The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutHLC June 2024 Packet* A G EN D A * HISTORIC LANDMARK COMMISSION June 10, 2024 REGULAR MEETING HISTORIC LANDMARK COMMISSION Cou n ci I Cha m bers, CitV H. a 11, 801 Main St. - 3:30 p. rn. *AGENDA* pni i rAi i APPROVAL OF MINUTES Approval of the minutes of the Regular Meeting held May 13, 2024. REGULAR MEETING 1) PZ2024-94: A request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to remove and replace windows and exterior doors. Applicant: Omar Elkhodour Location: 2033 Broadway 2-) PZ2024-122:A request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to resize and replace 109 windows. Applicant: Jose Carrillo Location: 2120 Broadway 3) Historic District Code Enforcement Report OTHER BUSINESS An ir)i i P Kj "To protect, enhance and perpetuate historic landmarks which represent or reflect distinctive and important elements of the City's and State"s architectural, archaeological, cultural, social, econ om ic, e th n 1c and political history are d to develop appropriate se t tin gs for such ploces. "' Persons with disabilities who plan to attend this meeting and who may need auxiliary aids or services are requested to contact Kaltrina Minick at 409-880-3777. HISTORIC LANDMARK COMMISSION Api-il 8, 2024 Council Chambers, City Hall, 801 Main Street, Beaunion t, Texas A Regtilar Meeting of the Historic Landmark Commission was held on April. 8, 2024 and called to order at 332 p.m. with the following men-ibers present: Chairman Dolin LaBiche Commissioner Hester Bell Commissioner John Berube *arrived at 3:34 in Commissioner Cl-tristina Crawford Commissioner Ronald Kelley Commissioner Lynda Kay Makin Commissioner Marva Provo Commissioner Thomas Sigee *arrived at 3:38 pm Commissioner Kirk Thomas Commission Members absent: Commissioner Marty Craig Colim-iissioner Theresa Goodness Commissioner Janelle Templeton Also present: Elayna Luckey, Planner I Jolui Wilson,, Oaks Historic Code Enforcement Officer Susan Smith, Recording Secretary APPROVAL OF MINUTES Commissioner Makin moved to approve the minutes of the Regular Meeting held on March 11, 2024. Commissioner Provo seconded the notion. The motion to approve carried 7:0. Commissioner Berube and Commissioner Sigee not yet present. REGULARR MEETING 1) PZ2024-93-. A request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to remove stucco and replace With siding. Applicant: Tristan Addington Location: 1880 Broadway Street Mrs. Luckey presented the staff report. Tristian Addington requests permission to remove the stucco facade from the apartment complex located at 1880 Broadway Street. He intends to ii-latch Historic Landinark Commission Aptil 8, 2024 the profile of the side of the structure., with four (4) by eight (8) Hardie sheets stackcd vertically. This structure is currently orange tagged for numerous violations of the adopted Intemational Property Maintenance Code (IPMC). The apartment complex is listed in the 1989 SPARE Beaun-lont survey, with its significance listed as "The building is a good exaniple of inicldle class cipartnient buildings constructed in Bectinnont ire the 1920's. " When recorded during the survey notes were made that "The building is structurally so-und, but -uns)i)nI)atheIic cilterations detraclftoin its overall aj.)I)ecirance. " Removal of the stucco and replacement of vertical Hardie siding could eliminate many existing code violations ultimately bringing the structure closer to compliance. Additionally, this could prevent further damage to the interior of the structure and preserve the contributing historic structure. Slides of the subject property were shown. Plan.ning staff recommended approval of the request with the following conditions: 1. All applicable permits and inspections shall be obtained through the Building Codes Department. 2. The "La Belle" insignia on the front of the structure shall be maintained and not ren-toved. 3. The siding shall be painted to an approved color and reviewed by staff prior to application. The applicant was present. "Ilristan Addington of Merrell -Addington Construction, 3235 Michelle Avenue, Vidor, Texas addressed the Coi=ission. He stated that foundation work will be addressed " followed by demolition of the stucco, and then any carpentry Work that needs to be performed. Mr. Addington ftirther stated that several windows will be rcplaccd with like windows and Hardie siding placed on the structure to replicate the current siding. 14C also stated that siding color currently has not been selected. Brief discussion followed concerning the time line for completing the project, ownership of the property, condition of the structure, use of Hardie panel stucco fiber cen-ient. panel siding, and the insignia located on front of the structure. Further discussion was had relating to amending the conditions by adding a condition for the use of 1--lardie panel stucco fiber cement pane siding in fine sand or mounded sand to be used in place of ridged Hardie panel. Commissioner Makin moved to approve the request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to remove stucco and replace with siding, as requested in PZ2024-93, with the following amended conditions: 1. All applicable permits and inspections shall be obtained through the Building Codes Department. 2 i s tori o La nd mark C o m mission April 8, 2024 2. T'he "La Belle" insignia on the front of the structure shall be maintained and not removed. 3. The siding shall be painted to an approved color cmd reviewed by staff prior to application. 4. Hardie panel stern fiber cement pane siding in fine sand or mounded sand to be used in place of ridged Hardie panel. Commissioner Bell seconded the motion. A roll call vote was taken. Chairman Laffiche-Aye; Commissioner Bell -Aye; Commissioner Berube-Aye; Cominissioner Crawford -Aye; Commissioner Kelley -Aye; Commissioner Makin - Aye; Commissioner Provo -Aye; Commissioner Sigee-Aye; Commissioner Thomas -Aye. The motion to approve the request carried 9:0. HISTOMC DISTIUCT CODE ENFORCEMENT RE PORT Officer Wilson presented the Historic District Code Enforcement Report, including information about current violations and inspections. The Commission thanked him for his work in the District. OTHER BUSINESS Brief discussion was had relating to the ordinance for homeless encampments. THERE BEING NO OTHER BUSINESS, THE MEETING WAS ADJOURNED A r Ir 3:59 P*M* DATE: June 10, 2024 TO: Historic Landmark Commission FROM: E|aynaLurke» Planner SUBJECT: Request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to remove and replace windows and exterior doors. FILE: PZ2024'94 STAFF REPORT Ornar Elkhodour, is requesting a Certificate of Appropriateness to keep exterior alterations made to the structure located at 2033 Broadway Street. A stop work order was posted in December 2023 during an inspection when it was noted that, ten (10) or more windows had been removed from the structure, other windows replaced, exterior doors replaced, and additional mechanical, electrical and plumbing work occurred without the benefit ofan approved Certificate ofAppropriateness orbuilding permits. The applicant states the property owner replaced twelve (l2)windows, replaced the exterior doors, sidelights and repainted the exterior of the structure only. Indicating they did not replace siding, foundation or move piers. This home closely aligns with colonial revival style. These homes typically feature large sets of windows and elaborated entries with porch columns and often Porte cocheres. The number of windows removed makes the alteration unsympathetic to the typical features of these homes. This request was tabled on May 13, 2024 due to severe weather that prevented the May Planning staff recommends approval of the request with the following conditions- 1. All applicable permits and inspections shall be obtained through the Building Codes 2. The Individual eight (8) pane wrap around windows shall be reinstalled above the porte Exhibits are attached. BEAV MONT Planning & Community Development Case Type -,Planning and Zoning Case Status: PAY FEES Case Sub Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Tag Name: Replace Windows Case #: PZ2024-94 Initiated On: 3/28/2024 12:42:30PM Location: 2033 BROADWAY ST, BEAUMONT, 77701 Individuals listed on the record: Applicant Omar Elkhodour Home Phone: 7656 Anchor Dr Work Phone: Beaurnont, TX 77642 Cell Phone: 7732093282 E-Mail: Omar8O@nisn.com Agent Omar Elkhodour 7656 Anchor Dr Beaumont, TX 77642 Horne Phone: Work Phone, Cell Phone: 7732093282 E-Mail: Ornar89@msn.com Property Owner Emily Alvarez Home Phone: 2033 Broadway Work Phone: Bearriont, tx 7701 Cell Phone: E-Mail: Reason for Request of a Certificate of replace 12 windows and paint exterior siding, replace doors. Appropriateness Paint y New Construction N Demo N Fencing N Miscellaneous N Has request been made before? N If yes, date: Notes: This is not a building permit, additi 0 onal permits maybe required I for' the proposed scope of work. Case Type: Planning and Zoning Page I of 1 Case #: PZ2024-94 Printed On: 4/4/2024 I It ff f . IV e " r � I M 1. +�„` !1141 , r t- 1 i' 4 s .y i t' �' .1 .• ^'+S #` � � �•I L �x� � � w i• x+ °�". ■`• f .'''' ,A . iq Y - ..�t�� - dw 2r , , ,� * _ • /� i - fir] } • tol 7� , f I•i 1 I ' ■ * 1 1 r t yi��` `- "k''1k' � 1 : ; � '1 iF l s`r.- i. .y�AL-4 � rf il��}■, ��-+# i I 'i � �a+w` 1 � ?, `i �� k �" a k t t r�T+� . kf a}# -` �{J�,�� T�� t .� .�y * �.°� �� • }L '+ i l' qt 41 i ;. "_ aK' � A �' � /y {.'f} jtjr ik ' +1 � � °� I• ti .�� `�r' rf+ r� �xr4r�,•�7,J, ;■ L � � IM1� f -i • .� IM � 'ir f .rR '�. ++r ■� Y �� }-� F Ltlr - � ��+j �"�� F�.. i � ■ � F�'t � ��•} •• to Fy' � t •+a.� f k 9aaP, £� _ i� f� � r I Lr� � 1 � � • ,�tr■ •4��. { +l Y � ce' .`r}''` - s *t _. •+� • 'r t x k } � ; y I a I �' x A' a, �y : rl� i , I�, � .�, � � k �,r � �a� � yT � � � � •,d• {��y��i ��+ � F' +_� ■�F�RY+it� •�� Ala.°�� F Tr Z Pat oil I Nv ip �\ I tee UL i T !, +• f Y I 4 i 'L.y.■.. '.i k "{ .. r4 , 4 •- rr �..*. # or r jr rr i N. r• + ' i4 .' .� 14 ; i 4 k MI5 r.. . Ly w _ . ,' I 1 { I {_ j IF ' A ' '`'"T vp 1y1y{1 ti j f e i r r r. L I ■ '� f III ` � �- +. r' � x•.,�� _,'• 2 rt'+ f 4 I :•fir' Jr I r liter I I ■ %r la 'y 'A PAS 16 # r i� r t IL �� a•bi +ap iT IF t ! A +r . i 4 1 DATE: June lO,2O24 TO: Historic Landmark Commission FROM: BaynaLuckp« Planner SUBJECT: Request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to resize and replace all existing FILE: pZ2024-I22 STAFF REPORT Jose Carrillo, is requesting an amended Certificate of Appropriateness to resize and replace 109 windows on the property at 2120 Broadway Street. The new proposed types of windows will be g mixture ofq/6, 6/6, and 12/6 windows and all of the new windows will be white v|ny|. The existing living room window is 32W x 74H, and the new windows will be two (2) 36W x 72H. The existing kitchen windows are SZ\Nx3GH,and the new windows will betwo (2)3GVVx46H.The existing bedroom windows are 32W x 74H, and the new windows will be 36W x 74H. The existing bathroom windows are 32VVx 36H, and the new windows will be 36VV x 46H. A Certificate of Appropriateness was originally approved by staff in early 2023, when a request to repair the structure came in with the understanding that the windows would be replaced to match. Permits were issued and work began. A stop work order was posted by the Building Codes staff on May 20m, when an inspector notice substantial work being done on the property with expired permits, prompting the applicant tocome lnand renew his application revealing the request to resize the windows once again. This property is not listed in the SPARE Beaumont Survey. Planning staff recornmends approval of the request with the following conditions. 1. All applicable permits and inspections are obtained through the Building Codes Department. Z The new windows be framed and painted to match the existing look of the windows. Exhibits are attached. gEauMaNT Planning & Corwnuiflty Development Case Type:Planning and Zoning Case Status: REVIEW Case Sub Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Tag Name: Changing windows Case #: PZ2024-122 Initiated Onh 4/26/2024 1:44:40PM Location: 2120 BROADWAY ST, BEAUMONT, 77701 Individuals listed on the record.0 Applicant Josh Carfillo 209 Newbridge street Menlo Park, Ca 94025 Property Owner Home Phone- 6506707746 Work Phone: Cell Phone- 6506707746 E-Mail: 2120broadwayllc@gmail.com Jose Carrillo Horne Phone: 209 Newbridge Street Work Phone: Menlo Park, CA 94025 Cell Phone: 650-67-7746 E-Mail: 2120broadwayllc@gmail.com Reason for Request of a Certificate of 109 windows, to be resized and replaced. Appropriateness replacing all windows on the structure with new proposed types of windows. They will be a mixture of 916 6/6 and 12/6 windows. all new windows will be white vinyl Paint New Construction Demo Fencing Miscellaneous Has request been made before? If yes, date: Notes: Existing Living room window is 74H x 32W and new will be 2 windows of 36W x 72H. Quantity 45 Existing Kitchen Window 36H x 32W and new will be 2 windows 46H x 36W Quantity 11 Existing Bedroom window is 74H x 32W and new will be 36W x 74H Quantity 23 Existing bathroom is window is 36H x 32W and new will be 36w x 46H Quantity 11 N N N N N N Case Type: Planning and Zoning Page I of 2 Case #: PZ2024-122 Printed On: 5/3/2024 ' � ,'A PCB Banc 535309 ry; , Grand Prairie, TX 750 3- 3 1 PH: 469- 90-1100 https:l/www.elevatewiiidows.net ORDER ACKNOWLEDGEMENT INVOICE INFORMATION Parker's Building Supply - US LBM, LLC. 7920 Eastex Freeway Beaumont, TX 7770 PH: 409-898-70 0 FX: 409-347-0942 RISER: 276697 ORDER DATE: 411512024 LOAD DATE: 4/29/2024 ORDER CONTACT: SHIPPING INFORMATION Parker's Building Supply R US LB1, LLC,[Parker's Building Supply # 690 R Port Arthur, TX] 2948 Gulfway Cyr, Part Arthur, TX 77642 PH: 40 -9 3-2745 FCC: 4-983-3993 SHIP VIA: Our Truck j+ q - - - •x {-, -, --- 1 - - ... � .it • °,'r }t��r,,�{ d 1 ir'---'-� --- •� _ , ' _ �., • .,� r f-,a{�;kr-��;ap� - - - •yf :}- �1 1 +°l M s ;• .i� ,.t ��t. i'+ _, t; .__ ..... �id+. i' ,`• s� �a rt .. - ,' F' t E: *4 1 !I +� F - '* .. -4 Ii 3.Rk 1 i#�'•, ,r� y js ii 4LX.1..'�'' ise• F 276697 1161 O2a4 407067 Jose � 1� 1NET 30 air:.- '— �e �•. .; INSPIRE-SH INSPIRE VINYL SH 46 36 W X 72 H _ EX, WHITE, L W-E CLILE , ARGON, GRIDS BY SASH, COLS=[2H2V], C LS= [l H2V], C LPAT=[910), HALF SCREEN, SKIP SEPARATE, DP RATING=1 O), FAIR LEAF A E=[O.3], SOLAR HEAT GAIN=[0.2], U-FACTOR=[0.3), VISIBLE TRA]SIITTANCE=[0.4) 2 INSPIRE E VINYL SH 11 36 W X 46 H ._- EX, WHITE, LOW#E CLILE , ARGON, COL=[1H2V], CC LPAT=[6/], HALF SCREEN, SHIP SEPARATE, DP RdATIN = [501, AIR LEdAI A E= [0.31, SOLAR HEAT GAIN=[O.2], U-FACTOR=[0. ], VISIBLE TRANSMITTANCE=[O. O] 3 INSPIRE VINYL SH 1 38 12 W46 EX, WHITE, L W-E CLILE , ARGON, C0L=[1 H2V], COLPAT=[0/ ), HALF SCREEN, SHIP SEPARATE, IMP RATING= [50), AIR LEAS ACE=[3,31, SOLAR HEAT CAIN=[0,2], U-FACTOR=[0.3], VISIBLE TRANSI` ITTAN E=[0.46] INSPIRE VINYL SH 0 35 1/2 W X 46 H EX, WHITE, LOW-E CLILE , ARGON, C L=[l H2V1, C LP.AT=[6i ), HALF SCREEN, SHIP SEPARATE, DP RATING= [0], AIR LEdAKACE=[ t3], SOLAR HEAT GAIN=[9.2], U-FACTO R=[O,3], VISIBLE TRANSMITTANCE=[0.46] INSPIRE VINYL SH 3 35 1/2 W X 74 H EX, WHITE, LOW-E CLILE), ARGON, GRIDS BY SASH, COLS =[3H2Vj, COLS=[l H2V], OLPAT=[l210], HALF SCREEN, SHIP SEPARATE, DP RATING=[), AIR LEAKAE_[O.31, SOLAR HEAT GAIN=[0.1, U-FACTOR=[0,3], VISIBLE TRdANSf ITTANCE=[0.46] 6 INSPIRE VINYL SH 23 36WX74H l C EX, WHITE, LOW-E +CLILE, ARGON, GRIDS B SASH, CLS— [3H21J'], C {BLS.- [ H2V �� LPAT: [12/6 ]4 IIALF SCREED, SHIP SEPARATE, DP RiATINC=[ O), AIR LEAKAGE=[0.3), SOLAR HEAT GAIN=[9. ], U-FACT f=[0.3], VISIBLE TRANSMITTANCE=[0.46) INSPIRE VINYL SH 1 36WX41 H EX, WHITE, L W-E (GULF), ARGON, C L =[1 H2V), C LPAT=[616], HALF SCREEN, SHIP SEPARATE, CAP RATING-- (50], AIR LEAFAGE=[ .3], SOLAR HEAT GAIN=[0.2}, U-FACT R=[0.31, VISIBLE TI AI S 4ITTAI E10. ) INSPIRE VINYL SH 6 36 X 42 H EX, WHITE, L W-E CLILE , ARGON, C L=[IF12V], C LP T^[61 ], HALF SCREEN, SHIP SEPARATE, DP RATING= [50), AIR LEAKAGE=10.31, SOLAR HEAT CAIN=[0i21, U-FACTOR=[0.3], VISIBLE TRANSM.ITTANCE=[0.40) TOTALS: 9 COMMENT: WEB -revised grids SUBTOTAL. TOTAL: 4/3012024 11:421 7 Air I of I