The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutHLC August 2024 Packet*AGENDA* HISTORIC LANDMARK COMMISSION August 12, 2024 REGULAR MEETING HISTORIC LANDMARK COMMISSION Council Chambers,, City Hall, 801 Main St. - 3:30 p, m. *AGENDA* Pni i rai i APPROVAL OF MINUTES Approval of the minutes of the Regular Meeting held July 15, 2024. REGULAR MEETING 1) PZ2024-218:, A request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to install a metal roof. Applicant: Robert Dickson Location: 2495 Louisiana Street 2) PZ2024-219:. A request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to construct a circular driveway. Applicant: Hollis Read Location: 2240 Ashley Avenue 3) PZ2024-225:. A request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to allow a chain link fence to remain surrounding the property. Applicant: Maria Vizcaino Location: 2085 Angelina Street 4) Historic District Code Enforcement Report OTHER BUSINESS An IM JIM%] "To protect, enhance and perpetuate historic landmarks which represent or reflect distinctive and important elements of the City'. arid' State"s architectural, archaeological, cultural, social, econ omic, ethnic and political history and to develop appropriate settings for such places. ' Persons with disabilities who plan to attend this meeting and who may need auxiliary aids or services are requested to contact Kaltrina Minick at 409-880-3777. M I N U T E S HISTORIC LANDMARK COMMISSION July 15, 2024 Council Chambers, City Hall, 801 Main Street, Beauniont, Texas A Regular Meeting of the Historic Landmark Commission was held on July 15, 2024 and called to order at 3:31 p.m. with the following members present- Chairmaii Dole. LaBiche Commissioner Hester Bell Commissioner John ;rube arrived at 3:3 3 pin Commissioner Marty Craig arrived at 3:37 pin Commissioner Christina Crawford arrived at 3:112 pm COIDIIUSSi011er Theresa Goodness Commissioner Lynda Kay Makin Commissioner Marva Provo Cominissioner Thomas Sigee Commissioner Kirk Thomas Commission Members absent: Commissioner Ronald Kelley Commissioner Janelle Templeton Also present: Elayna Luckey, Plaimer I John Wilson, Oaks Historic Code Enforcement Officer Susan Smith, Recording Secretary Tyraan Albert, Zoning Technician APPROVAL OF MINUTES Commissioner Makin moved to approve the minutes of the Regular Meeting held on June to, 2024. Commissioner Bell seconded the motion. The motion to approve carried 7:0. Conumssioner Berube,, Con-miissioner Craig, and Commissioner Crawford not yet present. REGULAR MEETING 1) PZ2024-1.56: A request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to construct a second driveway on property. Applicant: Milagros D Martell Ponce Location: 2595 Louisiana Avenue Historic Landniark Commission July 15, 2024 Ms. Luckey presented the staff report. Milagros Martell Ponce, is requesting a Certificate of Appropriateness to construct a second driveway located in the rear of . the property at 2595 Louisiana Avenue. Ms. Ponce plans to add a driveway to the side rear yard in order to have access to the backyard from North I Ot" Street. The home is not listed in the SPARE Survey. Slides of the subject property were shown Planning staff recommended approval of the request with the following condition: 1. All applicable permits and inspections are obtained through the Building Codes Department. The applicant was not present. Commissioner Makin moved to approve the request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to construct a second driveway ono property, as requested in 202 -1 6, with the following condition: 1. All applicable permits and inspections are of through the Building Codes Department. Commissioner Sigee seconded the motion. A roll call vote was taken. Chairman LaBiche-Aye; Commissioner Bell -Aye; Commissioner Berube-Aye; Conn-iissioner Goodness -Aye; Commissioner Makin -Aye; Commissioner Provo - Aye; Commissioner Sigee-Aye; CommissionerThomas-Aye. The motion to approve the request carr led 8:0. Commissioner Craig and Commissioner Crawford not yet present. 2) PZ2024-158: A request for a Certificate of Demolition to demolish an unattached garage on property and a Certificate of Appropriateness to place a new accessory building. Applicant: Homer Howard Location: 885 North 0' Street Ms. Luckey presented the staff report. Homer Howard, is requesting a Certificate of Demolition to demolish an unattached garage on the property at 885 North 4"' Street. The existing garage has reached a point of disrepair and is no longer, functional, the applicant is also requesting a Certificate of Appropriateness to place a new accessory structure at the property. Mr. Howard will replace the structure with a new 85 x 12' wooden storage building, with vertical siding, a pitched roof with shingles, and a double door with transom lights. The home is not listed in the SPARE, Survey. 2 Historic Landiiiark Coniiiiission hily 15, 2024 Scvcnteen (17) notices were mailed to property owners within two hundred (200) feet of the subject property. Zero (0) responses were received in favor and zero (0) were reccived ill opposition. Slides of the subject property were shown. Planning staff recommended approval of the requests with the following conditions: 1. All applicable permits and inspections are obtained through the Building Codes Department. 2, The Accessory building be painted to match the main structure. Brief discussion followed concerning size of the proposed storage building. The applicant was present. Homer Howard, 885 N. 4'h Street, Beaumont., Texas addressed the Commission. fie stated that he will demolish the old building and replace it with an 8' x 12' utility building with vertical siding and a pitched roof. Mr. Iloward furthcr stated that lie recently purchased the home and is uncertain of the paInt, color of the main residence. He also stated that he intends to personally construct the building on site and paint it with white primer until such time that research can be conducted regarding the correct color that should be used. ')taff advised Mr. Howard that research will be conducted as to the paint color. Commissioner Sigee moved to approve the request for a Certificate of Demolition to demolish an unattached garage on property and a Certificate of Appropriateness to place a new accessory building, as requested in PZ2024-158, with the following conditions: 1. All applicable permits and inspections are obtained through the Building Codes Department. 2. The Accessory building be painted to match the main structure. Gong-nissioner Goodness seconded the motion. A roll call vote was taken. Chairman LaBiche-Aye; Commissioner Bell -Aye; Commissioner Berubc-Aye; Commissioner Craig -Aye; Commissioner Goodness -Aye; Commissioner Makin - Aye; Conunissioner Provo -Aye; Commissioner Sigee-Aye; Commissioner Thomas -Aye. The motion to approve the request carried 9:0. Commissioner CralArford was not present for full discussion and did not enter a vote for this item. HISTORIC DISTRICT CODE ENFORCEMENT REPORT Officer Wilson presented the Historic District Code Enforcement Report for the month of June, including information about current violations and inspections. The Commission thanked Officer Wilson for his work in the District. 3 I fistmic Landmark Conini i ssion hily 15, 2024 OTHER BUSINESS Mrs. Luckey provided updates to the Bandit Sign Program and the Downtown Proactive Code Enforcement Program. A Downtown Central Business District Inspection Dashboard overview was distributed to the Commission Beau Hansen, Deputy Building Official, addressed flie Commission by explaining the Work Program as it relates to the Downtown Proactive. Code Enforcement Progrfam. THERE BEING NO FURTHER BUSINESS THE MEETING WAS ADJOURNED AT 3:51 P*Mq DATE: August 12, 2024 TO: Historic Landmark Commission FROM: BaynaLurkp« Planner SUBJECT: Request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to install a metal roof. FILE: pZ2024'2I8 STAFF REPORT Robert Dickson, is requesting a Certificate of Appropriateness to install a metal roof located at 24D5Louisiana Street. The roof will beanasphalt shingle color ordarker and will have vertical pones. Section28.03.O18 (g)(1)(M)(i) of the City of Beaumont Code ofOrdinance states, ""roof moterials an d colors mus t comple men t thestyle an dovercill color s ch emeof theb uildin g or structure. On residential structures, tar and grovel (b(ilt-up) is permitted only as o roof material on covered porches ondPorte oochereswith flat roofs. Corpet is not permitted asoroof mo��Comp ��cedar ��ondmetalroofing materials mclybepermitted. ° The honne is not listed in the SPARE Beaumont Survey, however could be classified as a Neoclassical home with its steep side gable pitch and flat fuU-fa�ade porch covering. This type of construction was popular from 1925 to 1950, and often featured slender columns lacking the elaborate capitals or fluted surfaces of traditional columns. Planning staff recommends denial ofthe request asthere are noother metal roofs within the area and does not seem to complement the Neoclassical architectural features. Exhibits are attached. B EAU 1N►Q SIT Planning & Community Development Case Type:Planning and Zoning Case Status: REVIEW Case Sub Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Tag Name: new roof Case#: PZ2024-218 Initiated On: 7/22/2024 12:18:09PM Location: 2495 LOUISlANA ST, BEAUMONT, 77702 Individuals listed on the record: Applicant robert s dickson Home Phone: 4096515037 2495 Louisana St Work Phone: Beaumont, TX 77702 Cell Phone. 4096515037 E-Mail: truckmiser@gniall.com Agent mbert s dickson 2495 Louisana St 2495 Louisana St 2495 Louisana St Beaumont, TX 77702 Property Owner Home Phone: Work Phone: Cell Phone: E-Mail: truckmiser@gmail.com robert. s dickson Horne Phone: 2495 Louisana St Work Phone: Beaumont, TX 77702 Cell Phone: 4096515037 E-Mail: truckmiser@grnail.com Reason for Request of a Certif 1cate of new roof , wouold like to use metal Appropriateness Paint N New Construction N Demo N Fencing N Miscellaneous N Has request been made before? N If yes, date: Notes: This is not a building perinit, additional eri may be required for the proposed scope of wo.rk. Case Type: Planning and Zoning Page I of 1 Case M. PZ2024-2iB Printed On: 7124/2024 ally center door' ECLECTIC HOUSES Neoclassical 1895-1955 I ng Features ent , fyi FI acade dominated by full -height porch -with roof supported by classical columns; col- uInris typically have Ionic or Corinthian capitals; facade shows symmetrically balanced windows and center door. rill Subtypes P Five principal SUbtypes can be distinguisfiled: subtype has a dorninant central —This comi -non FULL -HEIGHT ENTRY PORCH entry porch extending the full height, but less than the full width, of the facade. It closely resembles certain Early Classical Revival and Greek Revival subtypes. As in both -nent and gabled roof oft earlier styles, the entry porch may have a classical peditome Neoclassical above or, as in the Greek Revival only, the porch roof may be flat, S eranples have curved, semi -circular entry porches with flat roofs, a variation unusual on earlier prototypes. FULL-ITEIGHT ENTRY PORCH WITH LOWER FULL -WIDTH PORCH -In this relatively uncornnion subtype, a full -width, one-story porch is added to the full -height entry p orch jus t described. This dual -level entry porch is without precedent in the earlier classical styles. Most examples were btfilt from 1895 to 1915; few, after World War 1. T-r—In. this uncommon subtype, the full -facade, colonnaded FRONGABLED ROO porch beneath the front -facing; gable gives the house the appearance of a miniature Greek temple. This form was very common in Greek Revival douses, but makes up only a small percentage of Neoclassical examples. FULL -FACADE PORCII-111 this subtype, as in the one just described, a colonnaded porch occupies the full width and height of the faca ' de. Here, however, the porch is not covered by a traditional pedimented gable but ins te 'ad either by the principal (side columns typically have Ionic or orintthlan capitals Fac-ade dorninatcd by ful[-height porch with roof supported by classical columns FULL- M 91GHT BigTRY PORCH Pages 438.39 facade with symmet rlc211y 'hafancedwindows any# center door FULL -HEIGHT ENTRY PORCH FRONT -GABLED ROOF WITH LOWER PULL -WIDTH PORCH LA P290 440 page 441 FULL -FACADE PORCH Pages 442-43 [}NE -STORY 6 E_ pages 444-45 PRINCIPAL BTYPE M I 436 ECLECTIC; HOUSES Neoclassical gabled or hipped) roof or by a flat or slied extension from such a roof, This SLIbt ype becaine Particularly popular in the period frorn about 1925 to ig5o. These later exal-npl,, normally have slender columns without elaborate capirals or fluted surfaces. ONE- STORY— One-story Neoclassical cottages, a common subtype, ushall y have hipped roofs with prominent central dormers. The colonnaded porch maybe either full- or partial -width and may be included under the main roof or have a separate flat or shed toof, Variants and Details The principal areas of elaboration in Neoclassical houses are porch -support colurnn corilices, doorways, and windows. 11S) PORCH -SUPPORT COLUMNS —In Neoclassical houses built before about 192. o, the columns are generally more of nate than those of Early Classical Revival or Greek Revival prototypes. Corinthian or tonic capitals, or mixtures of the two, are found in about 75 percent of Neoclassical houses but in less than 9-o percent of Greek Revival examples, This change was made possible by the introduction of mass-produced capitals prefabri.. cated ofmolded plaster or composition materials. Fluted column shafts are common in ry early I -louses. After abOLIt 1915, very slender, unfluted (often square) columns began to be used, primarily on houses with full -facade porches. 1"hose usually lack capitals, and; their proportions readily distinguish them from earlier Neoclassical and Greek Revival examples. DOORWAYS —Doors commonly have elaborate, decorative surrounds based on Greek Revival, Federal, or even, Georgian precedents (see pages 2-03, 2ig, and 249), Those with Georgian or Federal doorways are easily distinguished, because original examples very rarely had full -height, two-story colunins (although some have had such porches added later). Greek Revival —type doorways may be more easily confused with original examples. CORNICES Neoclassical houses usually have a boxed cave with a moderate overhang, frequently with dental s or niodillions beneath; a wide frieze band is occasionallY f01JJ3d beneath the cornice. These are loosely based on Federal or Greek Revival precedents, - WINDOWS —Windows are rectangular with double -hung sashes. Exarnplr-s f0l'aw' ing early precedent have six or nine panes to each sash; others have a multi-Paf"e Or: single -pane upper sash arid a single -pane lower sash. The presence of bay inflow , paired windows, triple windows (except the Palladian type), transomed windows, arched windows differentiate Neoclassical from Grcek Revival or Early Classical Revival! examples. C OTHER DETAILS—Mallyelaborations found on Early Classical Revival and Gr k' Revival houses also occur in Neoclassical examples. Roof -line balustrades, ill ParriculOr' are much more common in Neoclassical houses than in the earlier styles. These ON commonly found on top of full -height entry porches with flat roofs (without a pedirOrll 0ow- 011GIIIAL BARLY C] 610CLASSICAL LOVAPLES AAOM11 capitals lit V510 Lily Orjlate doMns -are sltn�er 0 jimple exle .nsjons Ind porticos may .�ddcj' Tj nusllla ofin4ow vadat ions mi found in Itypial portico 4& 254 P0 Ich Or13' o ''D15TINGUISHING THI side and wing porches roll -width raised phtForm porch �' lt'KCAL BLABORATI P"MANG S StIbtyPL, ally h.., be either ?arat e N, colurnris, 192,o5 the -k Revival iabOM75 examples, ; Prefabri. 11111non in began to )itals, and .k Revival on Greek 9). Those examples h porches h original overhang, 11ty foulid ledents, followe 4-pane or windows) or adowss A Revival 'J Ind Greek )articular) fhese ate pediment with with Obi full- full- IXAIA height facade entry porch porch EARLY CLASSICAL REVIVAL GREEK REVIVAL GREEK REVIVAL C�ASSJCAL Corinthian Ionic 0$0 Composite in only jX'1A n raphals in only 0 15 percent 01 (00 rn,Ionlylly oraalc3 5 percent oforiginals 0 414kJ -art slendcr of originals 4010 n.111S to simple Post - lid C We JIS to n S end P0,11cos may 0 bc adird, unusual irl '01iginals paired arched 'adowvariatiom transomed windows triple SV i found in and and bay I windows wi originals Windows fin two-story entry porch curved ItYPIC-al Portico with oric- portico cornice -line ind pa(ch ❑ story porch Q in only a balustrade variations LL 1111S Q a I on 2 percent unusual on originals of originals unginals DISTINGUISHING THE NEOCLASSICAL HOUSE FROM EARLY CLASSICAL REVIVAL & GREEK REVIVAL ORIGMALS fide and wing porche Full -width raised platform porch I" TYPICAL ELABORATIONS Door with snore than one line of I ights always post-1-890 (ic may, however, replace ate original) �EA 'ryPICAL EitiTRANCES dustrade A broken pediment low balustrade around Platforin porch Houses with a broken pcdirnent at the entrance or above a window and two-story columns are always Neoclassical; houses with an unbroken pediment at the entrance and "vo -s tory columns ns are usually Neoclassical (a few Greek Revival originals have unbroken triangular pediments) 3i 438 1 ECLECTIC HOUSES Neoclassical above), above full -facade porches, along the cornice line of the roof, or arotind the re deck. Another type of railing, inspired by the detail found on Chinese Chippendale fur , niture, is also typical! A Chinese Chippendale railing consists of a repetitive gcotxt t 10 r illime pattern, generallycontained in a series of rectalIgUlar fraine ! It is more coo OUnd in latex examples built after ca. 19zo (see caption for photo 4 on Page ad Occurrence Neoclassical was a dominant style for domestic building throughout the cou rit ty dating,:, the first half of the 7,oth century. Never er quite as abundant as its closely related CojoniR4 Revival contemporary, it had two principal waves of popularity. The first, from about' 1900 to 1920, emphasized lipped roofs and elaborate, correct columns. The later phase f'r � i about 1925 to the z os, emphasized side -gabled roofs and simple, slender column During the z . s, the style was overshadowed by other Eclectic fashions. !a #�d��ir i d 1: A me JIL re ! r P � -7'F1 { - � y r Asia 'L,jj2jGjJT EN ,,$, Texas; 1936, Be Cd roof, roof Tyne h 1,10 Texas; 1940- led roof and slendel le�tlon of the entry Ibiature under the S �Cigha North arol" itect, This early' ex pcapitals.! Note th, '310,y iridow5, kngular over the arc )ntprner , Alabatrl: ;hitect, An el horat( Is on the pilaster ie windows are tic M Texas; 19 . Lt recessed into the (see also Fi,ul j City, Missouri p1i ied Chines a late example. ondon, Con= 'fie, The triple w ,columns, and t a Neoclassicalj We, Kentucky; e body of the h over the upper- ROSY triple win! f he ro ate f LIN' )Met during lolonial n about r phase, Aumns, 1W Neoclassical 1 439 ENTRY POCH j RCtj -rxas13 6. Bell House. Atypical later example xvith s ide- f;9 0 It s, of.roof-linc balustrade, and simple square colunins. pbled * 0- Mils grove House. A late example wit I, a side- ..... , rcxasl194 roof an a slender colunins. The somcwhat awkward -looking Sab.ccl,or, of the clitry porch results from the on -fission of all pro) under the pediment. Iry Ifs tpjabl2ture � r 4� forth Carolina; 19 03. Goodwi a House; '\X/i Mani P. Rose, Oleo, No, is earl example examPle has fluted columns with Roman ThI over the t�, -, r Note the varicty of pediments —segmental Oil c2pitals iidows, broken-ogcc over the entrance fanlight, and jolyer.story W1 ,gular over the arched upper-storywindow. omerYi Alabama; 1906. Governor's Mansion; Moses Sabel, CV9 An claboratcty detailed early example, Note the composite ��_..,�_ �itjls on the pilasters and coluinns. These and the arched and Ws are never seen on earlier classical styles, ble windo 1, Jr. Texas; 1933. Lee House. Here the entry porch (or PDrtk-0) haS d into the body of the house; this is known as a portico is (see also Figure 6). A, and Missouri; ca. 1930S. Slender colun-ins, side -gabled roof, ity n5as C, Chippendale railing along the roof -line markChinese irk dsiml�fied 05 as 12(c example. Cticut; ca. igio. An unusual gan-ibrel-roof w Londo"; onnec Mple. The triple wiridows, broken pediment occurring with full- _ t columns) and the curved entry porch widi balustrade all mark mple. j is a Neoclassical r-xa '1vilie, Kentucky; ca. 19jos. This entry porch is both recessed Uof the house and extended outward. Note the keystone the body 11 ovcr tile upper -story windows and three-part lintels over the Liu riple windows and the roof -line batustrade, r-story t WM%ARL ArA PIR Pi Iwo 14 lot R DATE: August 12, 2024 TO: Historic Landmark Commission FROM: Elayna Luckey, Planner I SUBJECT: Request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to construct a circular driveway. FILE: PZ2024-219 STAFF REPORT i a Hollis Read I is requesting a Certificate of Appropriateness to construct a circular dr vew y located at 2240 Ashley Avenue. The circular driveway would tie into the existing driveway and be ten (10 feet wide at its narrowest point and twelve (12) feet wide at its largest point. The home Is listed in the 1990 SPARE Beaurnont Survey as built circa 1938 and classified as a National Folk style home. The recorder noted that ". iding is pulling awayfrom the structure."" The significance of this home is listed as .The house is an example of middle-class housing built in Becrumont in the 1930s. " Planning staff recommends denial of the proposed circle drive as the ordinance discourages parking in front yards. Exhibits are attached, B EA U M► O SIT Planning & Community Development Case Typa:Planning and Zoning Gase Status: REVIEW Case Seri Type'. Certificate of Appropriateness Tag Name: Driveway Case#: PZ2024-219 Initiated On: 7/22/2024 2:25:23PM Location: 2240 ASHLEY AVE, BEAUMONT3 77701 Individuals listed on the record: Appilcant Holiis Read 2240 Ashley st Beaumont, TX 77701 Agent Hollis Read 2240 Ashley st Beaumont, TX 77701 Home Phone- 4093516607 Work Phone. Cell Phone: 4093516607 E-Mail: Readhollis@gmail.corn Home Phone- 4093516607 Work Phone, Cell Phone: 4093516607 E-Mail-, Readholiis@gmaii.coni Property Owner Hollis Read Horne Phone: 4093516607 2240 Ashley st Work Phone: Beaumont, TX 77701 Cell Phone: 4093516607 E-Mail: Read hollis@gmail -corn Reason for Request of a Certificate of Driveway Appropriateness Paint N New Construction N Demo N Fencing N Miscellaneous N Has request been made before? N If yes, date: Notes: This is not a building permit, additional permits may be required for the proposed scope of work. Case Type: Planning and Zoning page 1 of I Printed On: 7124/2024 Case#: PZ2024-219 P "� T° + it.Ft�;'Et 1. +° _yt .. �+y'f i�.y a,, y ml _ , , .. -�, , . ,, • lm� , °+ , , e _ a , l M � - . SURME:Ytto -', 0- k.; I ..--, , , IMM j. J .. C - - . i ` + Yr,{ 1t. 5-,a °s ', +{``1 1 IY ,, '"ti � rp.L L y - 1.. " 4 _ RCc r �' , , ,JII� Wr r""' gyp' II ' tom'*# !� •. ! :.' A.- , , _ -,• M 0 ■ 1R i - "comwmvsw' - InR1 .� 5 ickx . A. , /rr�� r F • - J� ,141;,� Y r�ri . r n q RA . `' _ ° { 'r t## f " # + 4` x i�_ . ' 1 , , F I !. . J - �. tra liri�rr°��' - ; L I + i , ' : r t _ '� ? I. 1 !! " I .. XM g �° fib, � �{� � k° f-'�`�^'kt.'Jl.fe r -�.f ,-I ,:� , „y rr�, ,, i 0 c 4', P '1� '•a ,. .{,J -.� J 9 k` L � � } .r } La2 J' # • • , � ' J',/ 1 a , :._'F �,y� , i a°i. i -+ ,,' f a' i - e _ , - , ` " •F .. r l a �� ■ [ , '+i ,-dlr [.,+,�:kt ta). is r- 'k}?f -1 .'ri r"� -" a J'�1 ° - ; , ..3 r r,1d# 7 +-i,. lI.+i , ,{: rr} ,f _ h-' ;- °; _ L`. _ , R . ?q. .°� rii :yy ,� I, S e! .7 i•,'�,r'-•.r-.ti. k-v .l 'Y`! },, •' �1 t Y� ,1:. Y•-rii s �` 3 1. i'"; e° l, k�•p�♦..r';l=r•J", iri '#4_r�1_°+., ..•4�t �'ti !1' f'y$ a-., "-J,i ° .,.} 'Y - _ , -- 'k' _ 'O tY { '�'1 ,. �, J I . .� R" L •5 .. � e. - .' '� L' �t.. ' .# I - - Y ti1� - r J , V , - " b 1 _ } _ , '� gyp. t ,}- L ti, ,w, y3, + _ -S.� .. °,r •r .f., t, _ +i _ r . - .:. } i + 1, 5 tx+r° ' i m.°. ', =.I'i . .° t. rt ,, + e L I . t •' �° l �j ,�; �,,*# +t'-w'.-s r rM L 1 •i L7 4 ' ° 'I . .- _- . . : . r. tr,. k I i , r 1 i Ts '# + ,.. I ,k. �'.' ^♦.�'ES -! °''.'t, t: 1�_ �.'--.d'. 3: rs..di,#„ - _ ' J,f-. _`f - , L ° + • "} j r _`� ,r - I , - I. I. . . - I 'e . -. , r r,Y,,�[y�,'y[ *°" +g`�'k.�ti ,L "�T : - - , 4` - 1° • ,r'. a} -1* +- - .. LkF 'f } 'Ft ° •'-^ 1°}, - - _ 1 } p . a t �4 '� [.,Y #� . + y n ,. - J .. i '4 s ' r ^ • - - . 1' e - - r ' ', d .. .I , � : I . .r yy g¢ - {t .ti J�+. t �t#ti".!1}y};p r4 .fy'y+, ;k. ,fir I- L: ', ., , , I "fit :1 L �r5k"`°tiih 'f,IRil 'I . + ,9t�' ° `° y'{'J' • , °�� .6.'J ;+ ,tLr h yi 5, ; '! l L ° , _d:, '� y11-'t L #, ' ., # r° �„ t + "' =l ," - �' i '}I +c 1C.� NERILOT 7 t` {'1 I s , _ i." ^, y+ , s y , . + . :,i, ; % P* � o •+ r . ti r # � ti'i ? . 7 , f f/7 „: 1'.''. R , r'~ _ [ L.. - ..1., +,' S'. ". r: �,. . �?' rr#. .:n I ,iw• r k- .yyy '� 1i 1, �1 i fl ! �.� �F �'�, .� p . - , i a+L .-i„yL r 41 . - , f ,',, a�� #■ ; J . 4 a, .'- " { , . y. OMENi , L , 1 i .'.+L ilfr`i'+f5,a•w,. p s ; xr* -r .t i pl.L A rf `II ,y- ~h 5 p ° .. _ ' Yr r , , , -. +9 , r f1. , . t + o j{��•1, A. Y.yr y�yp fI Ap C. ?, q ri t1, fi: ��y}ePALFI i,,g1J E i r� jl#�,tp tL'f s�il� til rF1 +{I•r I a �j .�, 1 4ti p I. 5 i i # ��III ��I::rrr /e Y.y �. . ',. "F 1, I xel * }";� :fLp J I i� L , .%Y '�.r_ d , k-a, h °Y tf{° �, i}. ;i'• ,° .!`'.Y' 'I '_ ..•t= _ - ", ` +Y } . ,. .+•._ _.. , r/ fir ►k�1 _ r. . 'I�"`h. - :r.`7QA 501,00) ■J��, „ - �'° .. _ " ', ++ t , . ,„ , , ' a r� d ,, r"+ , ,.i �`.,�. .t, _##`` d,...'Iy 1. }� 4.1. 1. •. _ , Y f +Y4 °°i .: •1 °1L L _ A,, , - , °1 �°: - i + 'A to } gl,; '}} } # , 3.3'R frr. . :! OWN J* { }. tI I', 3 i.' ' :t`,`; g I P ,i kk k �j r r , . () t , ` 1`!s# ,-, Mkt r"4 .}'"s .k. ',�^f 41Y .tir r'. .�. ,r !s ,l''.9 k a, . r M+ - I ,f•, 1,A I:.i xF�rie -Y}t'� i 5 '7�LF,,..o .�.R''•, #`". f�. ,IT'r i.- -:#+`. 5.�-J't-T+ "r �_ 'y. 'i!•p�',-1= •T{ _ - , - r . , ., t a I w '4 1 ,� ' rf',xi. -y "y. 9'j f Lh. 1J •r t. t 1 7 :I r. - a - , , r ..x -1 0. y i r " + , 1+' , +',-. + - i , , ,11 i . �9 4 Y,F.Ir61f r �+ ��7JI , i ' �- d.-:�, t+�;S,,.._,.s,ey¢;^1'` -$d�i .4 ,,Pl'".. t+ti,_�.' °!�. 'i1'• �/+:191R' ' f , . . . , °-.` 7i rI t t-...7Y. ,alb .It "4L� L 'i �;`k+.' '' '+.'4 ,R'„J{•, I• la''L ,. t{ ;+r',' . L `�y 1'•tj t'r' S•1 i..i'•_�•# k k"E"ui ,; ., 1'i+ �Y' °,+1 �. 14,,,; ir',� • t` , ,,1, A•r , .;�Y1 yI,Tr$' ,/1'1% r,r,-� •-�i +-" - r ° - _! -{ t ,l- i }` h p--.-t i • 'r. ,e'�.-, wk.- v � + j't _# :ix�dl#+'i�4J% .,� yj ±I j;;- h ,�1, , T.It "?e I�ti 4}--v 1 'f '- * ' - 1 { rt, ° r i�r�*, t :'t I� r 9r ! Yd fit: `r�Se.�F ICy ° r:. y �}9i f 'r; ,f Li j`. y 'S .I -F.1L' - I -1 yj} 'ji' 1� j I L , °i [ 'r`i ,r T.' iYF`� " ? {.J` I-< I-:',vk, . i{'t�a Is � 5-- -- � ,. �' T Fi - � � � �+1'y L, ` - • I , 'd r h ir5L... ,+'! t�*I.'"lii' '1.1 4t `' +.lt.g. r.ar�`"P:S `S I�i-A-f',�,y• .:,:ram " - '.r/ .'I'm.,. I 1°iip f , _ J�.R .'. r 1 `' ��Y 4 {,`+. �'�1+ry•. °yr, o -°��" rf,"A r4,F ,'A k %r�1�{;,i >�.1��{i -r5`t '�� - ki. lixrjyi'ITl3 F T w - � +'r A , .} - , 'er.I. rkF,p. ;y °J".,L,.„4tf.+x .¢ #1. .{' _ k•i,Gf-o�S;i �'a }a''#"i s; I,+. ° ,~�i._ i R_' . 5 .. III- - , :. REAMtSr�} +. 'C "•'r •, S`� J , - 174/i hp :r . l+ 11 % ` -r• g � e- , . `tiRl3 ,1'y�_ !'�+� 1�a11/ "ir'f 4 SI.*9 # .n,Ae'L F `1SMY it .. ,. . F Fr.'4 y L4 t y r �„ _ ° ;L L ,% I 'IN I. }}f.� + ��9�y,�Y , =f.L+ . ` r ' 4� 94rY wr �}�! 'fly +y py}{3. � , 0� ��f k F'I) �ioj rr �yJ _ S4+ r� ,li i�� S';,` 17^ 1 .2 ,F�`�' , . - + ' + +Y, . /�n�{* 1y■ #}y J/�y q��' '�l try 4i4y]% 4i R ' 4@��ry1F�{` FJri� �1yF Lk �5►i �i.�, i ; _ _ 7 ,. / �I+ #ifs i'f_ I '#/-, Fr �F'i �� Sr:��'FL I.t a*l _ , �J! 7�JY �'Y! i' t J #'{%s a i.# l ` F+i 4��+ + y t ' r + _ { J •'�.4 ' 7 iJ '+ , mw �Jy PPii i �+,r''*'Fi i�+lY 4{ F,F ` - * % f O 1 , + 5 - . _ ° . t' R I P.# ■ "$$ii +{ i { I 1�7i'� .MM 4'r r 1 x i`} �j a t + t t. " AS , 7.,f iF•i.,. � 7� . f {� i+ y,vu I r� ih�s} 3 !}V " t `tii+` 1 Ay. f R ` x F " - '*i - - ti i' p� 4 '. "4 �svtt "'r1'yY �- ' i. 'r ", 'tp`�. %..SSi' iyf!+, al - {. ,' - , ° _11 +iJ f. J � 1 ' '�f �° Y , L'''I r!.?Y 4 i a, . x - t ti '? N } '`Y** �p 'i., 1 �} .1. 4 f s I L r _ . , , , ° - t 1r r. °P ,s + ?r ,1x, ; a .1 J t k Fp r _ - - ' _ s . + ° i �'.Y.�iR i�a'r f i,ry_ :�1 i�5°�tL.9t"-':; ,ji x,' 1 C ok i2 ++, `,� 1,° - i, ti t C i i R. r5 l pr � `PW OF, ; OM I&W12,�,/ ` }k . 9� -�� s" ,`�.i.' ,t"+ -. S�Aptf YID � - ° I y Y + i , ,9 t „ L h Ba �'Fr . m 4..nr ',44' L r #"�S% i L+S j i KS 4 3 . `' 1 '.5•r� 'r- - 'tY �L '�+*titi: 'a ,. rI+.` S - - , , i . _ ,' - ° _ r - jRiiiMMC � o-`AN rK 0. �1*i LT/'? l f Tr I J, q. M1Ilj%.( + +L.p• r :, ' y , _ . Y } I •M, Y `iy1 j■lam/■ i "F x1ar j f� 1 1 '�I 5 _ + „ . + yi T ,�3 r %. y R ' '7}i• �. _ _ - -I Y , • - t ' t L r , S,1 " • T Y ° 4�I /�1'*� ' ",. 5 r`,. IyjL} ■,qF #F ,�`(-ti iil ��1Y�• ''4!r ,.I - 5 ° -• '+ `�k IQMMw� IVRA r r ; Y. 1 .� i -r �; , ♦ '. 1 � i- p •i +.5 '1 r s - r +i. `a}t . 4i. r +y}41r 0 `f?' ¢ L . S' a t _ s ' +i F .. _ 7 p r � 91YRi+ ,. TO, R-+1 ! _ , �'drf + 1 a J, r'- ;' n i y _ I 1. , L+Fi I�ii ' 9 I P�.. �, '1i k3i F I', i a -�fi- Y t}.'r ! sx�,,,Y ti., �1 t ``;'. L tl' r -' • : .,� 1 :`F� i ° , . i . + r ,. ,. , .,}. 4 r.. ",a .t1.., r'_9� a - " '1x#♦,. °i +■() A r}� 7. +r REr"DE' , L .. 4 - _ . � .. . jKla, I T - . , y "5y -,��M. . 1. I . I . . . . � � , ..,y � � � ,# I lb' r. r' I ,*MPPLI , - i t�' •� J q y i yp L, x� 1 ,- ,+%'• + 5 (�p#x �j1yy'+ �{{�r+ +/y�'� +y .tr4''f , '" L _ 5�+ 4i�-►/S/' rl i+ 5 ° , r ; -r�'i. ` 'R } rR+ 7r# art J-L."% �I, '!� g. � . r° - �e AIqf& }} � {# �t11� • { 1 Y , s_. 4 - y _ y +,,. L'yj117 Jll+''�'ll - /� `7 f,'."I- IF- 7 .+ l , R •, 4. S r �A _d L. %P�r ., Y' , # =+1 I R s -ai"911r i•+ -UNDM ■ CM4 �- 1. `ram 5 .'4 -y , , 1 6 _ 1 - , my �, r�- k 4,1' y- i jS �'al , r+, 'y , I', , ` ' t ' i r 1. a t ii it .. y'._ /.. I ,, e , I%, i,lr �f l - 1 _ 1 iF I ��3 L ' } .'L lR,. -, l'.ti. 11t 1 i , I '4>}'r! i R' _ - + I 1 1 a 5 ; i y�'t a•° i , y Y' 4 ' ± �' 6' ' - `i,.,f' ° R 4 r ' 1 1 t Y • + T r Jr'' " °; , r _ - .. , 4 ' i1 .�� .R.`{.° I I S,' y', L - + _ Fg t" r'e !. ` 1 , 1._ I 1 + ejrJ ■ _ ' I. t i. " � A- + t t . -`,1 ij+ L'J ', P yP J p Y, '+d:a Ar ,1 avF h.•=1, • .+. ,R ; �f' T��--9� 'r 1, -! - , , t y - �-+. -_ ` I - y%' L'+Ml f r f r.# S r Y t' µ' , - ,,'; " , r + _ . - ' *' . r`! I t • r - - �Isr;ts', k°+,1r , I(- P.... r; 'ti i ;-% 0 , if - + + ` •, n ' i , ' K .L% I y . I I ? - _ _ P , � {� �p ., j, L 1 * ovD. 1, - i °L j Y , 4,1 i ~,d''I- _ t' % k. `J.- ,r�,�-.+ F T,h3 * t w r 4 L . t '` -4 . ptip{ ,�d `''� 9 • -0 �:• +-�{ a,1 't+ i%` O 7 Y�Ga i+, ' Y. f ; 1`r ##`! I I . � I I .. I � � . . I .0 " J , 1 li , ,I .1 k' d ' ' , - , i ,� ` i r. P i f v _ _ �. 't, , t ', . , `71 1 J' w jMa r �. IN - . . 1. . - lFjyY � M i 1 t • r PM1 I.'a a - 1- • "f`i. N 1 5I S F I 3if .i' i „ " +y ? s. }} ` % , -. J ,` ''` r L ' , r (Y '$ R - R w , I 6 �' ' J° '+ a "•'r 'Y i + S 1 - `I \ I , i F , � ` ' ► K • 't�9 °ff. F l i Yj +s+ y l �--;+f,-,IJ[°- _i Fr'L� 4i6 L � iL r r' , , -!', P, , .I + f 4 rVfpq rF ?�i`l'1+i - �`, "1 y,. rjra86;#F#�.?1 } �.. ij3. r yr ;, + -- ,#- 5 1, '- / off' +�#},�,�'f p� yxF ,,.1,. .. _,', '1 ' r , 4++1. - * ! L ° •r i L i IFON 'i • f 9 •1. d �,P J f] .. ^ ' .,� I 4 , irtr yr�y,'� }, Y 1 . , e ° } JF R f i' : y, .a�vl•ti,;. Lc�{,. }r�s■ .. ors d•.,`� ,t i„ #�''Cf ° Jr R'�tr+ } , 'f w'."�r,r•�t,,y,-F�a--�.I gyp `- - I r L 1 + ♦15 �1i1 i�" i1,i a'J.�,�R-. ij1 4] .sa, r,. �,14 .. I. l 4+�' L'"} 't. �i S °1 7vr }L,,-,�... �..° i r i+f+i,M e ►- 'i'a. }r •{�iF -T� 7,°11 rik rI _ ° [ ° t r +'S'. L%. _+°,� {' 1 • f. y+1 ; t .f!1 1, •. A, •'4 f ' r f #ti `I�. i t „K � " ' J p . J - , j f, .i� ;max y' p",r L �I^ s -;','y,�}{i }., ��44."'. 4F" +' -;'_ " + I I , it' '¢ .4_ r'} {' aS.'�,^y� .rf 'SM�� 4 a R ° f a i i Jt 7'„ �•r� AY' - i _ , f l t� - " ' , :.1." .F +I 1 ` i d � R ;rf9 ifi �� p ,i4 �? r' - k p 1. • y' � Y? t T �"{. iL{ 1 J i ';,t� 7�' �� x .+('.fd, i FL., _ . ' t 'sr- 5, 1'1` I� r - t ,}•.'i ..r'' Yr- , .i,s �`, `'_ r,a , 1.-,,I-'4}`''JE-.i - , . .{ I. r _ , k, , I+ '+y° 22I t r°. .* ;1.rti F I ��.+. f',,,,`'r+ i 4 `'[i 1'!- °� `'i - SME ,irr�l `iE�'11�7{�{ � f 1 -, � I ' t I ; Y ;q1 ,M.:{' Y� -* '1r'``•4 d f ,_1 -k; , k `1L i 4 ""P } " ti l' i� r} + Ft'.. { p r . p1 R �, t '�'` 1Jq 1 'I:w*:�*p�' } :iF� 1_LL,�`. x' 4 l { S -+r '1'. �'. .ti�g1 f, . - y y r' + r l-.}��}�iL jai `A 4 i i`rS+# 1 5 � �Y'i'° �+ fir'- 1 � `� 1 � y�r}Ye #' t ' S 5 1 , p- ., �yryFlr'jT��`R"' h ' - -2�y k y #S{yY • y �!M,` 7' - 8'r-�. L,•• ,�l •,1s s'„ ' { ' ... ' . 7�■9W■ ■ � ■ a ,�'{��11 'w5, + KK�dt r 'x1''lrT # �I G',4 1 I,f�� l,, % Y i 1 l• l %P- - 1 , - ' 1 # _ a. 1ref 1 P_ #` r{. " iS. �%y r_IY .--' rrtl; f �S ti.1.'# a,t- y, ,i``�r: + iC1 f ' ._ - ll, ,t•�riJe+r}ttS i`:} F`SJ 1a h`��Lma +i $ IT i t , y �' Cyr ''a_U.r S- 1 L �' , t r . 1 • - - - . - - - r 1 `'*+#' air i'i,+ q, �a`ryj ASS°a"�--F.•.` r. 6 - - 4-` • -' L r t {' y r Y 'i.�-_-_��_--.,. _._�___ •____- -__-. _._- .---- �. _ _ _. "- - ." - Wit-1.-a.. r]�Yfs.YF':- i ° isi#-.� �° 7 l Y BEAUMONT, TEXAS HISTORIC SAS INVENTORY FORM - BEAUMONT HISTORICAL LANDMARK COMMISSION JEF 1. County JEFFERSON 5. USGS Quad No. 3094-111 Site No. 618 City/Rurat BEAUMONT I BHT --J 6. Date: Factual Est. c. 1938 2. Name 7Arch i tect/Bui Lder Address 2240 Ashley . Contractor 3. Owner Lee - J. 11. , 77706-2620 S. Style/Type Nationak Folk Address 1795 Hovel k , neaLmnt 9. original Use DOMESTICISin 21e Dwelling 410 Block/Lot Aver itt Lot 19 Block 10 SE 1-3 Present Use VACANT 10. Description: Two story frame structure. Cross gable roof covered with asphalt shingles. Pressboard siding. one Louvered vent in front gable and two pair of one -over -one sash. Main facade has one triple one -over -one sash. Enclosed gable front portico with glass and wood pane[ door and aluminum awning. Brick and cewnt steps. ii. Present Condition Good. —siding- isWLLinq awl from the tr`ucture. 12. Significance: The structure is an example of middle class housing built in Beaumont in the 1930's. 13. Relationship to site: Original, Moved Date (Describe OriginaL Site) 14. Ribtioaraphy 15. informant 16. Recorder S. skarbowski Date 05-31-90 PHOTO DATA Black and White 35 m negative YEAR DRWR ROLL FR. HE ROLL FRHE 90 04 13 to VIEW: RECORDED BY: S. Skarbowski DATE: DATE: August 12-, 2024 TO: Historic Landmark Commission FROM: Elayna Luckey, Planner I SUBJECT: Request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to allow a chain link fence to remain surrounding the property. FILE: PZ2024-225 STAFF REPORT Maria Vizcaino, is requesting a Certificate of Appropriateness to allow a chain -link fence to remain surrounding the property located at 2085 Angelina. Street. The chain -link fence was installed without the benefit of a Certificate of Appropriateness. The chain -link fence is six (6) feet in height, in the front yard, in front of the home and visible from the street right-of-way. Section .28-03.018 ()( (F) of the City of Beaumont Code of Ordinances states., hr wrought iron and' metal fen ces m us t be compa tib le with the style and pe rio d of the main bull ping. Ch clin - lin k, barbed wired and razor wire fences are permitted only in the back yards and must not be visible from any street. // The home is listed in the 1990 SPARE Beaumont Survey as built circa 1940 and classified as a National Folk style home. The significance of this home is listed as ""The house is typical of working-class housing built in the 1920"s and 1930's in Beaumont. It is identical to 2095 Angelina, site #883. "" Staff recommends denial of the request. Exhibits are attached. B EA UM ONT Planning & Community Development Case Type:Planning and Zoning Case Status: REVIEW Case Sub Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Tag Name: Leave chain link fence up Case #: PZ2024-225 Initiated 0 n: 7/23/2024 9.4 3:51 P M Location: 2085 ANGELINA ST, BEAUMONT, 77701 Individuals listed on the record: Applicant Maria Vizcaino 2275 Franklin St Beaumont, TX 77701 Property Owner Home Phone: Work Phone: Cell Phone: 4097827342 E-Mail: Ge.1ovizcaino@ic1oud.co1fl Maria Vizcaino Horne Phone: 2275 Franklin st Work Phone: Beaumont, TX 77701 Cell Phone: 4097827342 E-Mail: Gelovizcaitio@!cloud.com Reason for Request of a Certificate of Appropriateness Paint New Construction Demo Fencing Miscellaneous Has request been made before? If yes, date: Notes.0 Leave chain link fence in place for security purposes. House was broken into several times and house caught fire. The building next to the home has an even taller chain link fence visible from the street. N N N Y N N This fs not abu��ding permit, additional permits maybe required for the proposed scope of work. Case Type: Planning and Zoning Page I of I Case #: PZ2024-225 Printed On: 7125/2024 fig L4 OP if 4r .4p-- /F -or 1,7 tt I IW rA v or rT 0 ilk p Pak or. 0 —At jjF IN JF t j or or dP de T I p 41 EIF MONHISTORICAL LANDMAFIK GOMMISSION AUMONT, TEXAS HISTORIC SRES INVENTORY FORM - BEAU T REF 1. County JEFFERSON 5. USGS Quad No. 3094-111 Site No. 882 City/RuraL BEAUMONT BMT L 6. note: Factual Est. c. 1940 2. Name 7. Arch itect/BuRder Address 2085 AngeLina Contractor 3. owner Durso, Mrs. Al 8. Style/Typo National FoLk Address 1995 Che)CLChase B 2606 9. original Use DOMESTIC /Sin gLe DweLling 4. Block/Lot Park -date Lot 5 Block 22 SE 3-3 Present Use DOMESTIC/Sin Le DweUing. 10. Description: one story frame structure. Square plan with hip roof covered with asphalt shingtes. Exposed raf ters. Two six - over -six sash flanking cent ra i wood panel Moor with shed roof, porticos supported by two wrought iron brackets. Cement steps..' 11 . Present Conditl0r, Fair. The roof is rotted in places. The house needs paint and cosmetic attention. 12. significance: I The house is typicat of working class housing built in the 1920's and 19301s' in Beaumont. It is identical to 2095 Angelina, site # 883. 13. Retationship to Site; Original Moved Date mescribe Original Site) 14. Bibliography 15. informant 16. Recorder S. skarbowski Date 06-20-90 PHOTO DATA Black and White 35 mm negative YEAR DRWR ROLL FR14E ROLL FRNE 90 12 02 to VIEW: ' R�CORDED BY: S. Skarbowski DATE: ... N1. wo Maw 4C