The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutHLC December 2023 Packet*AGENDA* HISTORIC LANDMARK COMMISSION December 11, 2023 REGULAR MEETING HISTORIC LANDMARK COMMISSION Council Chambers, City Hall, 801 Main St. - 3:30 p. m. 'AGENDA* Rni i rAi i. APPROVAL OF MINUTES Approval of the minutes of the Regular Meeting held November 13, 2023. REGULAR MEETING 1) PZ2023-461:A request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to remove a chimney. Applicant: Alicia Gudino for Donna Kay Ware Location: 2420 McFaddin Avenue 2) Historic District Code Enforcement Report OTHER BUSINESS rAti-Treff M0.0 "To protect, enhance and perpetuate historic landmarks which represent or reflect distinctive and important elements of the City"s and State` s architectural, archaeological, cultural, social, economic, ethnic and political history and to develop appropriate settings fog' such places.' Persons with disabilities who plan to attend this meeting and who may need auxiliary aids or services are requested to contact Kaltrina Minick at 409-880-3777. M I N U T E S HISTORIC LANDMARK COMMISSION Novembet- 13, 2023 Council Cliambei-s, City Hall, 801 Main Sti-ect, Beaumont, Texas A Regular Meeting of the I listoric Landmark Commission was held on November 13, 2023 and called to order at 3:30 .in. with the following members present: Chairman Dohn LaBiche Commissioner Hester Bell Commissioner John Berube Commissioner Christina Crawford *arrived at 3:34 pni Commissioner Theresa Goodness Commissioner Ronald Kelley Commissioner Lynda Kay Makin Commissioner Marva Provo Commissioner 'Thoinas Sigee Commissioner Janelle Templeton Commission Members absent - Con-emissioner Yolanda Nan Avery Also present: Elayna Luckey, Planner I Susan Smith, Recording Secretary Pashae Randle, Zoning Technician John Wilson, Oaks Historic Code Enforcement Officer APPROVAL OF MINUTES Commissioner Makin moved to approve the minutes of the Regular Meeting held on October 9, 2023. Commissioner Sic e seconded the motion. The motion to approve carried 9:0. Commissioner Crawford not yet present. REGULAR MEETING 1) PZ2023-340: A request for a Certificate of. ppropriateness to construct two duplexes. Applicant: Cornell Price Location: 2490 Liberty Avenue Mrs. Luckey presented the staff report. Property owner Cornell Price, of CMP3 Enterprises LLC, has requested a Certificate of Appropriateness to allow the construction of two duplexes of property located at 2490 Liberty Avenue at the corner of Liberty and 9t" Street. Historic Landmark Commission No ember 13, 2023 Mrs. Luckey presented the staff report. Property owner Cornell Price, of CN4P3 Enterprises LLC, has requested a Certificate of Appropriateness to allow the construction of two duplexes on property located at 2490 Liberty Avenue at the corner of Liberty and 9t" Street. The proposed construction inethods employed would dictate that the two story structures will be constructed on a slab foundation with wood framing. The siding will be of a I x 8 x 12 profile and made of HardiPlank with a proposed body color of Alabaster (SW 7008) and proposed trim color of Acces sible Beige (S W 703 6). The roof will be finished with weather good 3 0 -y e ar arch i tectura I shingles. The orientation of the duplexes will have the proposcd structures and attached garages facing 9"' Street with the side of the structure facing Liberty Avenue. The site plan is subject to an approved Variance through the Board of Adjustment and the use of the lot for duplexes subject to approval of a Specific Use Permit by the Planning Commission and City Council. Slides of the subj ect property were shown. Planning staff recommended approval of the request, subject to the following Conditions: 1.Storn-i shutters be included for all upper windows and painted to match the structure. 2. All windows be one (1) over one (1) in appearance. 3. Roof overhang minimum shall be 12". Brief discussion followed concerning the size of each proposed duplex, which will be two two- story buildings each containing two units for a total of 4 units with a one car garagc for each unit. Specifics of the request relating to setback requirements were also discussed. The applicant was present. Cornell Price of CMP3 Enterprises, 2635 Rigby Drive, Beatin-lont., `I"exas addressed the Commission. He stated th-at the duplexes are not for low income housing and presented a proposed blueprint to the Commission. Further discussion followed concerning removal of the trees,, exterior materials, duplex size, landscaping, and rental fees were discussed. Conuiiissioner Bell i-noved to approve the request for a Certificate of -Appropriateness to construct two duplexes, as requested in PZ2023-340, with the following conditions: 1.Storm shutters be included for all upper windows and Painted to match the structure. 2. All windows be one (1) over one (1) in appearance. 3. Roof overhang miniinum. shall be 12". N Historic Landmark Commission Noveiiiber 13, 2023 Cominisslojier Kelley seconded the motion. A roll call vote was taken. Chairman La fiche -Aye; Commissioner Bell -Aye; Commissioner Berube-Aye; Commissioner Crawford -Aye; Commissioner Goodness -Aye; Conunissioner Kelley -Aye; Commissioner Makin -Aye; Commissioner Provo -Aye; Commissioner Sigee-Aye; Commissioner Templeton -Aye. The motion to approve the request carried 10: 0. 2) PZ2023-384: A request to revoke a Certificate of Appropriateness for expansion of a driveway. Applicant: City of Beaumont Location: 2555 Harrison Avenue Mrs. Luckey presented the staff report. rrhe City of Beaumont is requesting to revoke a Certificate of Appropriateness to cxpand the driveway at 2 5 5 5 Harrison Avenue. The request. comes foil wi11 g the discovery that the applicant had mistakenly applied for a Certificate of Appropriateness for the wrong address of where the work is intended. A corrected application has been submitted and will be before you for review. Staff recommended approval of the request. Brief discussion followed concerning specifies of the request. Commissioner Goodncss moved to approve the request to revoke a Certificate of Appropriateness for expansion of a driveway, as requested in PZ2023-394. Commissioner Makin seconded the motion. A roll call vote was taken. Chairman LaBiche-Aye; Con-imissioner Bell -Aye; Commissioner Berube-Ayc; Conmiissioner Crawford -Aye; Commissioner Goodness -Aye; Conu-nissioner Kelley -Aye; Commissioner Makin -Aye; Commissioner Provo -Aye; Commissioner Sigee-Aye; Commissioner Templeton -Aye. The motion to approve the request carried 10: 0. 3) PZ2023-403-0 A request for a Certificate of Demolition to demolish a house, Applicant: City of Beaumont Location.- 2370 Pecos Street Mrs. Luckey presented the staff report. Boyd Meier, Building Official, requests a Certificate of Demolition for the house located at 2370 Pecos Street. According to the inspection repoil, this structure was originally tagged on June 9, 2023 after damage from a fire. The structure received substantial damage such as a collapsed ceiling, rafter damage, the rear roof and walls completely destroyed with substantial smoke damage to the remainder of the structure, making it considered unsafe for human occupancy. 3 Historic Land nail Coniiiiission November 13, 2023 Based on the extensive repairs needed for this structure the Building Codes Staff recommended a raze order. The property is not listed in the SPARE Beauinwit Survey, and the OJ�Vner has signed the Demolition Consent. Seventeen (17) notices were mailed to property owners within two hUndrcd (200) feet of the subject property. Zero (0) responses were received in favor or in opposition Slides of the subject property were shown. Planning staff recommended approval of this request. Commissioner Makin moved to approve the request for a Certificate of Demolition to demolish a house, as requested in file PZ2023-403. Commissioner Templeton seconded the motion. A roll call vote was taken. Chairn-lan Laffiche-Aye; Conunissioner Bell -Aye; Commissioner Berubc-Aye; Conu-nissioner Crawford -Aye; Commissioner Goodness -Aye; Commissioner Kelley -Aye; Commissioner Makin -Aye; Commissioner Provo -Aye; C011111-lissioner Sigee-Aye; Commissioner Teinplcton-Aye. The motion to approve the request carried 10: 0. 4) PZ2023-425: A request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to change all windows and the exterior doors. Applicant: Tina Ellis for Melvin Taylor Location: 2570 Rusk Street Mrs. Luckey presented the staff report. Tina Ellis, on behalf of the property owner Melvin Taylor, has requested a Certificate of Appropriateness to allow the renovation of the home located at 2570 Rusk Street through the Texas General Land Office Harvey Recovery Program. The applicant is requesting to remove all of the existing four (4) over one wood window and replace them with one over one windows. Additionally, the existing exterior doors would be removed and replaced with a solid six (6) panel exterior door. The hoine seems to be coil structed with the inspiration of Tudor architecture with its multiple front gables, steeply pitched side gable, rounded porch entry and brick detailing around decorative edges, however lacks the grandeur details of the architecture. Examples of the Tudor details as described can be seen 1 n A F ieN Gracie to A i) iei - icon Ilo i ises (McAlester et al., p gs. 3 5 5 - 3 5 8). In reviewing the examples, multi -pane windows appear to be featured throughout the Tudor home exan-iples, making the request to change the windows to one over one seem inappropriate. The property is not listed in the SPARE Beaumont Survey. 2! Historic Landmark Commissioll Novenibei- 13, 2023 Slides of the subject property were shown. Planning staff recommended approval of the request, with the following conditI*ODS*. 1. The front door installed., be painted to, niatch the trim and accents of the structure. 2. The windows arc replaced to include the niulling strips to give the appearance of the original four (4) over one window's. A representative of the applicant was present. Kevin Scott of RM Quality Construction, PO Box 813, Co roe, Texas addressed the Commission. He stated that the home is part of the Texas General Land Office Harvey Recovery Program. Mr. Scott further stated that the Program will allow for windows and front door as approved by the Commission. He also stated that extensive indoor repairs will take place and the roof was recently replaced. Mr. Scott ftirther stated that the Program does not allow for renovations to the detached garage. Further discussion followed concerning specifics of the front door. Con-in-ii s s loner Berube moved to approve the request to for a Certificate of Appropriateness to change all windows and the exterior doors, as requested in PZ2023-425, with the following amended conditions: 1. The front door to be installed to match the existing door. 2. The windows are replaced wIth four over one windows to match the existing. Commissioner Bell seconded the motion. A roll call vote was taken. Chairman LaBiche-Aye; Commissioner Bell -Aye; Commissioner Berube-Aye; Commissioner Crawford -Aye; Commissioner Goodness -Aye; Commissioner Kelley -Aye; Commissioner Makin -Aye; Commissioner Provo -Aye; Commissioner Sigee-Aye; C om in issi oner Templeton -Aye. 'The motion to approve the request carried 10: 0. 5) 1'Z2023-434: A request for a Certificate of Demolition to den-iolish a house. Applicant: City of Beaumont Location.- 2070 Pecos Street Mrs. Luckey presented the staff report. Boyd Meier, Building Official, requests a Certificate of Den-iolition for the house located at 2070 Pecos Street. According to the inspection report., this structure was originally taggcd on June 9, 2023 after damage fron-i a fire. The strLICture received substantial damage by a second fire in October leaving the already damaged structure more than seventy (70) percent damaged according the Beaumont Fire Department, leaving it considered as a total loss and unsafe for human occupancy. 5 Historic Landinark Commission November 13., 2023 Based on the extensive repairs needed for this structure the Building Codes Staff is recommending a raze order. The property is not listed iii the SPARE Beauinoiit Survey. Twenty-five (25) notiecs were mailed to property owners within two hundred (200) feet of the subject property. Zero (0) responses were received in favor or in opposition. Slides of the subject property were shown. Planning staff reconiniended approval of the request. Brief discussion followed concerning vacancy of the residence, cause of the fire, property taxcs owed, and CODIMUnication from the property owner. Commissioner Tenipleton moved to approve the request for a Certificate of Demolition to demolish a house, as requested in file PZ2023-403. Commissioner Makin seconded the motion. A roll call vote was taken. Chairman LaBlclie-Ay e; Commissioner Bell -Aye; Commissioner Berube-Aye; Commissioner Crawford -Aye; Commissioner Goodness -Aye; Commissioner Kelley -Aye; Commissioner Makin -Aye; Commissioner Provo -Aye; Commissioner Sigee-Aye; Commissioner Templeton -Aye. The motion to approve the request carried 10:0. 6) PZ2023-438-t A request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to expand a driveway. Applicant: Ricky Pinkston Location: 2255 Harrison Street Mrs. Luckey presented the staff report. Ricky Pinkston, is requesting a Certificatc of Appropriateness to expand the driveway at 2255 Harrison Avenue. The expansion would make the driveway twelve (12) feet in width starting at the property line extending to the rear of the structure, where the pavement would expand to 28' in width. The expansion would not extend in front of the main structure. The home is not listed in the SPARE, Beaumont Survey. Slides of the subject property were shown. Staff rccommended approval of the request with the following conditions: 1. The new pavement shall comply with Section 28.03.024(18) District area and height regulations of the City of Beaumont Code of Ordinances by maintaining a 2' offset from the side property line. 101 Historic Laiidmark Commission November 13, 2023 2. All applicable permits and hispections shall be obtained through the Building Codes Department. Brief discussion followed conceming the width and ren-ioval of the existing driveway, construction of a new driveway, and location of the property line. It was also noted that the existing sidewalk will be pressure washed. "I"he applicant was not present. Commissioner Makin moved to approve the request to for a Certificate of Appropriatcness to expand a driveway, a s requested in PZ2 02 3 - 4 3 8, with the folio ing conditions: 1. The new pavement shall comply with Section 28.03.024(18) District area and height regulations of the City of Beaumont Code of Ordinances by maintaining a 2' offset from the side property line. 2. All applicable permits and inspections shall be obtained through the Building Codes Department. Commissioner Goodness seconded the motion. A roll call vote was taken. Chairman LaBiche-Aye; Commissioner Bell -Aye; Commissioner Berube-Aye; Commissioner Crawford -Aye; Commissioner Goodness -Aye; Commissioner Kelley -Aye; Commissioner Makin -Aye; Commissioner Provo -Aye; Commissioner Sigee-Aye; Commissioner Templeton -Aye. The motion to approve the request carried 10:0. HISTORIC DISTRICT CODE ENFORCEMENT REPORT Mrs. Luckey advised the Conunission that today will be Mrs. Randle's last meeting to present the Code Enforeeme nt Report as she received a promotion to Zoning Technician. She also introduced John Wilson as the new Oaks Historic Code Enforcement Officer. Mrs. Randle presented the Historic District Code Enforcement Report. OTHER BUSINESS 1) Discuss appropriate placement of mini -split air conditioning units within the Oaks Historic District. Mrs. Luckey stated that the Commission is being asked to consider future appropriate placement of mini -split air conditioning units within the Oaks Historic District. Beau Hansen, Deputy Building Official, addressed the Commission by explaining the process of mini -split air conditioning installation. 7 Historic Lai.idniark Coimiiissiwi Novenibor 13, 2023 The Commission was favorable to installation of mini -split air conditioning units to structures within the Oaks Historic District that are not visible from the street right-of-way. Units visible from the street right-of-way must receive approval from the Historic Landmark Commission. THE MEETING WAS ADJOURNE D AT 4:23 P.M. DATE: December 111, 2023 TO: Historic Landmark Commission FROM: Elayna Luckey, Planner I SUBJECT: A request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to remove a chimney. FILE: PZ2023-461 STAFF REPORT Alicia Gudino of Straight and Narrow Foundation on behalf of property owner Donna Kay Ware, is requesting a Certificate of Appropriateness to remove the brick chimney and replace it with like siding on the home located at 2420 McFaddin Avenue. The request comes as a part of a list of repairs being made to the property. The home seemingly identifies with prairie architecture most if not all examples provided by A Field Guide to American Houses, include bricked chimneys featured on these structures. Examples of the prairie details can be reviewed in A Field Guide to American Houses (McAlester et al., pgs. 448- 451). Planning staff recommends denial of the request. The property is not listed in the SPARE Beaumont Survey. Exhibits are attached. McAlester, Virginia& Lee. A Field Guide to American Houses. Alfred A. Knopf, Inc., 1984. Print BEAVMC3NT Planning a Community Development Case Type:Planning and Zoning Case Sub Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Case #-. PZ2023-461 Location: 2420 MCFAIDDIN AVE, BEAUMONT, 77702 Individuals listed on the record. - Applicant Alicia Gudino 15639 Old Sour Lake Rd Beaumont, TX 77713 Agent Alicia Gudino 15639 Old Sour Lake Rd Beaumont, TX 77713 Property Owner Donna Kay Ware 2420 McFaddin Ave Beaumont, TX 77702 Reason for Request of a Certificate of Appropriateness Paint Now Construction Demo Fenc ng Miscellaneous Has request been made before? If yes, date: Notes. - Case Status: REVIEW Tag Name: pier & beam foundation repair, chimney removal Initiated On: 11/1612023 3-08:38PM Home Phone: 14097516564 Work Phone: 14097516564 Celi Phone: 4097516564 E-Mail: sand.nai-row@aol.com Home Phone: 14097516564 Work Phone: Coll Phone: 4097516564 E-Mail: sand.narrow@aol.com Home Phone: Work Phone, Cell Phone: E-Mail: pier & beam foundation repair, removal of chinnney N N N N N N This is not a building permit, additional permits may be required for the proposed scope of work. Case Type: Planning and Zoning Page I of 1 Case #: PZ2023-461 Printed On: 11128/2023 STRAAONT AND NARROW F O lJ N O A T 1 O N Francisco & AliciaG10 148 S. Dowlen fed,, PMB 749 Beaumont, TX 77707 OFFICE: (409) -151-6564 FAX- (409) 403-8545 Email, ndmari- w l.c n July 24, 2023 David Bung WPi-pZ 2410 McFaddin Ave, Beaumont, TX (956) 286-8042/Email: d—bausman@hotmall.corn Thank you for the opportunity to meet with you. We are please" to submit the following bid. Job scri Lion ' raiah en & level entire foundation from hiahest point of house located at above address. Acid termite shields. Stratqhten or replace leaning dare as ngeded. R201ace-up to 32ft of rotted beams. Reinforce Six floor joists under kitchen. Replace 3 windows. Knock down chimney ce not tncl e�.. Place siding.where c irnng r moy . drear ace r r-■��- - - - ` sidinc If additional "'f rotted wood is found, it can be replaced for . o fit, per homeowner verl agreementf If additional "x " rotted wood is found, it can he replaced for .00 , per homeowner verbal agreement. We propose hereby to fu'rnish all labor and materials - complete In accordance with the above specifications for the Burn of Nine Thousand, Seven Hundred and 001100 Dollars. Total Price: 19,700.00 PAYMENT MADE AS FOLLOWS PAYMENT F $3000.00 DUEATSTARTOFJOB AND REMAINING BALANCE DUE UPON COMPLETION WORK ALTHOUGH CAREFUL CO NS I D EI ATI 0 N I S TAKEN, STRAI G HT & I ARR W FO UNDATl0N CO. IS NOT R ES P NSl BLE lr DAMAG E CAUSED TO GLASS, WALLS, WIRIN , PLU M BING, OR ETC. DUE TO THE ABOVE WORK PERFORMED 0 R SETTLING. REPAIR EXPENSES ARE CUSTOMER RESPONSIBILITY. HOMEOWNER IS NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR ANY INJURIES TO STRAIGHT & NARROW FOUNDATION EMPLO EE . All labor/material is guaranteed to be as specified for I year. Guarantee is null and void following a NATURAL DISASTER, All work to be completed in a professional manner as per standard practices. Any deviation from above bid involving extra costs will be approved by customer and will become are extra charge over and above the estimate with homeowner verbal approval. STRAIGHT & NARROW FOUNDATION COIS BONDED. ,A grade A member of the Better Business Bureau since 2004. Acceptance of this BID: The above price, specifications, and conditions are hereby accepted. You are authorized to do wor . A (I SIGNATURE Pleasesign �;�7'urn phis copy when bia acceptea, h r ��+.5�'�.{ •" ,�.,, fie. ~ M11 , ° ,,� r +; k 1. aL_ _ � I �•�}° l , _ 5 i■ x e. r . L y IL 731 4 x -t q 7 IL { " y .T 4 4L Vt k.c r �, 7d {• '''� til r i y,r `,fly �, -J, o ! Elf y 1 t, IL a ir #_ - ,+ qq —77 ___ t� �y' �kl�,1' ' :-W - _— - °— t-. .: a'w::�rieA�S�'— �a •�.1 • F� •l r k II I t '�' •k � F� r • •pf 1 - 1 t, l _ � t r f Y� k - y..• — �'mir� -. 11� , I S - ►. 'Ih'� -+ Al y . ,. MAI- a . Y - • r�ly JIY:1 _ �� { i ��-.� , `". �•, Yam,- Wit, t• d , ' •' v a