/05/2021. The structure is boarded and secured. There are windows that people are getting in. Transients are still going inside. The plumbing and electrical will need to be replaced. The garage apartment is leaning. There are boarded windows and the siding is rotting in places. The exterior doors and windows will need to be replaced the frames are broken and rotten._ Based on the extensive repairs needed in this structure, staff is recommending a raze order for this structure. DATE: April 12, 2021 TO: Historic Landmark Commission FROM: Demi Laney, Senior Planner SUBJECT: A request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to replace brick columns with wood columns and to reduce, replace and add shutters to windows. FILE: PZ2021-74 STAFF REPORT Malcolm Pryor, property owner, is seeking permission to reduce the amount of windows on the front -left fagade of the house located at 2375 Mcfaddin Avenue. Replacement and enclosure of windows have been completed without the benefit of a Certificate of Appropriateness (CA) or a building permit. Originally, the house had three (3) windows on the first and second story of the home and now remaining are two (2) windows on the first and second story. Please see pictures located in your packet. He is also asking permission to install shutters on all exterior windows; no color for the shutters has been delineated by Mr. Pryor. Additionally, Mr. Pryor is requesting that the original brick columns for the carport located off the left -side of the home to be made of wood. This work was also completed without the benefit of a CA or building permits. Staff recommends denial of this request. This house is not in the 1990 SPARE Beaumont Survey. Exhibits are attached. BEAUMONT Planning & Community Development Case Type:Planning and Zoning Case Status: REVIEW Case Sub Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Tag Name: McFadden Property Case #: PZ2021-74 Initiated On: 3/17/2021 11:58:31AM Location: 2375 MCFADDIN AVE, BEAUMONT, 77702 Individuals listed on the record: Applicant Malcolm Pryor Home Phone: 2815085616 5502 Willowpeak Court Work Phone: Rosharon, TX 77583 Cell Phone: 2815085616 E-Mail: malcolm.pryor@gmail.com Agent Malcolm Pryor Home Phone: 2815085616 5502 Willowpeak Court Work Phone: Rosharon, TX 77583 Cell Phone: 2815085616 E-Mail: malcolm.pryor@gmail.com Property Owner Malcolm Pryor Home Phone: 2815085616 5502 Willowpeak Court Work Phone: Rosharon, TX 77583 Cell Phone: 2815085616 E-Mail: malcolm.pryor@gmail.com Reason for Request of a Certificate of We have changed out all windows in the exterior area. All windows Appropriateness were damaged. Are desire is to paint the exterior walls, install roof, and general landscaping. Paint Y New Construction N Demo N Fencing N Miscellaneous Y Has request been made before? N If yes, date: Fees Assessed: DESCRIPTION _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ _ AMOUNT_ Certificate of Appropriateness $20.00 Date: 03/19/2021, Waived: false Notes: PAYMENT OUTSTANDING $20.00 $0.00 Total Fees Due: $0.00 Case Type: Planning and Zoning Page 1 of 1 Case M PZ2021-74 Printed On: 3/29/2021 Roof Shingles Tamko Rustic Black with 10- year warranty Replace all windows with Double Pane windows. Install 2 Shutters on all exterior windows Paint side and rear door Classical White SW 2829 front door Rockwood Red color SW2802 Provide general landscaping Power Wash entire home including stair bf.FoG r Igo . 1 '• r . OL rl �.,�r .. yr �,,7� .���iii••��� .^.�2-. .1 :a '1 •ate i r � _ - ``� i o.� s � •'(''. p�!' .q 1.1 �-Yllk - -- ��_ utm r "s_" --' - -=-J{-I�•-'--1--�--!_I-��r_ _ "�I , yam' � ti _.�iE, 1r AN y _ ^�•�. , r+ C � DATE: April 12, 2021 TO: Historic Landmark Commission FROM: Demi Laney, Senior Planner SUBJECT: A request for a Certificate of Demolition to demolish a structure. FILE: PZ2021-76 STAFF REPORT Dalip Rathore has requested a Certificate of Demolition to allow the demolition of a residential structure. This property is located at 1974 Liberty Avenue. Mr. Rathore expresses that this structure is beyond repair and a danger to the community. The City has not tagged this structure for property maintenance. However, our Demolition Department has reviewed the property and recommends this structure to be demolished. Future usage of the lot has not been delineated by the property owner. Staff recommends approval of this request. This property is not listed in the 1990 SPARE survey. Exhibits are attached. BEAUMONT Planning $ Community Development Case Type:Planning and Zoning Case Sub Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Case #: PZ2021-76 Location: 1974 LIBERTY AVE, BEAUMONT, 77701 Individuals listed on the record. Applicant Dalip Rathore 175 N 4th street Beaumont, TX 77701 Property Owner Hebert Indra Panjwani 18503 STEAMBOAT INN DR HUMBLE, TX 77346 Case Status: REVIEW Tag Name: LIBERTY 1974 Initiated On: 3/18/2021 10:36:OOAM Home Phone: Work Phone: Cell Phone: 4095502222 E-Mail: ddtxdemo@gmail.com Home Phone: Work Phone: Cell Phone: E-Mail: Reason for Request of a Certificate of REQUEST TO DEMOLISH STRUCTURE, BELIEVES STRUCTURE Appropriateness IS BEYOND REPAIR, Paint N New Construction N Demo Y Fencing N Miscellaneous N Has request been made before? N If yes, date: Fees Assessed: DESCRIPTION Certificate of Appropriateness Date: 03/1812021, Waived: false Notes: AMOUNT PAYMENT OUTSTANDING $20.00 $20.00 $0.00 Total Fees Due: $0.00 Case Type: Planning and Zoning Page 1 of 1 Case #: PZ2021-76 Printed On: 3/29/2021 pr 5, 2021 at 1:40:25 PM It 41-1 Ala, J4 momoff- AT or Ow Apr 5, 202�1:t'1:40:23 PM Op OP AAdb a�! ♦ lu V - •'--�.. ry. � p��� � AF+r �,� •�!i•'�•vr •l{ir rr���•�t htlti �� •�4 �.���• � 1� 't •,r, , V �� .• r „' 1�"ti�. �~ �. . "4`� '1�. I '. I. �. � •r j � ,\/�,_1 11,. r�}L �� r Ir � r�� ' fy ^.; :� .•t ��`_`►,r�'yry �'^ ��' �' :�1 rri Lr 'j .`f �a��•1.LO "�, ►'�V••lr iL �,i`` r�,; � 1�.`f�[''11�. %` "nl%t��14'{1{�•'l'.j[�.>w#� �,7� l'. �. � Y � ��.,�'��+'• ���1"�~,1.^`�`� •��j 1•r'►:� 'r �� Y .�.. .�I •l __\_�.i, ,t 1 I;t '►1r1>f,'L.1%,�it1�.^ L_•t1/.-IC'�•►..�' . �� �_r • Vf' Y` r. t Y 1 � .cam f. 1 � � •- � � �� � 4 � • � �' �� r �a ! � - - last •� .� a • 4 — � � — -�+� .�1•~ . t . t- _t .., DATE: April 12, 2021 TO: Historic Landmark Commission FROM: Demi Laney, Senior Planner SUBJECT: A request for a Certificate of Demolition to demolish a garage. FILE: PZ2021-81 STAFF REPORT Boyd Meier, Building Official, requests a Certificate of Demolition for the garage located at 2410 South Street. According to the inspection report, this structure was originally tagged on March 2, 2021. The report states that the garage has multiple rotten and deteriorated support beams. Two garage doors are broken and are stuck in place half way down, and there is overgrowth on most of the structure to the point that the garage is mostly hidden from the street right-of-way. Trash and debris exist all throughout the structure. Based on the extensive repairs needed to bring this structure into compliance, Building Codes Staff is recominending a raze order of the garage only. The owner has signed a demolition consent form and it is filed with our Demolition Department. Staff recommends approval of this request. The house is not in the 1990 SPARE Beaumont Survey. Exhibits are attached. BEAUMONT Planning & Community Development Case Type:Planning and Zoning Case Status: REVIEW Case Sub Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Tag Name: GARAGE ONLY Case #: PZ2021-81 Initiated On: 3/19/2021 10:38:54AM Location: 2410 SOUTH ST, BEAUMONT, 77702 Individuals listed on the record: Applicant City Of Beaumont Home Phone: DELANCY WOOD Work Phone: 801 MAIN ST Cell Phone: BEAUMONT, TX 77701 E-Mail: Reason for Request of a Certificate of DEMOLITION OF THE REAR GARAGE ONLY BY THE CITY OF Appropriateness BEAUMONT OWNER HAS SIGNED A DEMOLITION CONSENT Paint N New Construction N Demo Y Fencing N Miscellaneous N Has request been made before? N If yes, date: Fees Assessed: DESCRIPTION AMOUNT PAYMENT_ _OUTSTANDING Certificate of Appropriateness $20.00 $0.00 $0.00 Date: 03/19/2021, Waived: true Total Fees Due: $0.00 Notes:___ Date: 03/1912021, Written By: Delancy Wood OWNER HAS SIGNED A DEMOLITION CONSENT Case Type: Planning and Zoning Page 1 of 1 Case #: PZ2021-81 Printed On: 3/29/2021 ' K'- i• i'`y,`+. `ll w1S3 rl ' �i {t �.•7•M r 4r - '(� J' >'..R,, � t^J !,` ��, a�.. \ '1�k � • r ����t� f .T,"+i����' rKr+ ��R,� •�-'�'"' � 1� i _ � �r s. �� � ��,.��-+ , •� •' y „Beau X-7�Zr7 4 , it``:�1 l q . `•\V► �.\ ;.'. �t •I.`L ' .f �J _ ,/{r'•V If ! y 't * ~�� �� - .\�i' s • r•,R�G. .M }_'-.`,. ,; Ie,-: y� .a �' w !.•!. ' * �+ ais • 1 �__ 11'w3" �� i �-' � : 'Sn ^� ,yr�� � ., � 'mac' J� - •-`%s�- ti . X .r�•r1.,,.x :� Y :. tt wyr .':. ^c �.. m„�"! w t���r'9"��;-p. �1.R _ - - T'r'R '" ° y?>Z • ' �� �'. �.. •.� � tx T d " ' •�,. ��; � � F ,, ;C'- ' _ - _ tom` �_ �fJ t♦" � '''%�` �. - � ..� r�. ` •-{< r �_�, . l Il. � z $may vy. �^ �` �� '�,. - -L�r �•r . �•r' sry '�. , •. ��,,,.�a w.7 K �� f'- �t •Y sti"'t �r - .r a ^ i / yr� 'i �:i�.+4 t�,`Cr• Y` lT: \.- , iF y� i+ •. ~'K il. tl `r i1-Y � + - ''7� • i- �"! a •Y.. �'i. r���.. � 'ea `�' tfv ' � ` rk • � .I �ya✓`` �Z �'a'�,.w�y,�.�'�l �1• I' ra' .r,.,,tr..SG w �P 'S.M}k ,, r-- ':::.� � �-�..s`y�`�� �. � �.r►. s,4 ♦w•.`•�a `. _L�.,. �'V..'-^a�q, y� `a •r :, �',.��rar��-'t+.,'i�!-: ?` --w, ?,.;� - •,aeCY' ♦.J�, ,pl_ 'a:%y`-►•�.`'•`1: aT 'T!'::, K,f.''S �� .,� �� _ ap! .34 i' +. .J�P-y�i;��t' �� Y � i"' to � " ,. r,\ r `-�` �.y �- � � �_ -. •' yr• �.:, 41 ��. � +�F j• . ,M� : •� _ _._' .. - _ - - _ _ -mow - _ N --, � j�,T, ,T -t �e ram, -- J -� � �- 1, •� � / �..� �..- i j � `� � � fi '' ,ram " . �ql d " • - 1. Y'S: �'t` j1 .>A iTi � y_ ? � _ r � „n !�"n - - - ti � r .,.-!.'t-' • • _ � : + •"�`� ��� � � `� � h.Y ,�„� .� • � ,�1 � �,Z _ � s �",�� �� - = �� � ,;�l� c �y� �,.,e�-a- j..�� ' 'r'�l�„►.�.�, y.,�ar�b! ;_'`S_�,yXt-�_�r _ ` v.�..,.s- ..<� „' �' r,.:�._ ~� .;;�; wr��y�'"� _y�T♦ �y "' •-� .t •.•,�+-� r:=_� ��=�4'l^c,�'..., �'�.rC�;'"'t.•+,' .� ?v t � -_ -� ♦.. ,�'C. _ y_ Vim' -"t: 'S� 'G' _���, -••�. t �. �i� .t. -"�, �c..• '"� �-59 P 202j,-a-A;-P71. ar, J W, P, J! Mai AF 4v --A �j -7 \ 7 awl Y \ - "4OF Y .•"�� • � PIS !�•• - � �• I 7✓ 9 .i u I Mar 1, 2021 at 1:17:56 P 2410 South Beaumont TX 7770 United State t�1 4 Ir r zf 1 La .n ar R r• 't, �M, ,,� - j+ `�� �. T'j� f ' \ 'p/ s ��17r.�, _ � ��� (r.t r 1~ S} �, ,u .x• �^J r , ,. _ S _ ►� f r y -ir' ' y iat \ `l � �` .i . � .+ , r` � 'r+. J�� ..K�"h'rr ,� ���+. � "���� �� a '�'r °_� � •} � � .�'��`� � y\ r � .r. C a Y ✓ �:t Z�• �- �� �� �� �.V�. �* - rf •. -f I�%IY. �-rr ? I Y! � ' _ �f� •iC � +�:, `, 4„., � ,�� _ � _7��/� � � j ' T- _ r\ _ ••ice '(��r. � ✓�. ��__ `,,�'`;r '4� + �• °�"y�.s � ! ��y� �?j�`, -p Y•�,`� '�'�•�'.��y�- � iS��7V; �`�- +�r3 � k� ;b,6� Y fir' ' -'� ,.�� � a -. � L'� A vkr• �. � .. _ ;Ic. ., 4� � r �-,, ``� f y ' � � y1 � g' _.A�', �11` .r'K� '-- ', it ' `1 ` . � r. fr; ��' • �L �'� ` -� �" �} - .'. / 1 . .�` a �• - R.IJ`.�}��,, �L ;as•:d` II �F7 '�'�.�4 '� 'r�� .�. � :J s� ♦< r- � `�� rI ri���3 • * ,. i v, ...� a: i � � �� r j' 1 _' _, - /� .-r� t,' 'M."..itl.., t� N { '•• - : r. . .o � I ;��r. a i ! � � � viti ! '.,� L: si r . � . s• µF • v r • � �'! �.? r�S . �"'", t' r. + 'rr' 1 '. ..� -. � `:'" off •:�;yw 1 a' - .i „'ii \. • _ '. ��.�.. � l 'Il- i�y...h _ .� y ��: �a'�� � J''• r• t •L ! �{ �:�y � `` '- d�y ,� �� . is ' i /`� � �� - _ `��.y_ r „ �L� � __ ��.r�tu� r'..+�,a� i •\�-I r ` • F J, y _' i � +�� `Y�` � ` !i :,f t7�.'rti'i(� �11„_. -�..� `.. ��. \� _ - - .ter ,rye+/�'.r. :ra! � � -+ ark\`:,. �t ,� •ti.- "G�' C--� `C^ 5 - ` s .I- r.- `1;, �'/G i6A i�L � �, Gtl�, :r r�J'•t�� � ! �'� `ifs- �.Y- •��i - - - ''• r s,� - G .e - %Z v'� r!ri _� s . V�. . `�j� q�k 'i _ :� - �_ � - '�� _ .i �J �' i. •�,M � r<'�„�,H � �,. _ i fi i ,^ � � t' Sy► � � ��, fir-•'! .� �� � . f� - ��� 7 '��� A, - . / j"f l.� ►�11 Jkt ���' �'� `� �, � � k;��t �\ �1. v ^ i x _•`i� ��-�r•� �\- 'r1 'y s _ _ f�. c•.. •_J- j �'a_J - I �/rV�y" �ir it !. >_ .?:✓w 1 �� ��•'0 �^�� t•�/''. 7 `�Jr 1,1��}�" r.. .�' - '��� �t�,-/'� �.�.�.. -�-f� wr�:"a I-� `? L � - Z � _ -� .r � l .r'. 4 ' dyd �, ���"' r^.! �-�- . �Z���I `•jl_R.�'� +`\- 6_: - ...:� 4 .-y. \� � -'s'- � j?�;�� � -- � �\. � -_ :.ram, �,, , I i � �� v'r �, ;� � _�!, , . 4 •• � � � r -� � -�... 1 ( �� - � /' V � � _ �\� � r �� �o •: � �� / J ` � { 1, �v�•�:i ` 1 �.�~f `� r' � � Sark-', ' " + •- - 1 '�•1.��-.,� I � •� �.+4 � t° I �9®� , .1© i 1` 2(.- •N I` `' r,a+`. ✓`''� �`i: y �Va3• ,�,� t : ✓'`� - V`�-\`__ �� ".`y'a+' 1 1p _� ' =4Q. �• ``f.�•- �\ � h' ��d.��.: r r "�.. � u1�` 4�'��+ )'� �.� rrj,.11r°���pr�0 r�.a f'`'�'� �t- . _ _.�-. -r . �L'{,/ -, ,.; �. i �•,� ,:,A� . � r _ ;��� - , ✓ „�' � .ice= �1 --•.r-�. ��✓ .,.�4 r� � '�.:t ~yt��' �r .. t«� �' eg I�_ fa !C':� ]'y�r"^ a - - ��1\ _ *�� �e>^'-�✓'I��%6� .:�' `�0�, •� �11'i� r -i^hv �%'�� 5,( -;`^E�- �� v��a'�y � - -�T �,`�~ � s[L.j_ .�•r . - ' �.f I ,r•�'l✓/( ..a, � r1�„� � .o- [ .,,,.ter � ����r rr ` '� �i _ _. _ s• �r��' •� � ,0�!rrx�, •. i�.�'�r ° ^,-���jr`+a, •i-,Y7j¢�a�''1� ^'�' �-'� S�" . ,,, a'- � � .- ' ?� ,... Cw : + _ A � � -"'r��`.rrw� ,-.� i ��.. M xf' '✓i�.S,��r' .. �,• "�r:�-ti���i``' ''� A' -"'. ..r �.w � :.�-- _ �j1 IM r � e ,•o`er � �,;'�►�� r� +++rrr to 4-` �• 1 ', '1 , 1 4-t I P-1 Mar 1, 2021 at 1 I'l 8:26 1 South Bpau.mo 51-Tx- 4�*�!fnited Sta '+tidy► �f �4 ..- y f �4S �►� � ' ' 'r,� �+`T ,, ��ad��`?' a� -j�.� :�w� _ :.� ti. � _ � � i' ��� �.e , _.�- ~_ _ 'ram � .i. i : � r 1 �� ' �' It �,,. - t�,. (i.� � r� _ niuuo� Y- � f � __..__. © r � � .. �� � � � ��, .� � � � � � � � � � � i ��Ci ` � �' l� 1 �. ' ' ' r `' _ /� � �, .� i r � � , � , ' �y IJ I � � � -� F - I�� � � � A � � �, 3 � � �' I �� - �t j � 1 d y ��n � � . �' �� j'� � , � - „ � f; I f ,,. ,,(', 1 J ,' SUBSTANDARD BUILDING INSPECTION REPORT BUILDING CODES DIVISION CITY OF BEAUMONT ADDRESS OF STRUCTURE: CIliil`►1 I" OWNER ADDRESS: Market Value: Fire damaged? Property was Red Tagged on: 2410 SOUTH — GARAGE ONLY JOHN & VIRGINIA ROBERTS 800 CHINA ST CALVERT, TX 77637 Owner enrolled in Pre -Council Work Program? $84,924 NO 03/02/2021 NO DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY: Owner has signed a demolition consent. The structure has multiple rotten and deteriorated support beams. The two garage doors and broken and stuck half way down. There is overgrowth on most of the structure to the point it has hidden the garage. There is trash and debris throughout the structure. Based on the extensive repairs needed in this structure, staff is recommending a raze order for this structure. DATE: April 12, 2021 TO: Historic Landmark Commission FROM: Demi Laney, Senior Planner SUBJECT: A request for a Certificate of Demolition to demolish a garage apartment. FILE: PZ2021-82 STAFF REPORT Boyd Meier, Building Official, requests a Certificate of Demolition for the garage apartment and shed located at 2449 Broadway Street. According to the inspection report, this structure was originally tagged on February 13, 2021. The report states that the structure is unsafe and the support beams are beginning to lean. The roof has plastic covering parts of it and the rafters have rotted from exposure to the elements. Additionally, the windows are broken and the stairway is unsafe for anyone to walk up. The small shed located behind the garage apartment has already collapsed and Building Codes staff is requesting for the debris to be picked up as well. Based on the extensive repairs needed for these structures, the Building Codes staff is recommending a raze order. The owner has signed a demolition consent form and it is filed with the Demolition Department. Staff recommends approval of this request. The house is not in the 1990 SPARE Beaumont Survey. Exhibits are attached. BEAUMONT Planning & Community Development Case Type:Planning and Zoning Case Status: REVIEW Case Sub Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Tag Name: REAR GARAGE APARTMENT ONLY Case #: PZ2021-82 (2449 BROADWAY) Location: 2451 BROADWAY ST Initiated On: 3/19/2021 11:28:11AM Individuals listed on the record: Applicant City Of Beaumont Home Phone: DELANCY WOOD Work Phone: 801 MAIN Cell Phone: BEAUMONT, TX 77701 E-Mail: Reason for Request of a Certificate of Appropriateness Paint New Construction Demo Fencing Miscellaneous Has request been made before? If yes, date: Fees Assessed: DEMOLITION OF REAR GARAGE APARTMENT (2449 BROADWAY) ONLY BY THE CITY OF BEAUMONT N N Y N N N DESCRIPTION _ — _ _ — _ _ _ AMOUNT_ _ ^ _ PAYMENT _OUTSTANDING Certificate of Appropriateness $20.00 $0.00 $0.00 Date: 03/19/2021, Waived: true Total Fees Due: $0.00 Notes: - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - Date: 03/19/2021, Written By: Delancy Wood OWNER SIGNED A DEMOLITION CONSENT Case Type: Planning and Zoning Page 1 of 1 Case #: PZ2021-82 Printed On: 3/29/2021 13 �� =0w— -� -- �= `� • ��"4°,�� r .'� �r.,, r?. :yj,a+.f o-,.' s,�� Y.?�_."�� jrr�� C' : � �,.� �� � "k'.• , •._ , �f� ��::': ,,�► � 4-mot"^ SG.���,� MIA Op � �- �,: .mot; .. • �r�� -..: AV 4 AAL � ' i,, act-_�''' •-,rsr__�_,' T _ �� _ - mill M-A 'Wo = A* Fib 'W�j;:Ojp V 15, K LIS, kk Mv Art iw.W to '` v ��A s �:0. �►" _ ..+1 ,{ice - f-. ''low F 'l i 117 AM �.It"�' •.�- Iy I ,'-yiy„�r�'F'k""�'�S'r ,,.}z `"�`':F"' ( iN,�• , , _��/y�l�•• _:t,n,,:j �- Y ���h . !�al.,� i`� -Y.. — ' I!••� - T �..� i � y� • InM�N :Y.� G�,�,\�^" � �'7�/��d3��1 - a�. •� . •I � I V J# �- � 7. '�'• ti a i - ���, 1 tir'�r` .f r'•,R. � ` +'tom -1 �- '• �', �' .."� + 1%.r a�V;q„\ p• `-yam m OVA 'I SUBSTANDARD BUILDING INSPECTION REPORT BUILDING CODES DIVISION CITY OF BEAUMONT ADDRESS OF STRUCTURE: 2451 BROADWAY (REAR GARAGE APARTMENT OWNER ADDRESS: Market Value: Fire damaged? Property was Red Tagged on: & SHED ONLY 2449 BROADWAY) ALMA MAURINE MARTIN 2451 BROADWAY BEAUMONT, TX 77702 Owner enrolled in Pre -Council Work Program? $102,147 NO 02/13/2021 NO DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY: The owner has signed a demolition consent for the rear garage apartment and shed. The structure is unsafe the garage support beams are rotten and some have started to lean. The roof has plastic over parts of it and the rafters are rotting from exposure to the elements. The stair way is not safe enough for anyone to walk up. The windows are broken and the frames are rotten. Based on the extensive repairs needed in this structure, staff is recommending a raze order for this structure. DATE: April 12, 2021 TO: Historic Landmark Commission FROM: Demi Laney, Senior Planner SUBJECT: A request for a Certificate of Demolition to demolish a house and shed. FILE: PZ2021-87 STAFF REPORT Boyd Meier, Building Official, requests a Certificate of Demolition for the house and shed located at 2555 Mcfaddin Avenue. According to the inspection report, this structure was originally tagged on February 26, 2021. The report states that the house is sinking caused by foundation issues. Half of the roof has been covered by a blue tarp. The doors have been broken into and it is now covered by wood to deter anyone from going inside. All of the windows will need to be replaced and the frames have rotted. The electrical wiring will need to be brought up to the 2014 National Electric Code standard. Based on extensive repairs needed to repair this structure, Building Codes staff is recommending a raze order. The owner has signed a demolition consent form and it is filed with the Demolition Department. Staff recommends approval of this request. The house is not in the 1990 SPARE Beaumont Survey. Exhibits are attached. BEAUMONT Planning & Community Development Case Type:Planning and Zoning Case Status: REVIEW Case Sub Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Tag Name: MCFADDIN 2555 Case #: PZ2021-87 Initiated On: 3/22/2021 2:32:49PM Location: 2555 MCFADDIN AVE, BEAUMONT, 77702 Individuals listed on the record. Applicant City Of Beaumont Home Phone: DELANCY WOOD Work Phone: 801 MAIN ST Cell Phone: BEAUMONT, TX 77701 E-Mail: Reason for Request of a Certificate of Appropriateness Paint New Construction Demo Fencing Miscellaneous Has request been made before? If yes, date: DEMOLITION OF STRUCTURE BY THE CITY OF BEAUMONT N N Y N N N Fees Assessed: DESCRIPTION _ — — — — _ _ _ _ AMOUNT PAYMENT_ _OUTSTANDING Certificate of Appropriateness $20.00 $0.00 $0.00 Date: 03/22/2021, Waived: true --------------------------------- Total Fees Due: $0.00 Notes: Date: 03/22/2021, Written By: Delaney Wood OWNER SIGNED A DEMOLITION CONSENT Case Type: Planning and Zoning Page 1 of 1 Case #: PZ2021-87 Printed On: 4/5/2021 ,s f �Ij qq McFaddin e } /fUnited States, �c.l W jr) Ave 77702 3 4 .0 I 4 t .1 Feb 25, 2021 at 11:35:03 A 2555 McFaddin Av 01 Beaumont TX 7771 United State 2-B Nlir Faddl i %',\/ I f i f I:c,0 I.a I.G .omit, , 0 2 1 21� 5. 1 l 4,"17 ur A Feb 25, 2021 at 11:34:23 A 2555 McFaddin Av f Beaumont TX 7770 )l United State I 13 _ 1 ';jam � ?' �r-t� � j , � -.. Y :r _ - --- -----„ -- - � - •� - I - `' ` | - -- 9� "" Feb 25, 2021 at 11:33:37-A 2555 McFad( A Be �7 7770 ;r- d State 'yt Y 4 h'. �*--*Vow .�`^ti!"u"�•=+., s 2555 McFaddin AvI Bea, mont TX 7770, United State Bea, X 1. %4 F1' AS' A NVA . , d•M��;1, : �1► ��IIl ;t - irk dif 4'�V tl 70 `,v •�`�'�!a's 00 1 i el �/_�� �11 d:=Sate Aw NO ` F "vo �► J^'i7c' �" 1': .fir �' i�` , °'�'•�i.'.. •� rf 'C''��� �} i� a�4- '•' �1 �; �sa;. . ��p C�-�Y 1r - t�1�.\� / � J r �4.5'• : h'r � i� �'i�p,�" �� !, �r C•'i' ^ ��.%�"/-r- - �''�� ��E��f� .fr �! � tY�:,;•v.r-„�. -• / iron �{T�'jy�< In • �. is �r :� ��>,,� a a<r.• �_ jw rfy•, DwO �9r(ry'�% •y,.Qy� l�Srr'.-,Ai / �i,\.':.�'L w•4 ��i1;1 jig ION , LGf�.,tl./�.. r. ► ww � V 'O • f• r 1i �, f o !4�ae mrpa� '117 /r . 61 AS ...V��r��''�d►St7ib�ati'` {t QiwG is �s rt`n Tr `s�'�7„6 • "� Sf:� 'yam, �+ .r � - � - _ ►?'tom' ' '7�-4''t a ,'� "4 `ti �� �. `_ .�Y-Wlmv� qu - � ".y -a p•-fir, ,. 1 'r ��4�' �, TI • �h' llf j � t 1J �. ! � f t 4 �'C, 'yam �" .'v •p, " - -� I � � .,_,,..��__ � .. f . _ .yt ?M�.-M •� �+ 5 ... yr.-+---". k. -_- �w r �'. _ may, ,, w.�„�x �_y ��e�y"r-• - -� `G '' R' ' `• - � __- _ •W: 'I Grp/' r w � ALSO'- 25SE N t 'S T` L L AMy ft, 1 74 AA, 7Y -�el- r � �_ zr - _ � �� - � + T ' ' t r 3 �- ram./ � �. "w +•-r i �.lr„ ';y/�� � ��_ -� �. i -: ._��7qp, , y�v� r �'^►.�.;y„ti.'�C.�,�y?�-.� _3553'�`'�v�"t.- ..C�7��C:� l� -"-� •Q-"y'l t'yv�:. �01r��,;,�+r'., �l rxx '�t'i.` s •... all -� _ .t I +.. s411xY.w �.ti,,. �', u�;,i." zi- • .-�=Yr - 'SF% _ "� r.,• � �� = ova .� � �' i���,K I � "�< 5�1•-__...._-.-. .._--..-•.• _ �.._�t�a�io1^a;'�'�°Gt�4'!���Y'C+IC�s..'i?�� _.vs. ...� .9+.p... ,,...._ �� _ _ __ -• 1 • 1 M ,: ---� -- :....,......_ T �. �, — l/\J �.o � � — / F. _� .- � � _. ���� _ _ _ — /i ��,� `�. _. � �t'�"+�.�'w`"�.'£4� ��.1- � .��.-'�a�sn�`Rr'� �_n..�1Y.Tr..._ _ �A4iI�r�-- _ �.� � ��� < ayr� , •�+P,�. V• �Y �• �3 f Y .., f. met 4 ' i � ar'- � i� Ti"'- u z*��1��1��. � ®_... 1 �i� � a.'�.�ii�`:.�'�1� tf'' ,t �..��' +'� s� : � �. � y� �i ' sf .��z�p y. �*..te:o :v, .:h.:'.�a. v.�i.a,La. rt 'a.\`����:i.t.:J�. ..a9�_..�.-�Vl�_ ..aia--��.�®1�s3-ti�:�. i�� 7 _J- or 0 Ai N}Db,Vrr TOa CODL OMCML'S SURDI N'ANKAY, >TnTLDr nc,� xxO0Nl:o.vvNNT, OLnLr AInDL L'vDlec] �nNronxT:K loan¢ IONT.astLxl>v coLnlv.nanz Aw DUNO DLLv xuoK\oN nnm waro.rrnmuaT nw nLtTLAAnoN, L U n nD, CT' or tu_,L'SIQvr, nD}LKSQY CUUNT', rr Ml.A r rnD MACLD DUICKKILD AND L lw AN rO11o%x K• i — MCF'ADDLY NT : 1 LY CIUR4[.01 hNDC0NTKOWiD III' &S.UJtARGR FAE C ALIMNO RAFACL �),� DRIDIDC O', W'T n M nn]LL L, AT. DI SVSI'ICTID PLACE: JtDOL'�CO\DnlO\AVDOR,TOLnnW O(nIC tlVIl11lNG AND IrVJ: - ' a orn¢cmrornLap,lovl. �_ .. . 110m{DIrICN14rNaCq of R,em.rr\],r0.+. arNlaen [oNCWNLW Na.ge nel ��� dr1,ImN.a, IlN.n bw .wv.oflo.WrW 4W v[Nv,.plygp.N Nu Lutw. ' } W Inxlmn W.Iatiwm.x.,II. WnWwn N4 nSh„. ' rOKL AIRI\T AYKl r%IY?VA\O. OI-A WA%PAW lnlT Wlll - Y f ODT 4D80KCTw1G\T OfTICIIIoII o D R]I d \IONATZD IAo•I .M or 'fir-, .•�4 >..• ♦_y",__ IF �h UNSAFE llQ SOT EtiTER OR OC cupy w. r•r,. alx.,,W,4 h •ronnP.w Wnpn.IW. na n..,,,,,Wr. a ,a. nl• Rnnr I,.nNwn W W atl.nxy,n +•I I!N! 0. .! nrnra..l .n4N ]xn.l I'n.nn..,hnnMnAl,Inn W n ..wb Ow W W 1 , I IL rlll„1III r l'I 4n' ,Ir:1't\ (Onl f.1\ll'LIA\LG AI I 1 nl 1 rlr,1.11 L ln' IIL,r V\,(fTl'1 �ylrWrtn• : A,. nnrlun .., in, �y �/� c j � I,r,rA �•• GVANN.TTO]PAKCHA\V MRICT 4tID,U,1[(Ti'O PLACI:1OR wN\' :ammoNOKcoxATDLAnoN. 1.«NN. %�� S��'O 'lllrr�y..Iurnnrn.,nl I� � /1 � In01Jln� r„rin nlr r4nn CI _ IK IAI AIV}T'1 4'ON Yl' 1'PL• I WN/.NmWNtODNW � UCCI�1•,' w KTIIIATliN1 I�IF>I aA141'L: �1,`T IU4 nPPY .r",:r•CD wr AY 'l�\�.YP. .4�n:4T.ANDAµ11 lmEtOLCN.IN9 TO 111'l'ORL,11:nm'n¢]1n1 OA,'(N'PrM,ary, ]o21. ]I.IW OP nIP cm nr IIEW. o [ cove f)p rl LICNA'Dlgt WMATCOVna'ANl'I!NAVTNORIZX.DP)31SONNPIO.I1ALLDrVACI: DIQi 4 ]• R7{�( 1 ,� _lvA :,• ni•,5 IN SI'WYLT T�I TrO 1.aC1:F.UACL,D 5{ 1 ... ryT I 11 �y rev tif•Maf7.JE, ! - ' l�?l l^� rl Oat 1 _ r r�� / f f 1. �Jrlir✓�l ��r���rJ +��"1•f�jw,rua urs �• %. =1 - J l BEAU • ItW-4 I.hvllt,�l (il1LWl:f1 i . + • � AtPVnlVAfa LLttS C.•4J Vtl l'�+fINR�N..+fS`Sfi axllfdLtl\'tl (ill? UraYllu V3YUr .Y t..Vnl�TS r•Ir Jl xllffkJ.VSIYM , SGIVOYII � -i hCtl pEt VRO lIbVARVStLLLTFl. IYbITV tdSNMI ONIk�srtviCn rand. e•m N!•dvt,a.LN� PT., rs �.� � ' ..FKa e. nWrsarr l'kr n.P wJNrownur......! �ry.r.y t.af�.:»n. M 11 a Itr.n S.. N..f ra+.Y. ••u� raY:.v nJm. ' A. rye.w dd..vn.n • m.e�Ma n W.r4 b W weyrp rl • n • wNAaro. W t. 11.f•b NrJn�fe.lgvUlnJ-+rl •.Nr, NfY nrw NMar�11 k»•nnlnw.a•na l.:+M 41su4 tLr.Lf fewsnf lN•r.'•IR•+r x4P+++41nm V Nml NAe [.h N ' R4.ra rL•ry1t c.m i.�.dfl NtaxNE.[ryYfeb M[.Jwn Qom.N.wCi wN.dNs+».. Lt 1. f..ewry r 41f 6+u•n.sJ Ir{n,l {4a•�• [.k Yr nabf NYidf.�.l a• <..�.. n.Y.Jledn •1•f•1 rwt>•!./.0 lho Ityr,•N!, a..dff. " r�wmun[.a.n.....k....,w.,.a...r.,�uf..Ne....�....,..r.�ta... 1 •a4 k......a! Ik�.4r.l.k k�+Ylw.v. W s� W. a-..i-J x •.•A t�rv4 ^:J' . ' rl�iv l�rx. silr...�f.... �INa+w.Nmxrh['..ka..f...... .+••fulMy,.+ret ri( ' s.aarnq+r.,..1..a�.+,a+..ar.rrs+wf..[va.�,ib rt'.w.L�r+e.�• � ' .• IW<Ikr.t MML•Irw4 �Nsfn++rt NrNu n.�u.Yfry N[dz.t�.L v r raa.u.J Nls..d Rn+D.N.rr�• •SNr ir..Y r:a».rr.a.allr / _ Ntq AW,LRaa14N•wr.N.+..d.•e�NJsar Nn..n•1 J.Ol..e.en. 4 1 •x1- t II11 I 1 I . t� f I 1 i L�f a .T• .' " fEaq, - IT'lJ J. ,-,�711a "d r ��.,�J 11., 11 /! /' �1�� t7v i -r;,l 77702 United trtJJ AFFIDAVIT FOR CODEOFFICIAVS SEARCH WARRANT ' STATE OF TEXAS COUNTY OF IETFERSON THE UNDERSIGNED AFFIANr, BEING A CODE ]ENFORCEMENT OFFICIR FORTIIE CITY OF UFAU![1GNT, IM- TRSON COUNTY, TEXAS, AND BEING DULY SWORN ONOATH, MAKES TREFOLIAWING STATEMENT AND ACCUSATION; 1. THERE IS IN nlECE-Y OF BPAUMONT, JEFTERSON COUNTY, TEXAS,A SUSPECTED PLACED DESCRIBED AND LOCATED AS FOLLOWS; ; 2555 MCFADDIN ST tt,, T. SAID SUSPECTED PLACE IS IN Cl URGE OF AND CONTROLLED BY (t.5 REYES ALBARO RAFAEL , T. ITIS TI[aBELIEF OF AFFIANF IT [AT TITRE IS AT SAID SUSPECTED PLACE. A , HAZARDOUS CONDITION ANU'ORVIOIATION OFTUE BUILDING AND FIRE CODES OF THBCITY OF DEAUMONT. I,Bgd b[ekr, ktoiJiiog DffrcW far tbs Ctry of Br .004lwadm�cuiun moplilcl+n•J tF.s+Be acd — 5enm1 cenlixw of the Jc<misc[. I fuss L<.vow anarc of posubk life s[frrysioluims aOEis I�atioo. It will be:—.,.y to pea[ Inswi—. 01 st—h.aat tMs aids+. WHEREFORE, AFFIANT ASKS FOR ISSUANCE OF A WARRANT THAT WILL, •. AUHIORUE ANY CODE ENFORCFMFNT OFTICEROROTHER DESIGNATED EMPLOYEE OF - TIE CITY OF BFAUMO.YTTO SEARCH AND L\SPECT SAID SUSPECTED PLACE FOR ANY - HA7ARDOUS CANDRION ORCODEE VI-OLnATIO.4. NT, 941 bkka, Bondi., Olr.w SWORN TO AND SUBSCEHEFDTO BEFORE METIUS TIE 23nI DAY OF rebra+O, 2011. � Nuikiil �'N��OlttkiV� ' NOTARY LICNATDFORn®STATBOF TEXAS SUBSTANDARD BUILDING INSPECTION REPORT BUILDING CODES DIVISION CITY OF BEAUMONT ADDRESS OF STRUCTURE: OWNER: OWNER ADDRESS: Market Value: Fire damaged? Property was Red Tagged on: 2555 MCFADDIN RE, YES FAMILY INVESTMENTS LLC ALBARO & ANA REYES 5031 GRIFFING COURT GROVES, TX 77619 Owner enrolled in Pre -Council Work Program? $28,830 NO 02/26/2021 NO DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY: The owner signed a demolition consent. There is a blue tarn from the middle of the house to back of the house covering the roof. There is foundation issues that have caused a portion of the house to sink. The doors are broken and covered with wood. The electrical will need to be repaired along with some of the framing. The windows need to be replaced and the window sills are rotten. Based on the extensive repairs needed in this structure, staff is recommending a raze order for this structure. Re -inspection was done on 0/13/2021. DATE: April 12, 2021 TO: Historic Landmark Commission FROM: Demi Laney, Senior Planner SUBJECT: A request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to install solar panels on a roof. FILE: PZ2021-96 STAFF REPORT Gage Mueller, the applicant, requests permission to add solar panels to the front side of the home located at 2394 Calder Avenue. Mr. Mueller plans to attach the panels to the roof of his home. The placement of the panels will be visible facing toward the street right-of-way. With permission, there will be seventeen (17) panels installed on the roof toward the front side of the home. The contractor has provided a visual design concept for the exact placement of the solar panels on the roof. This design is located in your packets. In the article attached, the National Trust for Historic Preservation appears to be in favor of solar panels given they are not visible fiom the street. The owner of the property, Charles Thomas, currently has stop work orders posted for the existing accessory structure in the rear of the property. In 2018 Mr. Thomas received two (2) stop work orders (SWO). The first SWO was posted January 31, 2018 because he renovated the structure and installed a sewer line without the necessary permits pulled fiom. neither the Planning Department nor the Building Codes Department. The second SWO was posted on September 21, 2018 because Mr. Thomas demolished one half of the structure and then rebuilt the structure with recycled materials from the demo; again without the benefit of necessary permits. Due to the use of the recycled materials a third party structural engineer must be hired to approve the structure's stability. Additionally, the demolition of the structure disrupts his existing legal nonconforming setbacks and will need to also be brought into compliance with Chapter 28 of our City's code of ordinances. This structure has remained red tagged since 2018 and no effort has been made to resolve this issue. Staff recommends denial of the request until the property has come into compliance. The house is not listed in the SPARE survey. Exhibits are attached. BEAUMONT Planning & Community Development Case Type:Planning and Zoning Case Sub Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Case #: PZ2021-96 Location: 2394 CALDER AVE, BEAUMONT, 77702 Case Status: REVIEW Tag Name: Solar Panel install Initiated On: 3/24/2021 12:09:42PM Individuals listed on the record: Applicant Gage Mueller Home Phone: 8326685791 5146 Grape Work Phone: Houston, TX 77096 Cell Phone: 8327212339 E-Mail: gmueller@theprocompanies.com Agent Gage Mueller Home Phone: 8326685791 5146 Grape Work Phone: Houston, TX 77096 Cell Phone: E-Mail: gmueller@theprocompanies.com Property Owner Charles Thomas Home Phone: 4092129188 2394 Calder Avenue Work Phone: Beaumont, TX 77702 Cell Phone: 8326871099 E-Mail: char]esintx@gmail.com Reason for Request of a Certificate of Solar panel install on front of home Appropriateness Paint N New Construction N Demo N Fencing N Miscellaneous N Has request been made before? N If yes, date: Fees Assessed: DESCRIPTION Certificate of Appropriateness Date: 03/24/2021, Waived: false Notes: Case Type: Planning and Zoning Case #: PZ2021-96 _AMOUNT_ _ _ PAYMENT OUTSTANDING $20.00 $20.00 $0.00 Total Fees Due: $0.00 Page 1 of 1 Printed On: 3/29/2021 3/30/2021 Mail - Dern! Laney - Outlook MCA-1p No-. 2c 10 01, LIDAR 2344 Btaumom TX 3D n- cit Pw%1- 8.446 kWh 8.4 MWh En" O Avx ccrr,%�r U Design Request tjj 2­1- -N :T L H N,zm71 g Document; now. Pt, 1A., https:lloutiock.of�ice.com/mail/inboxlid/AAQkADVhYTVkOD13LTNkY2UtNDkyMS040WQzL\IVIwZTk3ZjgyNGJiYwAQAGiWE4KTTPBFrz9VE6OxEbo`/`3D/sxs/AAMkADVhYTVkOD13LTNkY2UtNDkyMSO 1/1 4/5/2021 Powering Historic Buildings: Solar Panel Projects Around the Country I National Trust for Historic Preservation k National Trust for �`�� Historic Preservation`" June 27, 2013 Powering Historic Buildings: Solar Panel Projects Around the Country By: Guest Writer Written by Chris Warren for Preservation magazine [Link: https://nthp- savingplaces.s3.amazonaws.com/2015/07/31 /15/40/29/6/130624_blog_photo_wc-solar-panels_mystic.jpg] https://savingplaces.org/stories/powering-historic-buildings-solar-panel-projects-around-the-country#.YGtjhehKiUk 1/4 4/5/2021 Powering Historic Buildings: Solar Panel Projects Around the Country I National Trust for Historic Preservation Solar panel installation at Mystic Seaport Collections Research Center. The brick parapet is visible in the background. As covered in the Summer 2013 issue of Preservation [Link: /magazine]magazine, it would be hard to come up with a more high -profile and historically significant place to install solar panels than Alcatraz Island in the San Francisco Bay. But as the price of solar panels and equipment continues to fall and people generally get more comfortable with this source of clean energy, it no longer requires a large chunk of federal dollars (which was the case with Alcatraz) and years of effort for historic buildings to tap the sun to meet their electricity needs. For instance, this past winter and spring the Mystic Seaport [Link: http://www.mysticseaport.org/] in Connecticut installed a 230-kilowatt solar power plant --just under 1,000 panels -- on the roof of an old mill building [Link: http://www.thewesterlysu n.com/news/sola r-power-system-hel ps-to-preserve-mystic-sea port-s- many/article_abf47f3c-c48c-11 e2-bf66-00]9bb2963f4.html] that houses the museum's collections and some administrative offices. As is so often the case, the impetus to cover 43,000 square feet of the 1800s-era building with solar panels was both environmental and economic. "It will generate 10 percent of the power the mill uses," says Ken Wilson, the director of facilities at the Seaport, who notes that the electricity produced will be cheaper than what would otherwise be available from the utility. "And it's an attempt to move in a more green direction." At the Seaport, Wilson says the museum worked closely with the town of Stonington to address any historic preservation concerns. The main issue was whether or not the panels could be seen. In this case, it was not a problem because the building still had an original brick parapet shielding the panels from view. https://savingplaces.org/stories/powering-historic-buildings-solar-panel-projects-around-the-country#.YGtjhehKiUk 2/4 4/5/2021 Powering Historic Buildings: Solar Panel Projects Around the Country I National Trust for Historic Preservation I �• I""! I-_.: Ll �9111 II LI� I� 11 Mal Illiur_ I� I I .1 3 LOU,O [Link: https://nthp- saving places.s3.amazonaws.com/2015/07/31/15/40/29/918/130624_blog_photo_wc-solar- pa nels_su n power.j pg] This former Ford Motor Company plant is now a SunPower Corporation facility in Richmond, Calif. Elsewhere around the country, solar panels are helping provide electricity to both historic residences and commercial buildings. In Richmond, California, a former Ford Motor Company Assembly Plant that churned out Model A cars in the 1930s is not only covered with solar panels, it has also become a facility for SunPower Corporation [Link: http://inhabitat.com/historic-ford-factory-transformed-into-sunpower-photovoltaics- headquarters/] , one of the leading makers of panels. In Bethesda, Maryland, a local landmark known as the Sycamore Store added solar panels [Link: http://montgomeryplanning.org/blog-design/?p=2537] in such a way that they are actually visible from the street. Clearly, individual circumstances and concerns about the impact of transforming an historic building into a solar power plant are highly specific -- sometimes it's appropriate, and sometimes it's not. But the sort of give and take that goes into these decisions is hardly foreign to the companies that install solar panels, accustomed as they are to customers who voice their opinion about a project's visual impact. https://savingplaces.org/stories/powering-historic-buildings-solar-panel-projects-around-the-country#.YGtjhehKiUk 3/4 4/5/2021 Powering Historic Buildings: Solar Panel Projects Around the Country I National Trust for Historic Preservation "We in the solar industry are well -prepared to deal with these things," says Gary Gerber, president of California - based Sun Light & Power. "We have run into these situations enough that it's not far out of our wheelhouse." Have a story idea that might be interesting and engaging for a national audience? Email us at editorial@savingplaces.org. hfps:llsavingplaces.org/stories/powering-historic-buildings-solar-panel-projects-around-the-country#.YGtjhehKiUk 4/4