The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutHLC January 2024 Packet* A G E N D A * HISTORIC LANDMARK COMMISSION January 8, 2024 REGULAR MEETING HISTORIC LANDMARK COMMISSION Council Chambers, City Hall, 801 Main St. - 3:30 pe me * AEIIDA * Pni i rai i APPROVAL OF MINUTES Approval of the minutes of the Regular Meeting held December 11, 2023. REGULAR MEETING 1) PZ2.023-467- A request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to construct a new home. Applicant: Jiliverto Lopez Location: 2241 Liberty Avenue 2) PZ2023-486; A request for a Certificate of Demolition to demolish a house. Applicant: City of Beaumont Location: 1032 McFaddin Avenue 3) PZ2023-SC 9:A request for a Certificate of Demolition to demolish a house. Applicant: City of Beaumont Location: 2254 Liberty Avenue 4) PZ2023-510; A request for a Certificate of Demolition to demolish a house. Applicant: City of Beaumont Location: 2229 Liberty Avenue 5) Historic District Code Enforcement Report OTHER BUSINESS an ini ipKi "To protect., enhance and perpetuate historic landmorks which represent or reflect distinctive and important elements of the City's and State"s architectural, archaeological, cultural, social, economic, ethnic an d political history an d to develop appropriate settings for su ch places. Persons with disabilities who plan to attend this meeting and who may need auxiliary aids or services are requested to contact Kaltrina Minick at 409-880-3777. MINUTE Sk HISTORIC LANDMARK COMMISSION December 11, 2023 Council Chambers, City Hall, 801 Main Street, Beauniont, Texas A Regular Meeting of the Historic Landmark Commission was held on December 11, 2023 and called to order at 3 -.3 2 p.m. wi t 1i t lie fol I owing men -lb ers present: Chairman Dolin, LaBiche Com.niissioner Yolanda Nan Avery Commissioner Hester Bell Commissioner John Berubc Commissioncr Marty Craig Commissioner Theresa Goodness Commissioner Ronald Kelley Commissioner Marva Provo *arrived at 3:38 pin Commissioner Thomas Sigee Commission Members absent: Commissioner Christina Crawford Commissioner Lynda Kay Makin Conu-nissioner Janelle Templeton Also present: Elayna Luckey, Planiier I Susan Smith-, Recording Secretary John Wilson, Oaks Historic Code Enforcement Officer APPROVAL OF MINUTES Commissioner Goodness moved to approve the minutes of the Regular Meeting held on November 13, 2023. Conuuissioner Sigee seconded the motion. "I"he motion to approve carried 8:0. Com.niissioner Provo not yet present. RE, GULAR MEETING 1) PZ2023-46.1-0 A request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to remove a chininey. Applicant: Cornell Price Location: 2490 Liberty Avenue Mrs. Luckey presented the staff report. Alicia Gudino of Straight and'Narrow Foundation on behalf of property owner Donna Kay Ware, is requesting a Certificate of Appropriateness to remove the brick chimney and replace it with like siding on the home located at 2420 McFaddin Avenue. Historic Landmark Comniissioii December I I, 2023 The request comes as a part of a list of repairs being inade to the property. "I'lie home seemingly identifies with prairie architecture most if not a] I examples provided by A Ffield Guicle to A inerican Houses, include bricked chimneys featured on these structures. Examples of the prairie details can be reviewed in A Field Guicle to American use, (McAlester et al., pgs. 448-45 1). rl'he property is not listed in the SPARE Beatiniojit Survey. Slides of the subject property Nvere shown. Plan.ning staff recommended denial of the request The property owner was present. Domia Ware, 2420 McFaddin Street, Ialiniont, Texas addressed the Commission. She stated that the home is being renovated and the fireplace/chimney are not functional. Ms. Ware further stated that the home has a gas beaten and the fireplace is unnecessary. She also stated that significant damage to the home is causing water leaks, including on either side of the fireplace. Ms. Ware explained that bricks are falling o,ffthe chimney and the house is sagging three inches on either side of the chimney. She further stated that the leveling company will not level the home until the chitailicy is removed. Ms. Ware also stated that siding will replace the chin-iney if approved for reinoval. Further discussion followed concerning maintaining the interior mantle and bricks, installation of a faux brick facade, removal of the second chimney located in the house, placement of siding that will replace the ebininey, replacement of windows near the fireplace, and the architectural design of the home in relation to aesthetics of the chimney. Commissioner Bell moved to approve the request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to remove a chimney and replace it with like siding, as requested in PZ2023-461. Commissioner Sigee seconded the motion. A roll call vote was taken. Chairman LaBiclie-Nay; Commissioner Avery -Aye: Commissioner Bell -Aye; Commissioner Berube-Nay; Commissioner Craig -Nay; Commissioner Goodness -Nay; Commissioner Kellcy-Aye; Commissioner Provo -Aye; Commissioner Sigee-Aye. The motion to approve the request carried 5:4. HISTORIC DISTRICT CODE ENFORCEMENT REPO T Mr. Wilson presented the historic District Code Enforcement Report. OTHER BUSINESS None. N Historic Landmark Commission December I 1., 2023 THERE BEING NO OTHER BUSINESS, THE MEETING WAS ADJOURNED AT 3:50 PIM, DATE: January 8, 2024 TO: Historic Landmark Commission FROM: BaynaLud/e» Planner SUBJECT: Arequest for aCertificate ofAppropriateness toconstruct anew home. FILE' PZ2023'467 STAFF REPORT Ji1iverto Lopez has requested a Certificate of Appropriateness for the construction of a new home to be located on the vacant lot at 2241 Liberty Avenue. The proposed home will be approximately 1633 sq. ft. in size. The construction methods employed would dictate that the house is to be constructed on a slab foundation with Hardie Plank siding and the windows will be six (6) over one (1) in appearance. The roof will have a l' overhang with the pitch rising six (6) inches each twelve (12) inches horizontal distance. Additionally, the roof will be 30year architectural shingles in Shasta White. Lastly, the porch co|unmn}stobeatapered craftsman style column. The front door will beecraftsman style door with ahalf light. The exterior body paint is to be Sherwin Williams Needlepoint Navy, the Gable is to be Sherwin Williams Colonial Revival Tan and the trim is to be Sherwin Williams White. Planning staff recommends approval of the request with the following conditions- 1. All necessary permits and inspections are obtained through the Building Codes Department. 2. The finished floor elevation shall be 24" above the existing grade. Exhibits are attached. B EAV N1O NT Planning & Community Development Case Type:Planning and Zoning Case Status: REVIEW Casa Sub Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Tag Name: Certificate of Appropriateness Case #: PZ2023-467 Initiated On: 10123/2023 2-,08:47PM Location: 2241 LIBERTY AVE, BEAUMONT, 77701 Individuals listed on the record: Applicant Jiliverto Lopez Home Phone, Missing Address, City, State, or Zip Code in People Work Phone: Cell Phone* 346-812-4287 E-Mail: Elprotx @gmail.com Property Owner Jiliverto Lopez Home Phone: Missing Address , City, State, or Zip Code in People Work Phone: Cell Phone: E-Mail: Reason for Request of a Certificate of Build new Single Family for in a historic district Appropriateness Paint N New Construction y Demo N Fencing N Miscellaneous N Has request been made before? N If yes, date: Notes.- This is not a building permit, additional permits may be required for the proposed scope of work. Case Type: Planning and Zoning Page 1 of 1 Case M PZ2023-467 Printed On, 1215/2023 November Zl.2O23 RE: 2241 Liberty Ave — Certificate of Appropriateness To VVhorn It May Concern: This ismyrequest for aCertificate ofAppropriateness. iornlooking tobuild anew home atthe location of224ILiberty Ave,Beaumont. This isan empty lot right now and is in the Historic District. | believe this new home will beanadded benefit tothe neighborhood. The following isalist ofthe materials that | will beusing onthe new home: It will be a stick frame home, m/ithJarnes Hardie siding. The roof material will be 30year Architect shingles and the windows will beR/lLovv-Eenergy efficient. The paint colors I have chosen are from the Sherwin Williams Historic Collection: Siding Color: 3VVO032 Needlepoint Navy Gable Color: SVV2828 Colonial Revival Tan Front Door Color: SVV2865 Classical Yellow Trim: White | have attached samples ofcolors. | appreciate the opportunity tobeable tobuild this home. Please donot hesitate tocontact nmeifyou have any questions. ]i|kerboLopez 846-812-4287 ;m 0 Z Cl) X m m r� rn R f- m m r- m 0 Z N PAPI, m r- m 0 Z N 0 -Z m I— m 0 Z j7 QOyyB�0,4P < w Ilk, LUE) E3 U[ M �Swerto Lopez Family i; 5 2 t r Ell] ' 4t PA ;:n House 0 r TO: Historic Landmark Commission FROM: BaynoLurke« Planner SUB[ECT: A request for a Certificate of Demolition to demolish a house. FILE: PZ2023-486 STAFF REPORT Boyd Meier, Building Official, requests a Certificate of Demolition for the house located at 1032 K4cFadd1nAvenue. According to the inspection report, this structure was originally tagged on June 1Z.2O23. The stairs to the structure are collapsing along with the ceiling in several rooms. There are a number of broken windows on the structure where the frames have rotted. The structure attracts transients and stray animals. The property is listed in the 1977 SPARE Beaumont Survey and included in a local Historic Cultural Designation; however, the structure originally listed at this location was the Byrd Horne, which was demolished in 20I1 with approval from the Historic Landmark Commission. The structure there today was not included in those designations, just the land from the legal Based on the extensive repairs needed for this structure the Building [odes Staff is recornmend ingaraze order andhas received consent todernoUshthestructurebythe property owner. Planning staff recornmends approval of this request. PUBLIC NOTIFICATION Notices mailed to property owners 16 . Responses in Favor . Responses in Opposition Exhibits are attached. B EAV MO NT Planning & Community Development Case Type:Planning and Zoning Case Status: REVIEW Case Sub Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Tag Name: Case #: PZ2023-486 Initiated On: 11/3012023 4-42:13PM Location: 1032 MCFADDIN AVE, BEAUMONT, TX Individuals listed on the record: Applicant CITY OF BEAUMONT Home Phone: DEL NC WOOD Work Phone: 409-880-3762 801 MAIN ST Cell Phone: BEAUMONT, TX 77701 E-Mail: Reason for Request of a Certificate of Appropriateness Paint New Construction Demo Fencing Miscellaneous Has request been made before? If yes, date: Notes: DEMOLITION CONSENT SIGNED BY OWNER. CITY OF B EAU M ONT TO D EM OLlSH THE STRUCTURE. N N y N N N This is not a building permit, additional permits may be required for the proposed scope of work. Case Type: Planning and Zoning Page I of I Case 4: PZ2023-486 Printed On: 12/1/2023 SUBSTANDARD BUILDING INSPECTION REPORT BUILDING CODES DIVISION CITY OF BEAUMONT ADDRE SS OF STRUCTURE: 1032 MCFADDIN OWNER: GLENN EDWARD BYRD OWNER ADDItE SS: 116 2 ND AVE NEDERLAND9 TX 77627 TAXES OWED: S-0.00 Market Value: $18�698.00 Fire daniaged.9. NO Property was Red Tagged on: 06/12/2023 DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY: The owner has signed a demolition consent for tyre of Beaumont to demolish it. The siding.is falling off on the right side. The stairs are eollapsing goipg up to the entrance, There are homeless people going in and out of it and steeping -In it. The ceilinLy has collapsed in several roonis. The are around 50 stra cats living in or around the house. The windows are broken and the frames are rotten. The electrical an lumbing will have to be replaced. Based on the extensive repairs needed in this structurstaff is recoinniending_a raze order for this structure. Tile reinspection was -completed on 11/29/2023. I jj i 11 ,.• I s r t ffj F i IF rF r , r j, I 11 w4 , rlki T. # a vk +" 4 _ j j y f I r1�w 01lk '� # i�► r� sa�� '� r h. s."� r L 1 A rf� "I'■ *'�f� �' �f �� ` i� ':� _ a 7 � iya x q� •■ 14 a k rv. .`•e•s �► i� � # r r'yI h � tk � y• rya • rF f, L . t,jSIY a lit y ,� �, R,� �^.■"�,�-r,,� �'� ,} � Y 1 ,T• *� _ y. �` _ 6a r . �• f " ''� ', ,f17 , k Lki,{Y' •Fe 1 a L` 0.. 1 3..r•.p L �. - ■ �•a • a_ �.r ` -.�; - f -r!'• �_ * - ' ter•' 3f." a' at %'. e `- •�.- i �'�. ,' ,F Tlb Vie; w *•��,F�_�,rR�+��.� ]!'• t� + ..a- �: �-. �� ,*.�- e.#� ,h .ta -} 'f„�a Y'�� _ � ■� qw— .�'Via+ r IT S +y MA i�4[k 1'rt � ."7�. ► _ �r .�� ' � ka,�af �; �.,r.�� 1�� . Al k if Ffl#.a" Fr s,,��5 ddL "� y � + � � r � � � �L �� ra i a' `s �' '-• � •'., � _� _`,t ,.� i y J. `�4► � $+ ';� �� 4 � � � '� •``�'`` � � �` +. "'�*`. , �t � d a, " "+'A4'k;s' J+b 3 r9 t. +'■ ■ ' fir 7 ./ } 5 ➢ } {, Y s IF all f r y•.>r NILI IL -�. f ■+. PL FA 0 qL Mp }_ �' �� e5 • r �� a'. Fw � •� �+t� gliL � , 'S�+"I{� � � 6' ",�y, 1�, � �, i k _ ,fir 7 • �• �rJl de - �-•�4wk� +�� .�i:i�' + #- S+� ,��~ :#,may r •�*' � �"s.L�F� # �-�� :�.- �,` "�. .F a ,fir - 'ar,' 1 •. { • ;. y ; r } _ L 'I r' ;�- } IF At A r# : *, � . �YL �■�i+I-�a a � . � tl�i' � {� �. t - "a� f-' t t e +�'I _ �lLy_ �' � 5 i +�, r r �I��„i7�A3f� `• �� ^r� ry� + LL P T•"� *�,� d � � +'14J jy f�',.FL { e'�+� I � 4�' �*'. �� - � - y +. fir. � • �� : aF �'a . #'*' w ' - •�� ' � • ��' r y - i }' .rl ',�'�i ek.. �$ s p '^�� r^ � a rJ - a. r,�''�". � w � ; � �' tir'r ti*...; ' f r • � / I r' * �i I �� f� a "a k z5 �-'� • -k i` ^� } ' '14 •k + • a 7r�1 , e J F �,� • 7■'� �r - e� + �,rj �' I � R _ ., ,� 'w J • s 3 � , ; { + � q I 1 Y� 5 F �_ � , t 1 Y i•t '� r .fi R#�� t ,�[, `o{s_-•_ a ,,,.• A. 'i 1 _,�, i �L��{a�y�fw ' SFJ� f�- *� �� r''#i �,,�1�■��r.P 4r� J"'-��, - r �, ,. �' '4 �� , y i 6 4 lk lk ip J� ��{r #%F��., �-��_- �`f�■.■._k��„r.. +—�14k�-„�,�.:, �""..y _d;�_ ' � -f h �.. - _,..�['�'g�.;�y�.+5'- ,� �, }. e r ' , Z.J �, � '''i �4r ��.� �� + . i _ a ` ,.+ 1 +� .t J `''• rti"" fly* i�`[ S�','� " y s _ b * •� , ` i - + .i'•" f+f F^.� r I tiT� -a+�IL ?I 5 .� �! ` il` •, - �}` h .. . _ " , " y `f� � 1* ■ �.' •. rJ4fl rF � � , ,f �� {y _ '�� . °• -rJ - , .� -� 7' � , , e ..� _" �-,� •+ h ��"�h, . < .a - - -�■ r �„ .�.•� �* ,� � 1 w � � ,� ��r�., .. '�.} .�'� try � _ ,, r f� r�. �, ,'�wy �`�,#� �,'��rf■' � � r,. �+ " _ R �'i' J' } � �e,w�.�. I/[ ,.7# � ' s ,° f ' S e S� . ,�_ �i. _ +, , -s ++ i ' �r t. ��1�49� ' ��. /-:.` ■ "�' �,�`�`��}} a',i* � 1 � e I •`.5J k ' ` f , � arl � J+, h F_ a •� •� :� _ : s= , .*`° " x` M .A , ��' , r i3 5 'F dn h . f A. IL Ilk IkF e v_ �� '�� , ' is #�#, . �► , ,i,� � �-� ' A f jjy f S\ ti rt k Y � • 1 4 -oar* ilk AM 40 dt "Mo-molm" ov T. sir 3 °. 1 - `-` LeG�c„_ fii`4•�° Fr *i... J -�91_;j JJ .r F { •- � L �. ' _ _ "mod ■ '. ; at �. �" 'r. rr f,F " 1 �/ . I' y 7' n ' ♦ .r. - ,e � �. twit �.� �•.. e , y- + s fil ry •..i::` it , r y y +_r Of f .1All + _ `Ile TP IF , a , to , A • - •` { A �' 1, 4�* .� a F � ✓' i , ` h4T Y' +' a A � • �� 7y • _ Y , t yy a + R 1 + a,►.�� -A rNff FF - . t}j� 1 7 Yam•+'r� *}3 {�j.f+ �1} czy , �- 33 R a� t r yLy a#L +1 ',. rl'..1' ,. all �.� �� i 1 `. I. _i 'i �� 5�i'� 4 *' � '�i �� •� �� .i ��, f } � `�� 1i . 4 C " 1�' i ,"� r i4�141' ,A � , ''y�� .r �� #• y�.�.��+1 (+�� '�i ��.��R e� �* � r .,F�. 11 , � fN / '1i"`.'/T4Fo t # � iirr • .� i+{,J` 4+ + r 1 i •?'� � 1 +}�k `1'a "� IY�I ItiM1 � v. '"� -'� �ji�'�`�i��tl� ie•' �� ya (.� 1 � [��„FFti li 9�� ia�� j�, • � 4 e u, ,�, _ • �K�j �,: �, r�,� �i�{i �.a .' � ++� � r � �►,.� � � i,�+��i�r i + i. l 'r` "i?I� -A'i 't,['. �_ e?A\,. - jaiti'Iy}� Wes•' • `�'. F' .�� 4.}1 , 17 + 4 �L{ + i �.4.41 r•ai ? �1 �`.�,S�k� # �,�• +;Jl Fr R i�+ e � j�,A�J�`�-� � r F , *+`{��' ��•' '{��.. �. '. -f}yr� -A r,�..'. * {„ l �, 4 f. : �1r 4..1Jy '4r�•�'rl ' A i. e.++5.'a3� 7 s #T 'k 5,,rP•',,'; .: A�p Ilk C �il►ry�"R.. fi F{+• °` �' ,', t �, q _ �`, ` �` rem' ` It. 1 f'Y l ti �y 4+�1 r �d . � �51i4P j� S' � • J � � ,y�, k�'�a r k � Ry} .•s�� 16 pk ,5 eS. ti �}yi� }`l'ri,T t, .. � ,� ' M1I{ . f{y�(. .' •' L {ie� �lt� 9 e _} leis ¢. 1• T'e�i`} i ! a a �° •. _,� ,� I k� 1 .1. F ,�}+ of •+. ', !f-A'yS {"4�•`! f x +y ~ e Jr ,..*'.'S i l tip+ P f�k"e4 _ Ste* `�'_ 'ter � � .* k. 1 • it Sill! 4 i R l a ' , .� ,!}� 3a+. . fy4, r r ,� 5� ' s ttfr4�� Ik -r r_�• '� .#' �!#$FN ryf� *� �- tr 4 jk��t ` • +�� a��+ r r r y,Ya• ` � a }_�# IX 7 y Ir � A � ' . � e �. � �.�17 J y�1{i%Y.� 4• +'. yS i }-.� � 1,�` � �,,,r . 'PAY. • � � 'si `'� 0- I _ f • 1 � ?' R 4 4 ? � °-J )" ��_ � x' kp � � yr^7' , ' `� iA!4�. •a f . � � �� '{,i r# Y y x�•4 �.. ,ti., i e . � � kk , •i') 1�1�•f#.. qSy� ■,,� ♦,•; �F F�$. •� - _ ` ', # j h t ` "F, j � a 4" f i '. 4 y ►,y ° : � • 1 A% iY" ?�1�� " +_-s4 f d'e•� '' i JyL,' a�y� yit "� - - rY J • 4 atl'•.+„ �1 - i1 1 R f F 4- Alp JAW zM _ _ r • `.1 i Y. , t MW. - l _ y a� 0.} , E - , .' _ram: � . - �� + •" � � - __ , . 3� ',."` jJ R-�q� y , _ r ;l%.) troof, f f I .-�'�-11~+ , _ - , � '- , : �f y.. � �� T '" � i _ F . # �°� � , � Jjl i. �. yy r. ,f � I � • _ 5 _ - � �� + DATE: January 8, 2024 TO: Historic Landmark Commission FROM: BaynaLuckey, Planner | SU50ECT: Arequest for aCertificate ofDemolition todemolish ahouse. FILE: PZ2023-509 STAFF REPORT Boyd Meier, Building Official, requests aCertificate ofDemolition for the house located at 2254 Liberty Avenue. According to the inspection report,, this structure was originally tagged on February 10. 2021 after it received darnoge from a fire. The property owner initiated a work program onApril 3[i2O2laiwhich time they secured the property and replaced the windows; however no additional work has taken place since an inspection dated October 4, 2021. The property is listed in the 1989 SPARE Beaumont Survey and was built circa 1925. The significance ofthe structure was listed as"7hehouse /s representativemFthe/oco/od«ntutionnF the Craftsmanstyle and oflarger middle-closshomes built in Beaumont during the first decades of the century.," Additionally, the condition at the time of recordation was listed on the SPARE Survey as "Fu/r. The house isstructurally sound but not particularly we/l-maintained Unsympathetic cilterations detractfrn/nits architectural integrity."' Based on the extensive repairs needed for this structure and the lack of repairs made in the past two years, the Building Codes Staff is recommending a raze order. Planning staff recommends approval of this request. PUBLIC NOTWICATION Notices mailed toproperty owners _33_' Responses |nFavor ______ Responses inOpposition ______ Exhibits are attached. B UMO. NT EA... Planning & Community Development Case Type:Planning and Zoning Case Status: REVIEW Case Sub Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Tag Name: Location: 2254LIBERTY AVE, BEAUMONT 77701 Individuals listed on the record: Applicant CITY OF8EAUMONT Home Phone: OELANCY\NOoo Work Phone* 801 MA|N8T Cell Phone: BEAUMONT.TX777U1 E-Mail: Reason for Request ofaCertificate uy CITY WANTS TODEMOLISH THE PROPERTY Appropriateness Paint N Now Construction N Fencing N n0(soa{anooua w Has request been made before? N If yes, date: This is �� 0ibuildingpermit,�� permits��a�' U�(� __-- .. ~ required for the proposed scope of work. Case Type: Planning and Zoning Page 1of1 Case #:pZ0000-5on Printed On: 12/1s/2o2o SUBSTANDARD BUILDING INSPECTION REPORT ADDRE, SS OF STRUCTUI�: OWNER: OWNER ADDR-E SS: Taxes Owed: Market Value: Fire damaged.? Property was Red'*Tagged on: BtALDING CODES DIVISION CITY OF BEAUMONT 2254 LIBERTY ANDRE S RODIUGUEZ LOPEZ 11 RUTH ST BEAUMONT, TX 77707 Owner enrolled in Pre -Council Work Program? $5,381.85,00 $44,727-00 YES 02/10/2021 YES DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY: This structure was brouplit to HLC on 03/14/2022 for demolition but was denied. No work has been done since 03/14/2022. The taxes have not been paid since 01/22/2021 by the previous owner. The owner signed up for a ivork program allowina 150 days to make the repairs and no work was done except a few windows beiniz replaced. The rotting siding and missing siding will need to be replaced,. Some windows have been r reed but there are still some that have not been replaced. The structure is secure but there are exposed electrical wires. Based on the extensive re airs needed in this structure staff is recommending a raze order for this structure. SEE ATTACHED PHOTOS OD S. CD co r 19 co C) 4L ba Rik g h t rx •� � � t fl 5 1� X MA 5 i Milk Mill Rd 4 r r 4 / " �e .'.lI r � I i' rr 1 s t 1 � f1 ;• 4 �L G fiiiLL• 1�1 � � jlf�� _--- r� r IL i a t IL If -RI h' L lk � � r tie s 4' air ir Ll a 4 • 1 + * a r 1 a � d_ _ +, 1 .I 11 L �' • -OL I r 51. 74 f 1 'i r - s '• Fit } •_ • � - ,� �' ,d '-{ _1'S - - �{ 11 �' y +y,$[(��. Rye': '4 �sw— is }jI f d' r'�. �• -ria \554*4"°•• - ar ��1 diL 1.�.7 ��., ,. 3:t� ��. 4 - y k'�" ` rt r ra'' _ �•'irtrs_.__ d �. -TR r _ � M v � ; � ... Y � i �. Y.-► * • a y�� 47{ J 1 a # e �- , � f= �} 4r,i �9{ e. _ Y� k +ti 1Sk 'C}IT% ryj}i# -rpm I OL ,yam.. r1'a"�+ •�+ d_ a.+L�'S�}�fr---' P� � ,►'cam a ,t Z47A lit ge co � }` •� tali. �`y� {r �, ! S — M 1•s � -iYh + l '� ir -,- p C loll NIX o �fi•`''r'�+ �� rJ .� ar f r , ` . �,P'' a i 1' �'*.. — J' 1' , f rF-: BEAUMONT, TEXAS HISTORIC SITES INVENTORY FORM - BEAUMONT HWORICAL LANDMARK COMMISSION JEF 1 county JEFFERSON 5. USGS Quad No. 3094-ill Site No. 452 city/Rurat BEAUMONT BMT 6. Date: Factual Est. c. 1925 2. Name Address 2254 Liberty T. Architect/Builder Contractor 3. owner Wendt Arne y Lee Jr. 8. Styte/Type Craftsman Address 5112 Port Arthur Rd. Beaumont, TX 77705 9. Original Use DOMESTIC/Single Dwel.Ling 4. Eock/Lot Aver ilL Lot 20 Bloc k 2 SE 2-3 Present Use DOMEST ICZSingLe OweLting 10. Description: Two- story frame front -facing plan with cross h 11 pped to Le roof, exposed roof rafters. Two symmt r i ca L Ly spaced paris of nine -over -one sash on second story of projecting front bay. Hipped full -width h porch with asphalt shingle roof, plain, square vernacular columns, brick steps. Projecting centrat wooden door between two recessed nine - over -one sash. Windows on second story of projecting side bay have been removed and the opening framed in. Triple nine -over -one sash are on the first story of the side bay. Fared skirting. Vernacular porte cochere. 11. Present Condition Fair. The house is structuraLty sound, but not particuLarLy wet.1-maintained. Unsympathetic alterations detract from its architectural. integriV. 12. Significance: The house is representative of the locaL adaptation of the Craftsman style and of Larger middle class homes built in Beaumont durin4 the first decades of the century. 13. Relationship to Site: OriginaL Moved Date 14. Bibliography 15. Informant M. Recorder (Describe Original Site) D. Hush PHOTO DATA BLack and White 35 rim negative MR DRWR ROLL FRME ROLL FRNE 89 15 06 to Wf Date 08-07-89 VIEW: RECORDED BY: D. Bush DATE' DATE: January 8,2024 TO: Historic Landmark Commission FROM. E|aynaLurkp» Planner G^.50EC_: /\ request for a Certificate of Demolition to demolish a house. F|LE: PZ2023-510 STAFF REPORT Boyd Meier, Building Official, requests a Certificate of Demolition for the house located at 2229 Liberty Avenue. According to the inspection report, this structure was originally tagged on September 27, 2021 after rnuLdp|e code violations were discovered. The foundation is collapsing, a full roof replacement will be needed, and the eaves are falling due to rot. The property is listed in the 1989 SPARE Beaumont Survey and was built circa 1915. The significance ofthe structure was listed as"Thehouse bogood example nfolocal adaptation nf the Craftsman style and is representative of middle class homes built in Beaumont during the early decades of the century." Based on the extensive repairs needed for this structure the Building Codes Staff is recommending approval of the raze order. Planning staff recommends approval of this request. PUBLIC NOTIFICATION Notices mailed toproperty owners _27_, Exhibits are attached. BEAUMONT Planning & Community Development Case Type:Planning and Zoning Case Status: REVIEW Case Sub Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Tag Name: Case #: PZ2023-510 Initiated On: 12/18/2023 2:13:28PM Location: 2229 LIBERTY AVE, BEAMT, 77701 Individuals listed on the record: Applicant CITY OF BEAUMONT Home Phone: DELANCY WOOD Work Phone: 801 MAIN Cell Phone: BEAUMONT, TX 77701 E-Mail: Reason for Request of a Certificate of Appropriateness Paint New Construction Demo Fencing Miscellaneous Has request been made before? if yes, date: Notes: CITY OF BEAUMONT WANTS TO DEMOLISH THE STRUCTURE N N y N N N 16 This is not a building permit, additional permits may be required for the proposed scope of work. Case Type: Planning and Zoning Page 1 of 1 Case#: PZ2023-51 0 Printed On: 12/18/2023 SUBSTANDARD BUILDING INSPECTION REPORT BUILDING CODES DIVISION CITY OF BEAUMONT ADDRESS OF STRUCTURE: OWNER: OWNER ADDRE, SS: Taxes Owed: Market Value: Fire damaged? Property was Red Tagged on: 2229 LIBEWYY JOHN R. ANTHONY 2229 LIBERTY BEAUMONT, TX 77701 Owner enrolled in Pre -Council Work Program? $179997.50 $48528S.0,0 QTC 09/27/2021 NO DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY:, The foundation has collapsed in a fe-sv areas. The roof will need to be replaced. The windows are broli-en and the frams s are rotten. The eaves are failing because they are rotten. The electrical will need to be replaced. Based on the 4 extensive repairs needed in this structure, staff is recommending a raze order for this structure. SEE ATTACHED PHOTOS 1 F , • 1 4 , k � ti Tkq idl— IL IN .-0 3 F Y a f t{rAL R i ! f • ' k i + ,! a .. % r # - led If 7. r ice_ v - 'V L _ _ w. y w ' 4 , d y a �w �' - � � ] � � - • � � �- - w f S:Ff TF ; �� _� k��`�;'w+ ;� `ram i=j•. t n�• i1�'��- L IN +-,... a• - •lye ! + ,�` ' �y/ k L '�'4,ti�r�.e},"+.7,, f .. - Y �y}� i'tjr _£+�{�a-'�-fi . i 3� .a•� _ 4' ' r•., �,' w■ 1 { • - 7"�.'; _ t r • �, ti .-�, L ; •G# .'+.� �!ti _1 '4_ T •..._ir X .fit _' f+Li,/ f ,t•� ■. 'r ■� •'z .yaz_.C=w -- - Y - iK. y } r am , '* ■ i klyl L,' ey 'b► , ■. :y` - :�: �■ r _ -i E� o' r "r 49 :l- 1 _ '. 1't r i4's ^ `• •. 4, . , ■ xa-' .I # �rk a€ t '� 4 L - ;�� '• k J }�L4 y�\ R�ii��F` i e� a }1 �� q M1 % ' ■ } Y -� 3 J 7- 7 _ t ^ t _ ti - f t amp TL rzd t r °r � � r _ � w�� . r _�" ;: r �" d�r .� .l ,fir +"� '`i� ��w■ � � �a i "'• .'f.'x•` - #� f 1"'�.. {t��t `4�. ��i f'M.P + �. A.� tS' - � i,� jr,�S� _}fir* •�} �y�: "ALL � Y - �' .+ASS r� y� � '�. � .�'� y-L Ir y#p+�. � `� '4� +�.! � � ,,■Y��e� 1 U 9� 4 ��i � � y� L11 r �fI r# �kR 11� F'. S- •f'�... �.'•'! _ • �{fJ. -•' if S 1G T� 1 • y / y r_�1�1 .l .,Y`._, `�{ '.•. `'�* 3'4 i' fw �f+.LIZn' f= . 1 f _ � ��e j . �� Tit �'_ ' � . � � • ,�� ";.��{�� .~- � � f �-:* - P IS I.4 yr �,`,�° • '.� 1. PIL` .,. F h,��; ' rr I• aIt .f r .v v 9 _ ' 7' � r I f 1r ' Y`■ ` rr - •5' F r- - '-� }�'• i 't�i°�.. �� I/ i + �- � �^ ` F a �r ` Y - i - , t i If X A If -_ _..If_ Fl�e�,.a�.��-r' r- °it ..�' i -�t � i '�_ I y1 r _ ,+f• , � I j ,r - Y �+++: II I '■J -, f � 'Ji. 'r1i, �. '17; I'Z5•.� �_� 5 _ �'y`+ I i� �, r 9 ,1+ li t , +. '+� ''i_� _•;+�. �i , y . , •'� :#r�� 't�Y ' r ! S I � s � ° ,_ . � l t f'il � �Zr ' +1 k 4 J ' .� + +� ', i 3 r f y r i f w _ - y : P. -1_s + ., }, '� J i' .- {° r .� , �i, ,t1•� •r L° y,i�t I� r fiyf a .a1 =I! °��,� C •s � J` �:` � i ! 1 �'�'� t �y •- + { � Ste° p r '� � s � !" - � t s t �•-.�^ ' -. , r ,. � " � - � , yS, t 1 ! s t � �'# L fii! ` " r d � Y •f �, L f y S ,r � '1 - JF , y _ A�..+y�- Jr- i�_�s l�✓_� � A 1. P.- r� } S r ' °xJ, _ ;; Fry � i+' r� fi r .J, r �,�r ski rti •la •aF+ tE ''�-t'- - _ -..Jr. M • ' + - • T _ � Y f 1 � .+i r .a ��7 i �' rar � a�q -' 7 _ _ '. - f * ° r +�. ,_ -fir .� } _�� t. • + #�. s �; b�: � � r ;�},, „� + t �-.^ - K 4 sa}�J■��.' • '*�'��y".�1{ *��'S,, ti � ! r�.�r? I: �.� - -- _- J� °r _ a 1 + b - F Yk. , 115 p , } _ - jr,iJ re' v*~ r 1p P , f 1 ) J' - - r'" es+F I- - / Y, + >,+--�-•5 �l.�i'.F - - r = 1' �[+-J- - A A. ry 'r. • _ r '. - j _ e1 rt - _ -. �-- -\ c a�t+ fir'' 4 ��{ �t '' ��' �._ r � �f• ' ,� id - _ w _ - �-1`��,r+� +#- - y * - �•,"�"7ti°� 1 €�.� �. -r Xt l� 4' 4�'r'`+ s� �i r' � �� l � � �-� - sf, �_ _. •.i °L+4 r-1.idrl.fa +,�.�' ti'�..trr, 'i ,rrq _, sy!-{ * t;.• S.. rM1 _ - J' 'rJ ; x.* 1 y. r a? r+p � S; . f. '. TJ - `� % I' + '.'mil; fit ' ■ _ �' 'b r` = }-l.r .''L ..1 .. +IY +- �' � - ',' + �•r #r a - - _ f+.Y V J aa.� �: _ �_-r `��hs„�t'� � r'�'•��}t; '� ��"�` �� _ ,�: t'! � � r.y '�, �y,r�l�,_ �fr�� +4. *c� •.- � � *','."`.,t prr:-�, ,, _ � .J�+�,`e �f` � �>• � e f � ,_ ! 7t}+ r?,.�2� �„°ia ki� t'Tf ,a?+Fyk+ r {I, �Jj°4��.:'`�. �'e��• _ - $? � �5`•�.i'�?��'r J �i � r � °{E it i�ti -� - ``'a � �J► Y� --,..- � ��.+' • y �'�`�-�, ` [J�.y.� ;, #` y. � ~'.�' j�x°"Il�.. _.� w.� � _ .� i�. �'� i a.^ ry r ;; i k,; , � � r . ,.� - f .4�1; -� �r�-+�.f5 # •. l r c tia ',r, ir�t'`'��w'``•` ice` ,'p�*�j'.r''.' + r. '. �a.P ,:1' 1't i. +�, 1ti' t`v e. "' ftr�., ! "i°' r i� z'R�74* ti Y.1 x+ `+�=.:'■.� t# t S !ry w 1 ', p ti r a� �a -a r-]_ ++ #ry{�i_/• F £ 1: t.P- ' # 7 f - 3U`}■.. ia.f L' �-`-7 1 ...•: -,'°' L i'1 +. L{ '�'% t 4i i ■ - ,{ +y! JI° ■.�� fr.F " f 4 S-! �.. +J' �rr' %}f.j frr . F _� .Fire{ 72• Ij+ '} }' t + q J q •� y-` F + g -y �•._ i'r : }� * ! r� " k t 'Sf ro e ti' , ai �t b' i' *," l� . y,+r i�•i �Ip,5�■ ++aiJfif, #�5• 4 J y'_{, Lrii"°.ti. -i'... it t�f*r'' •,k .�. -Fa"t:• R, '_ - _�,_ t . - ,� -ti' :t',;. {,.:•J� .s y. 4�T�{� r,�l e ii:•l�r��r i. �' *, �� s °�? L ,}4. ,1si, ' �1�■ � Ri # Ft fi$ F4�` �}+,� F ` - �--•-��_+ _ "- ry'�..." #,,z� .�•� „ - s"14yS�'J~_$�}'.i� #4 - i • s'"4PJ7 ,. { Xi.� : S r''1 ,; . #- 'rr+ X■' MONAr ?; 'a'f y-tIS• •-J�.rCTM i+i t. ' ` - N .:5 ' ` yr rj + 'R - i5f ti Y.. l.a�„-''�., �...., _' eye. 4 '■ ;'�r,,y. 5±i'�'J ,�-"}s' fl+`Jr.: .fi. ifit •r �y`"i�'']n^F ya r,3 yi r ''-# �i! J{e`a /1!i'-,� L J�a rP._J�?'t .' _# larrll - 17= C. F��'°ti -�-7J r.lr �J tr I.+ry : �•'t47L.#.£f}�z `t "} {. 1G _- ��4t a ar_+i- ,k*, ,.$ i� af__,T.�,,.: rf�-.'j''^'C',�'�i�}'r •+t. '�#%7--. F�',rzd' J'P! '..+ p,l, ;sue.` r' ly�""AAr"'.i e� ..ti ,y _. - ►,,.* 'it�+ a<� �['.�'.+ "•'�S r SA'_ �✓Yr% ,-atita�,rr i,�'r'h °;.}�s,�_r�''Y`Jttts+ ice}}ii7l4' IV°�� ,'; 1'r,':'i .` :i•._.4 ! :+�a'{�vi ' •ir •t "{ t aT.�i`#'`. + �, ►._��`.i: "��,\,► - _ :k ,+ t � :r .J. i s�f. r r� A- P' f �� i � ��'-r��e.J��y`. ='Y. M-•�{�.� fJ,! yfi .+►LOr Lr'±ti, -�,F$ +.• #7 t�+j, i�'F+ ' il. lj. w+ r - t► �.",.. _ram 1 -t{{�. fir. �.R� is r{°S'•- r'','4�,,r•.+...iiJ {rt� [_ St''*�� •+F z;■• `.. +... �js ■'" 'i" -� •r'1 �.ti.) ti .: w;+!_. 1. `. +�''.-.1.i�'ti, Fy,y Y, %r' ��'■: ■.,. [ _'`+F�h�+,yJ'.t+}`.ry=� k#, �' e � � • • •x•r•�-- `""'-�,� 3� ��k �'' ii�� + �r '� ��!'�s' i >Tr " +i' r, 'J*� } '•.�'! +M � yy , �:� j� a: r;+ }fi' _ '- f� ° aR ..' i� ;a�yyi �sl .e r �: I�Y �+✓ �,T 161 ;� i s � '�`d'�'��f ��,� •"' 1 �" *19 rr�4F �•0.� -'r. � -� ``�y t.- ! PJJf[ J `�1 t#�?�j�*r;1.+ +� rjj}�},.t-'*+..�I ;..1;'■rg-C Ycti �+* 1+�}.,■Y'J 11''. * A4'... 44f Y° :/ :.e' : �,`�'t hr4•'t. ki +F��'' n k�l� e `• #4� >� .r4fT * .fir* `•', jay i ry or L ..ra k . �■ + •li71 art•;f.. M � ,! Y `"�}!�� I .'f "�.� �!s'�� ? � 'L1'�+ L�� • - ti �,4.. � `-� � i:' 4 v � �. � �i 'i� ;�•, ,`' Y'ICr �I �Ir ! YI l a �J ,{lei �■•. �fi+ �: �� * IL 6 r f. L: V, fa .. tZ,a _.•,'p7l h. 11y r xiil,__] °i'�J- • 71S�C r�..•i# f!L'y� - - ar,�. <YrF i _vt9* 4 `• w tA tf k4}./'ref a�� 'ti �. � '��?• �� ,�1' y�� :`� s "','—,� err F� � { •F+=cam. x ��,�md�i LI �/ ,Ir�'a 4t�l�f -+�• 4'�1 1• . yi 'L~' ' �F m, �� Y� �- � � �(' � 1 P + d t '# l •FL ~' _ ` *{ m[ yam' �A ,i -#' ' }� 0 FI Le L IN -+ r I 1!k} L = i5 t•' id } , + Yr *.fir•. 4s • J 1 1[ Np a � J. Y - ra ti z -A Jffr ,fr ={. 'l -` r fF.� i a44 .Y�;f * {'+' off r y r. { ►7 Art # �'1i � } '�' �-y_•'° r4+�m�°{t� � � iL+,�!• �t�S- •� r �. a��'r.mr-!9 -��i•{ `� F%* _.#"_.��r�'1 1 J r}-ii"` i .• � '� {`,' -a`� ..�. ay• +j�'. i Y�'; y r g. # '�d �ti�.rf r err{{ i �l;, _._ r''L ;u s� ! 1�,r+, r`ti` y •-. ''r 3 `"l ar� m.,�r ��r�.:�� F4e�__'" � r ��• 14� �It �. r 1 f -,!• Jli -S 1, t I a 1' �: t 1 � _.'J% •�� f{�j�- G"_ ++� S } � fug � r � � � - f ' `-' -'i� � -•Y� • Y i • y 4+' �.s ''1 _dl� •';ro* t,11• °°�, `4 ,rrfi'_.iJ +r,•ti: .v °J , . .f dui`I'� y� rt .i r e t.�,. � I�''r ta+ h �'.�' � �,5r7.mY f'r ��.,t�'F• � �F'`I`��',r� �'�' '� y' xl'. 1 '�'y ,t _°t� +?,� �� rSS�', � l-°•Jt- •Y ,�-: �'r-•� ,��-+�" ,' .�Fb ii.T� � __ .� G �'11', � <'�a. �,��,' h �.1 ''r?�rr�*'�`rj �,a ~�F ��. lr�1•i.�''.4��,�■ f°�f ,ae .r° �r i,},! .1'-��•,y ,'�1,��••� Me L .rr'"i 4 - ti,5,1 �.M !y' ..," 1' •i=CY�"'r y - aa- • _� _f•.r P - ix e�ti r 1 NY 'qy, �,'� ��ti,''"``. �„# T �ti je �`� � .�`,�A ti.�� ■ Yet t. m- , � 1_ '> w •" r �is•r �, -y`'.vY~�{ IL _ -4 . 14 iJ tl 7# lF_4 "� yr`.-� ��., i ',�±-, • � r7]-a"� f 9 `�'�' f fj '� I� � • a � fr t { v ry fm . � LI L f '! a 1 f• � � f ra -� #r. i' JF � a 1'! i�� * 11, jf]4, o. is k' k;� 9{4,_�, � �{..��J 1' F �P ��e �'!Y ,�� f , !�1'�' + •i'y r� �`I} � � - IF � r' ' It ♦+� ''k �� 1 L a, �r� 1I � �`• 1 i �' r , . ■ 4:r 3 4, [,v ; r e� j �f} rTr' :' Pig .a 1 f, f' `Jf+- r` ! }x" - m% fl/f. L/r�� .;��t ��'+[�f y,�� r7f• ff i �-, Tfr�- •Jr��.. � J. T f °'�-� -. � i y 1l kk3 WN yT-, Yi i+� r5 tip} am.f *r f•� }� �# ^_.`' _�=�"� _ y r 4-'S, rt{ f �/r � {4r� � ' Y I` � �-�j'+1' �m P+.� r if' � �J, L IL op IL FN AAA III mi dr 7 ! F pr APAT , m l ,_ /# Y_ r#ram .1 4 * ¢ 4 / P ■� 171 _ ,rr . l -1 BEAUMONT, TEXAS HISTORIC SAS INVENTORY FORM - BE UM HISTORICAL LANDMARK GOMMIS S10N JEF 1 County JEFFERSON 5. USG S Quad No. 3094-111 site No. 468 City/Rural. BEAUMONT BMT 6. Date: Factual. Est. c. 1915 2., Name Address 2229 Liberty 7. Architect/Builder Contractor 3. Owner Brown, Della 8. Style/Type Craftsman Address 2229 Liberty, Beaumont 77701-1975 9. Original. Use D0MEST1CjSinSte DweLting 4. Block/Lot Averill Lot 3 Kock 1 SE 2-3 Present Use DOMESTIC/SingLe Dwelling 10. Description: j One-story rectangular plan frame with hipped asphalt shingle roof, interior chimney. Offset gable front%porch with bracketed, stucco -covered pediment, square wooden columns on stucco -covered pedestals, wooden stair ' s with stucco covered banister and vernacular wocden balustrade. Central. muLtipane glass and wood door with muLtipane sidelights between one nine -over -one sash with nonfunctionirig shutters and one pair of nine/one sash with nonfunctioning shutters. 11. Present Condition Good. The house is structurally sound and welt -maintained. 12. Significance: The house is a good example of a local adaptation of the Craftsman style and is representative of middle class homes built in Beaumont in the early decades of the century. 13. Relationship to Site: Original. Moved 14. Bibliography Date (Describe Original ,Situ 15. informant 16. Recorder 0. Bush Date PHOTO DATA Black and White 35 mm negative YEAR DRWR ROLL FRME ROLL FRS 89 15 22 to VIEW: RECORDED BY: D. Bush DATE: 08-07-89 I