The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutHLC November 2023 Packet*A{2ENCA* HISTORIC LANDMARK CON1PN|6S|OKl REGULAR MEETING MSTORIC LANDMARK COMMISSION Council Chambers, City Hall, 801 Main. St. - 3:30 ps M0 * A G E N C> A * n(.,. ra|| APPROVAL OF MINUTES Approval of the minutes of the Regular Meeting held October 9, 2023. REGULAR MEETING jj Arequest for aCertificate ofAppropriateness toconstruct two duplexes. Applicant: Cornell Price Location: 2490 Liberty Avenue 2) PZ2023-384: A request to revoke a Certificate of Appropriateness for expansion of a drivevvay. Applicant: City ofBeaumont Location.- 2555 Harrison Avenue 3) Arequest for aCertificate ofDemolition todemolish ahouse. Applicant: City ofBeaumont Al 5) /\ request for aCertificate ofDemo|Ujontodemolish ahouse. Applicant: City ofBeaumont Location: 2O7OPecos Street 6) /\ request for aCertificate ofAppropriateness toexpand adriveway. Applicant: Rick«Pinkston 7) Historic District Code Enforcement Report OTHER BUSINESS 1) Discuss appropriate placement of mini -split air conditioning units within the Oaks Historic District. FIVOTOMPTIT ""To protect, enhance and perpetuate historic landmarks which represent or reflect distinctive and important elements of the City's and State"s orchitectural, archaeological, cultural, Social, economi . c, ethnic crud political h is tory and to de velop appropriate settings for such places., Persons with disabilities who plan to attend this meeting and who may need auxiliary aids or services are requested to contact Kaltrina Minick at 409-880-3777. MINUTES L HISTORIC LANDMARK, COMMISSION Oetobei- 9, 2023 Council Chambers, City Hall, 801 Main Sti-cet, Beaumont, Texas A Regular Meeting of the Historic Landmark Commission was held on October 9, 2023 and called to order at 3:30 p.m. with the following menibers present: Acting Chair Lynda Kay Makin Commissioner Yolanda Nan Avery Commissioner Hester Bell Commissioner Jolua Berube Com.missioner Christina Crawford Commissioner Theresa Goodness C onami s s i oner Ronald Ke I I ey *arrive at 3:3 2 pin Conimissioner Thomas SI*gCC *arrived at 3:34 pin Commissioner Janelle Templeton Commission Members absent Chairman Dolui La fiche Commissioner Marva Provo Also present: Elayna Luckey, Platiner I Susan Smith, Rccording Secretary Mayor Roy West APPROVAL OF MINUTES Corr missioncr Bell moved to approve the minutes of the Regular Meeting held orl Septcmber 11, 2023. Commissioner Goodness seconded the motion. The motion to approve carried 7:0. Commission Kelley and Commissioner igee not yet present. REGULAR MEETING 1) PZ2023-329: A request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to construct an accessory structure. Applicant: Elizabeth Jcan Stark Location- 2645 Long Avenue Mrs. Luckey presented the staff report. Elizabeth Jean Stark, is requesting a Certificate of Appropriateness to construct a new accessory StrUdure at 2645 Long Avenue. The structure will be located in the rear yard and used for personal storage, and will be visible from the street right- of-way. Historic Landmark Comm iss 1011 October 9, 2023 The accessory structure will be made of Nwood, with horizontal siding to match the home. It will have a shingle roof with the pitch rising five (5) inches every twelve (12) inches. It will feature ail overhead door and a swing door at the front. There will also be an attached breezeN�,ay from the swing door to the back door of the hoine; the breezeway Neill not be risible from the right-of-way. The setbacks displayed on the site plan are in compliance with the Section 28.03.024 District area and height regulations of our City's Ordinances. The home is not listed in the SPARE Beaumont Survey. Staff recommended approval of the request with the following conditions: 1. The accessory structure be painted to match the home. 2. All applicable permits and hispections shall be obtained through the Building Codes Department. Slides of the sub 0 ect property were shown. j Brief discussion followed concerning location of the structure on the property. The applicant was not present. Commissioner Goodness moved to approve the request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to construct an accessory structure, as requested in PZ2023-329, with the following conditions: 1. The accessory structure be painted to match the home. 2. All applicable permits and inspections shall be obtained fl-irough the Building Codes Department. Commissioner Avery seconded the motion. A roll call vote was taken. Acting Chair Makin -Aye; Commissioner Avery --Aye; Commissioner Bell -Aye; Commissioner erube-Aye; Commissioner Crawfofd-Aye; Coy- missioner Goodness - Aye; Commissioner Kelley -Aye; Commissioner Tenipleton-Aye. The motion to approve the request carried 8:0. Commissioner igee not yet present. 2) 111,2023-375: A request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to install lattice. Applicant: Roy Malifeaux Location: 2346 Broadway Street Mrs. Luckey presentcd the staff report. Roy Mal veaux, is requesting a Certificate of Appropriateiiess to install lattice around the crawlspacc under his home at 2346 Broadway. The purpose of the lattice will be to keep animals out from under the home. The lattice will be a N Historic Landmark Conm-iissioji Octobei� 9, 2023 traditional wood lattice in the diamond pattern and be painted a cream color to match the trim and porch. The home is not listcd in the SPARE Beaumont Survey. Staff reconin-icnded approval of the request. Slides of the subject property were shown. The applicant was present. Kaffie Malveaux, 2346 Broadway Street, Beauniont, Texas addressed the Commission. She stated that she wishes to install the lattice to prevent animals from entering under her home. She further stated that a homeless person bathed near her property and threw his clothes tinder her home. Further discussion followed concerning securing the lattice to the frank of the residence. Commissioner Kelley n-lovcd to approve the request for a Certificate of AppropriateDess to install lattice, as requested iD PZ2023-375. Commissioner Bell seconded the motion. Additional discussion followed concerning adding a condition to secure the lattice to the residence. The applicant approved of the condition recommended by the Commission. Commissioner Kelley revised the motion by moving to approve the request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to install lattice, as requested in PZ2023-375, with the following added condition: 1. 'The lattice be framed as to secure the lattice to the structure. Commissioner Bell seconded the motion. A roll call vote was taken. Acting Chair Makin -Aye; Commissioner Avery -Aye; Commissioner Bell -Aye; Commissioner Bet ubc-Aye; Commissioner Crawford -Aye; Commissioner Goodness - Aye; Conn-nissioner Kelley -Aye; Con-imissioner Sigee-Aye; Commissioner Templeton -Aye. The motion to approve the request carried 9.-0. 3) PZ2023-3844- A request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to expand a driveway. Applicant: Ricky Pinkston Location: 2555 Harrison Avenue Mrs. Luckcy presented the staff report. Ricky PiD-kston, is requesting a Certificate of Appropriateness to expand the driveway at 255 5 Harrison Avenue. The expansion would make the driveway twelve (12) feet in width starting at the property line extending to the rear of the strLicture, where the pave ment would expand to 28' in width. The expansion would not extend in front of the main structure. k Historic Landmark Commission October 9, 2023 The home is listed in the 1991 SPARE Beaumont Survey with its significance listed as ",/In exany)le of upj)ej- )niciclle c1ciss ho-1-1sing buillditring 1he Illorld lVal. H ercl ". Staffrecommended approval of the request with the following conditions: 1. The new pavemcnt shall con-iply with Section 28.03.024(1District area and height regulations of the City of Beaumont Code of Ordinances by maintaining a 2' offset from the side property line. 2. All applicable cmilts and inspections shall be obtained through the Building Codes Department. Slides of the suject property were shown. Brief discussion followed concerning location of the new pavement, along with the existing walkway from the front door. The applicant was not present. Commissioner Goodness moved to approve the request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to expand a driveway, as requested in file PZ2023-384, with the following conditions: 1. The new pavement shall comply with Section 28.03.024(18) District area and he regulations of the City of Beaumont Code of Ordinances by maintaining a 2' offset from the side property line. 2. All applicable permits and inspections shall be obtained through the Building Codes Department. Commissioner Sigee seconded the motioll. Additional discussion followed concerDing including a condition to disallow changes to the existing walkway from the front door. Commissioner Goodness revised the motion by moving to approve the request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to expand a driveway, as requested in file PZ2023-384, with the following conditionso. 1. The new pavement shall comply with Section 28.03.024(18) District area and height regulations of the City of Beaumont Code of Ordinances by maintaining a 2' offset from the side property line. 2. No changes to the existing walkway from the front door. 4 Historic Landmark Commission October 9, 2023 3. All applicable permits and inspections shall be obtained through the Building Codes Departnient. Commissioner Sigee seconded the motion. A roll call vote was taken. Acting Chair Makin -Aye; Commissioner Avery -Aye; COMMisSioner Bcll-Aye; Commissioner erube-Aye; Commissioner Crawford -Aye; Commissioner Goodness - Aye; Commissioner Kelley -Aye; Commissioner Sigee-Aye; Commissioner Templeton -Aye. The motion to approve the request. carried 9:0. 4) PZ2023-392-0 A request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to enclose and resize windows and change the front door. Applicant: Alberto Perez Location: 1955 Long Avenue Mrs. Luckey presented the staff report. Alberto Percz, is requesting a Certificate of Appropriateness to enclose and resize windows and change the front door to the home located at 1955 Long Avenue. He intends to change the front windows on the 11orth side of the Mollie from one large window into two 32x6O four (4) pane windows that are side by side. Ile intends to enclose two (2) windows on the west side of the structure, three (3) on the east and two (2) on the south side making for a total of seven (7) windows to be enclosed. The windows would be closed with alike siding to match the home. Lastly, Mr. Perez intends to change the front door from the existing solid craftsman style door to a craftsman style door with a transom light. The home could be classified as a National style home with its gable front and wing. This style was extremely popular in the south and typically featured a hall and parlor type entry. Most homes feature a large number of windows with prominent windows and shudders along the front gable and wing. Examples of National architecture details can be seen in A Field Guide to Anietican I-Iouses (McAlester et al., pgs. 92-93). The request to eliminate a number of windows on the sides of the home will substantially change the design of this structure. The request to change from one large window to two individual windows side by side would change the appearance of this structure, however, seems appropriate based oil the National architecture. 'I"he request to change the front door seems �tppropriate, with the design of the home. The home is not listed in the SPARE Beaumont Survey. Staff recommended denial of the request to eliminate the windows of the east and west sides of the structure and recommended approval of the request to eliminate the two (2) windows on the south of the home, change the front two (2) widows into four (4) individual windows, and to change the front door with the following conditions: 1. Removal of the windows to the south of the home shall be replaced with alike siding to match the home. 61 Historic Landmark Commission October 9, 2023 2. The shutters on the north side of the home shall be reinstalled after the alteration is complete. 3. The front door shall be approved by Planiiing Staff before installation. 4. All applicable permits and inspections shall be obtained through the Building Codes Departn-tent. Slides of the subjcct property were, shown. Brief discussion followed concerning the color of the siding, the shutters, and specifics of the request. The applicant was not present. Conmil ss loner Goodness moved to approvc the request to for a Certificate of Appropriateness to enclose and resize windows and change the front door, as rcquested in PZ2023-392, with the following conditions: 1. "Ilo enclose only the two (2) windows on the SOLIth (rear of the structure), the bathroom window, and the window to the rear bedroom on the east side to be replaccd with a like siding to match the home. 2. The shutters on the north side of the home shall be reinstalled after the alteration is complete. 3. The front door shall be approved by Plaiming Staff before installation. 4. All applicable permits and inspections shall be obtained through the Buildhig Codes Department. Commissioner Templeton seconded the motion. A roll call vote was taken. Acting Chair Makin -Aye; Commissioner Avery -Aye; Commissioner Bell -Aye; Commissioner Berube-Aye; Commissioner Crawford -Aye; Coniii-iissioner Goodness - Aye; Commissioner Kelley -Aye; Commissioner Sigec-Aye; Conimissioner Ten-lpleton-Aye. The motion to approve the request carried 9:0. HISTORIC DISTIUCT CODE ENFORCEMENT REPDXf Mrs. Randle presented the Historic District Code Enforcement Report. 0 Historic Landmark Commissim October 9, 2023 Mrs. Luckey announced that the applicant for Agenda Item No. I (PZ2023-329) was now present should the Commission licave questions relating to the request. The Commission had no questiolis for the applicant. OTHER BUSINESS THERE BEING NO OTHER BUSINESS, THE MEETING WAS ADJOURNED AT 4:07 PIM. VJ DATE: November 13, 2023 TO: Historic Landmark. Commission FROM: E1aynaLurkn» Planner SU BJ ECT: A request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to construct two duplexes. FILE: PZ2023-340 STAFF REPORT Property owner Cornell Price, ofCMP3Enterprises UZhas requested aCertificate of Appropriateness to allow the construction of two duplexes on property located at 2490 Liberty Avenue at the corner of Liberty and 9th Street. The proposed construction methods employed would dictate that the two story structures will beconstructed onaslab foundation with wood framing. The siding will beofaIxBx12profile and made of HardiPlank with a proposed body color of Alabaster (SW 7008) and proposed trim color of Accessible Beige (SW 7036). The roof will be finished with weather wood 30-yenr architectural shingles. The orientation of the duplexes will have the proposed structures and attached garages facing 9tmStreet with the side ofthe structure facing Liberty Avenue. The site plan issubject toan approved Variance through the Board of Adjustment and the use of the lot for duplexes subject to approval of a Specific Use Permit by the Planning Commission and City Council. Planning staff recommends approval of the request, subject to the following conditions- l. Storm shutters beincluded for all upper windows and painted tomatch the structure. 2. All windows beone (l) over one /l\\nappearance. Exhibits are attached. SEAVMONT Planning & Community Development Case Type:Planning and Zoning Case StatLIS: INCOMPLETE Case Sub Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Tag Name: New multifamily construction Case M PZ2023-340 Initiated On: 818/2023 11:01:15AM Location: 2490 LIBERTY AVE, BEAUMONT, 77702 Individuals listed on the record: Applicant Cornell Price Home Phone: 4098329500 5610 Old Dowlen Rd Work Phone: Beaumont, TX 77706 Cell Phone: 4095539553 E-Mail- pricehomestx@gmail-coni Agent Cornell Price 5610 Old Dowlen Rd Beaumont, TX 77706 Home Phone: 4098329500 Work Phone: Cell Phone: 4095539553 E-Mail: pricehomestx@gmall.corn Property Owner Cornell Price Horne Phone: 4098329500 5610 Old Dowlen Rd Work Phone: Beaurnont, TX 77706 Cell Phone: 4095539553 E-Mail: pricehoniestx@gmail.com Reason for Request of a Certificate of New construction Appropriateness Paint y New Construction y Demo N Fencing N Miscellaneous N Has request been made before? N If yes, date: Notes: is isThis not a permit, additional permits juay be required for the proposed scope of work. Case Type: Planning and Zoning Page 1 of I Case #: PZ2023-340 Printed On- 10/25/2023 All F1 (OB-�l- 7�3 I I PASM 2 New Residential Structure Questionnaire for Oaks Historic District The goal of the district is to protect, preserve and enhance structures within historic areas, to stabilize and improve property values, foster civic pride and to promote the use of landmarks. Please take a moment to answer the following questions regarding your proposed new build within the bounds of the Oaks Historic District. This questionnaire should he filled out and submitted with your Certificate of Appropriateness application along with elevation drawings and site plans for the property. .0 Color of roof? Weather wood a Type of roof? (20/30 year arch shingles, etc) 30 yr Arch Shingles 0 Color of brick? (only relative to brick builds) N/A 0 Type of siding if not brick? (vinyl, hardy plank, etc) Hardy Plank 0 Color of siding? Alabaster 0 Profile of siding? (size of each piece) 1 x8xl 2 0 Color of trim? Acc;essllble Beige 0 Color of windows? White a Type and frame of windows? (vinyl, wood, aluminum, etc. 3/3, 6/6, 1/1, etc) Vinyl windstorm Argon Gas Windows /Al.I..CJJIIJIC DCI6C FULL DETAILS \/ Unlike many beiges, this color has undertones of graythat can give your space a warm, snug feel. Pair with earthy tones,, Get this color in a: Color Sample Paint Sample '0>C1 O Interior Paint Exterior Paint Color > White Paint Colors > SW 7008 Alabaster SW 7005 SW 7008 SW 7566 SW 7570 SW 71 April 2022 Color of the Month SW 7008 Alabaster FULL DETAILS \/ When you want the brightness of a white without sacrificing a warm coziness, try this soft, warm but balanced white. And turn up the peaceful, Get this color in a: Color Sample Steel Prehung Right -Hand Inswing Front Door (220) DATE: November 13, 2023 TO: Historic Landmark Commission FROM: E|aynaLurkp« Planner SUBJECT: Request for revoke aCertificate ofAppropriateness for expansion ofadriveway. FILE: PZ2023-384 STAFF REPORT The City of Beaumont is requesting to revoke a Certificate of Appropriateness to expand the driveway at 255SHarrison Avenue. The request comes following the discovery that the applicant had mistakenly applied for a Certificate of Appropriateness for the wrong address of where the work {sintended. : corrected application has been submitted and will bebefore you Staff recommends approval of the request. DATE: November 13,2023 TO: Historic Landmark Commission FROM. BaynaLucke» Planner SUBJECT: A request for a Certificate of Demolition to demolish a house. F.LE: PZ2023-403 STAFF REPORT Boyd Meier, Building Official, requests aCertificate of Demolition for the house located at 2370 Pecos Street. According to the inspection report) this structure was originally taggedon]uneq' 2O23after damage from afire. The structure received substantial damage such asacollapsed ceiling, rafter damage, the rear roof and walls completely destroyed with substantial smoke damage to the remainder of the structure, making it considered unsafe for human occupancy. Based on the extensive repairs needed for this structure the Building [odes Staff is recommending araze order. Planning staff recommends approval of this request. The property isnot listed |nthe SPARE Beaumont Survey, and the owner has signed the Demolition Consent. PUBLIC NOTIFICATION Notices mailed to property owners 17 . Responses in Favor______. Responses inOpposition. ____ Exhibits are attached. B EAV MO NT Planning & Community Development Case Type:Planning and Zoning Case Status: REVIEW Case Sub Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Taal Name: RED TAG HOUSE Case It: PZ2023-403 Initiated On: 9/2712023 1-41:28PM Location: 2370 PECOS ST, BEAUMONT, 77702 Individuals listed on the record: Reason for Request of a Certificate of Appropriateness Paint New Construction Demo Fencing Miscellaneous Has request been made before? If yes, date: Notes: Home Phone: Work Phone: Cell Phone: E-Mail: OWNER SIGNED A DEMOLITION CONSENT AND THE STRUCTURE IS FIRE BURNED N N Y N N N This is not a building peg rnit, additional permits maybe required for the proposed scope of work. Case Type: Planning and Zoning Page 1 of 1 Case #: PZ2023-403 Printed On: lOY20/2023 SUBSTANDARD BUILDING INSPECTION REPORT BUILDING CODS DIVISION CITY OF BEAUMONT ADDRESS OF STRUCTURE: 2370 PECOS OWNER: STEVEN RUSSELL OWNER ADDRE SS: 7315 BROMPTON ST APT 155 B HOUSTON, TX 77025 TAXES ONNIJD: Market Value: Fire damaged? Property was Red Tagged on: Owner enrolled in Pre -Council Work Program? $0.00 $74,254,00 YES 06/09/2023 DESCRIPTION OF PROPERTY: The structure is -fire burned and smoke dama . The roof and. walls in the rear will have to be replaced. The ceiling has coil n,)sed. The rafters are alligatored. The back of the house will have to be coma betel rebuilt. The owner did # 15 S114n. a demolition consent. Based on the extensive repairs needed in this strueture, staff is recommendinf, a raze order for this structure. I L r Jun 9, 2023. at 9:4:1 qr t t x Ala a 1 a ' p.. [A i . a � e , 11 i1f i■y'l{}�}y�ji�i T t- {a r � r s Ilk32 '1' 3.`�iT1' -�,- 11pr��• I 91hlA '44 1. f •" YtI. ' C:•" r `- r d µ• tf i n r 7i #�N °I�-fi *� F 7 1' , �{.l '#•• ,r '� - r �' 4. - i'�f .� l' 'p+ +{.;4�PP i k _ 4 1 ; +"�'`�=�� ) 1 �+ ''F 4 •; � �y�,_�. _r.— 1.yhk{1 d'+f,*tT F r.. ,r t •�} Lb' �'.�.t �°, y3 +•E S�F_ do ,- 1 f ��. ,. �f ��. .% � �', ° .r'� r� x ��.��' 1 � i r '��' ,t �'i Y�� x ,1•,i �{ �}{ � ��,�ti' �. 1- �d r+ y'a,� •r 3 f 1 N_! I y p4� 1 4�f t1t t �r c +< "}lk yl �} .. +� ' l �.'.�". x ir�.f ' `d , '{ L •d /" t- 1' `.h Fr. '- *a�.�til�= .L:`� "ti il Y J► j #� r ALI ' °►�s :.ak- � I N ' nl � t 4l � — + }r � ,�`'YrJ i fk t T, �.}, r° i�.'1. __ M -'� p1��k11 •!.Y Irl a I• � � ..'�I f' �•- fi. . ff o{r I V t, �F r ,• yr�lp #, — ..�.- �k. — _ t ' 4 'J + ♦ y'r'�t-�i' ' �i�91� L — 1 i�'�• f+. ra •fig i ,Y ' I'- - 'pie ��j � + di -�.. Nil 4 +: r }; -"`- (i�p+ d+I�p �fyJ,�u- • � ,�, 5 ��._ r .'N �, Y'F � i� I�r �N 'F� J ' !'�" , [' �+1. •',. �� 1'Fd �. `, � �,, - .J , v li• PL i[I �I I ;R L ri - r + �Y �5r '.� ! S h r`" 1y -Jf x �.I M - ' I�. r r''r%.5 � _:!i_ r" 11 •F '� j}• . �F , �1L I r + !v"i.—.i1 t- ��'��. 1 .•'�' ��• � ,�: I. -- '' '�' �l.;1�P,{.lri1l�I�r41�r p�' � � �� .�_� (J 9+.4 I �. ,�,�ry.°i�r�''M �. � �_ `�.��` f� A.� �, k r r-,.+ �+ °I f L �r� �+k6F�4�1 ,�I�� i #'�..,.. �;•" it *�, 'w.��r ''�. , . I 4, '� .i""r• "i'ff. 1��11`.`'!`r , - i , a `{ i T! °i �I��7. 1�1J"1:1a41i�lif J,r1 • ,r��I+ a `' `�' ` * ,y it p•■l1#I 1#Ir 1q IjL ."�''''► • a f + J' ��i -.. l' +'" d° _ '=r� + , IV i�r�e ' 11 N .. L .1��F� �`Y ��. Yt Jill.' 'f' I r -- �rrp �f�lI1�Ir�Fji+ r iii 5,d I �� , `Fir „ }• � � • _� �`� � -t `� ip �iiI.I�Ir�'I• ;Ig+I} I # � dfjy�—fl ii�1,li- l�� `� � _-r 1 � _ �" � �� .6 #� - * #.. .� '. � .4 r �., I L' , 4 n irJ�.�l .%; .� i Y _ `Y-��° r/� '{� {`.�..��a �� I � � s,� � f � •4 tA ��k •.1� .� . � {y�;�.. �-4�i �5 °�j Y'ti�� . f " ]� .f• �-,7 N 7. .ri ,•r � _ _. � r(-� 1 •� r i ��F �,a L1� � ! �,}`�p+ Nr- 4 �3}, J r ,� '•3 �yti , -� j - � �; � '� °��#* al _ ++"f Y +� t .�_ +ill°� ,.�+�}y .•e rl��. �r,, J3.� �� "� .1�4�, Y � i' '`�i� j - � - tiN t DATE: November 13, 2023 TO: Historic Landmark Commission FROM: E]aynaLucke« Planner SUBJ5CT: Arequest for aCertificate ofAppropriateness tochange all windows and the exterior doors. FILE: PZ2023-425 STAFF REPORT Tina Ellis, onbehalf ofthe property owner Melvin Taylor, has requested aCertificate of Appropriateness to allow the renovation of the home located at 2570 Rusk Street through the Texas General Land Office Harvey Recovery Program. The applicant is requesting to remove all of the existing four (4) over one wood window and replace them with one over one windows. Additionally, the existing exterior doors would be removed and replaced with a solid six (6) panel exterior door. The home seems to be constructed with the Inspiration of Tudor architecture with its multiple front gables, steeply pitched side gable, rounded porch entry and brick detailing around decorative edges, however lacks the grandeur details of the architecture. Examples of the Tudor details as described can he seen in AFie/d Guide to American Houses (McAlester et o)., pgs.355-358). |nreviewing the examples, multi -pane windows appear tobefeatured throughout the Tudor home examples, making the request to change the windows to one over one seem inappropriate. Planning staff recommends approval of the request with the following conditions: 1. The front door installed, be painted to match the trim and accents of the structure. 2. The windows are replaced to include the mulling strips to give the appearance of the original four (4)over one wlndow's. The property is not listed in the SPARE Beaumont Survey. Exhibits are attached. McAlester, Virginia uLee. A Field Guide mAmerican Houses. Alfred A.Knopf, m�1994. Print BEAVMONT Planning & Community Development Case Type:Planning and Zoning Case Sub Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Case #: PZ2023-425 Location: 2570 RUSK ST, BEAUMONT, 77702 Individuals listed on the record: Applicant Tina Ellis PO Box 813 Conroe, TX 77305 Agent Tina Ellis PO Box 813 Conroe, TX 77305 Property Owner Melvin Taylor 2570 Rusk St Beaumont, TX 77702 Reason for Request of a Certificate of Appropriateness Paint New Construction Demo Fencing Miscellaneous Has request been made before? If yes, date; Notes: Case Status. REVIEW Tag Name: Repair damaged home Linder the Harvey Recovery Program Initiated On: 10/11/2023 10:37:14A11 Home Phone: 9365886331 Work Phone: Cell Phone: 8322214643 E-Mail: pei-mits@rmqconst.com Home Phone: 9365886331 Work Phone: Cell Phone: 8322214643 E-Mail: permits@ri-nqconst.com Home Phone: 4098935403 Work Phone: Cell Phone: E-Mail: Permit is on hold until I receive a Certificate of Appropriateness to repair damaged home under the Harvey Recovery Program Changing all windows to wood 111 windows, and replacing transom light front door with solid front door. Y N N N Y N & This is not a building permit, additional permits may be required for the proposed scope of work. Case Type: Planning and Zoning Page I of I Case #: PZ2023-425 Printed On: 10125/2023 10/20/23,1:22 PM McCoy's Building Supply a My Store: San Marcos Open Today lam-7pm 9 Home / Doors & Windows / Exterior Doors / Front Entry Doors McCoy's 36 in x 80 in, 6 Panel, Steel, Prehung Door, Left Hand, Yellow Zinc Hinges Skin 1407042 $246,99 $1 PayPell Pay in 4 interest -free payments of $61.75. Learn more Add To Cart 1 Available at SAN MARCOS Location: Aisle 24 More OpLions Description McCOYS Pr hung Door, Insulated, Double Bore, Door Handing: Inswin L I V E C 11 NY Material Thickness, 38 in Opening Width, 82 in Opening Height, 36 in \A https://www.mccoys.com/shop/p]1407042/36-in-x-80-iii-6-panel-steel-preliutig-door-left-haiid-yellow-zinc-hinges 113 DATE: November 13, 2023 TO: Historic Landmark Commission FROM: Elayna Luckey, Planner I SUBJECT: Arequest for eCertificate ofDemolition todemolish ehouse. FILE: PZ2073'434 STAFF REPORT Boyd Meier, Building Official, requests a Certificate of Demolition for the house located at 2070 Pecos Street. According to the inspection report, this structure was originally tagged on June 9, ZO23after damage from afire. The structure received substantial damage byasecond fire |n October leaving the already damaged structure more than seventy (70) percent damaged according the Beaumont Fire Department, leaving it considered as a total loss and unsafe for human occupancy. Based on the extensive repairs needed for this structure the Building Codes Staff is recommending araze order. Planning staff recornmends approval of this request. The property is not listed in the SPARE Beaumont Survey. PUBLIC NOTIFICATION Notices mailed to property owners 25 - Responses in Favor . Responses in Opposition _. Exhibits are attached. BEAUMONT Planning & Community Development Case Type:Planning and Zoning Case Status: REVIEW Case Sub Type: Cerfiricate of Appropriateness Tag Name: Case #: PZ2023-434 Initiated On: 10/18/2023 12:54:26PM Location: 2070 PE COS ST, BEAUMONT, 77701 Individuals listed on the record. - Applicant CITY OF BEAU FONT Home Phone: DELANC'WOOD Work Phone: 409-785-3043 801 MAIN ST Cell Phone: BEAUMONT, TX 77701 E-Mail: Reason for Request of a Certificate of Appropriateness Paint New Construction Demo Fencing Miscellaneous Has request been made before? If yes, date: HOUSE HAS CAUGHT FIRE TWICE N N y N N N Notes: Date: 10118/2023, Written By: Delancy Wood THIS HOUSE CAUGHT FIRE AND WAS RED TAGGED FOR DEMOLITION. THE HOUSE HAS SINCE BEEN BURNED A SECOND TIME EVEN THOUGH THERE ARE NO UTILITIES GOING TO IT. 46 This is not a building permit, additional permits may be required for the proposed scope of work. Case Type: Planning and Zoning Page 1 of I Case #: PZ2023-434 Printed On: 10/20/2023 IL ! i• I E ! - • - '-� f )L - Ar ■• a �}� , #.s �Y+1 � .,' �'�,� yf! 'f J �`' 4 i 1Ti• alb 4�f r °l{fr 4 'J tit {{� i • r'. J i 'Lk� ¢} ��y�a,.�'y} k_'�` 1 r� '� iy~ r3 ram, 't -! •,,,_' _ �!' ��F- '�,. - ° �' - �.�i' I �.r .•r i�y,1 f � +ti �• �}� 4 P + •� ri +:*1�.y4�EwS rQk^s+i - �' ry * � 4��'r wry, •'�.- � I • -�� f �l �_ Sri r. .f r � �� _ _.� .� • !ti1�� 7 l " 1� 1 . �y i -•-i �� +,ram .� i� R j - p ♦�. f 1FJ (J rI�/./ -= 1 1k-...kIL ■ `X fi. *1 sir i+ L r? ' ZIP rrSrjJ�9+m; kM1 gyp'• F 4.a &,t,k MP-:�•jF*r•% '^.{:�-'..4'Y 'f ' !, r ; S''rr •'i.'[ -'4 '; "•,.. ' 1 # t4' k#, • _ 5 5 4-.: k■,i` 1 y?i;, •'r - r '1 f T° + ` J ,y"t%•S� • , "!' 1i! ifai•a�..44+-tii'S 4�"' • tit't •r :,F + ih'� •i } t ` h � Jr'%a r• � , F '1 , � , ' T. i} •�. i � � 5 ��.' # �_ 1 .eta 1 ' _P t S� 1~`• .. fFt a.°��L^i.$_�l. ;+� 'I # °'M 1 ": � p f'� .•a- •'{, _ • f'1 r_� �° � ar�,i+f4��itj'`+_ yI' r' r' f A •ram ' i f l . C f'� -�� - #` � r � 'a is �� / +,-'� d� 1 ti-trLi r<.'� J,•s� "'Tri li ��.,'y�rc� 4 d i._•� ,+Rf � •P :! �F .Ik -:,s ��+ °� L � _ '-,•��F�'��} � aa� ilk � I ,# ' � � ! � r }� C' k .� '4• � � ,i�,«2' ': y - M! i 1. 'a, 'A' Y •,��.r' L•• �• � IJ 51L y a ' � ••lam 4 ;T��rt j�> 4 k J'�7 ��,� �4-' x. � fps ar f 11 r 1 f _ #} : yj • �,4 }. xY X - ' "' +y _ .y i�i i. q _;Li i' ` f • yµ ■ -.-} ^ -Dr 711W. t + a x { 4 • _+ �r i ' (;i ' S is AV S ' '• / �e 9e ,rE 'r `e t 14 1 `Jeffl�gl- 1+1}x■�.il� •� qr ••W+ ti IF {[,7 r !�!i flE 11�' I {.■7� r � � f 55� .l { .`� �t s - ?L'' l ° a e F 4 i P ,7/j'� i.7r■'t?., �i 4•\ �' `lam `� � •i ,. �- y Wk ilk. r; 1 �r +�+Y.• �. _-� 5 - vt KL XSSS�fff555i� # 1{• is i`•''-1� ; •`F/} }•I'a}.�+f*� '� ,_r pie }P ,t •.I#may �_y+�'.k -� T�#'-S r• •y #e' �1t�r' L - • :Je� I E,i- _ _- _ V�y`��yI Fk A .• � ! � ��■�r r�a_ � ti ! � Iwo 1 � °�' - 'ti. ° 1.-'.J'+.l_i �.: IL rk off ` l � ` 1P +4 *E�iM1�•,.-1.-i1t •4° a e�'�` F'} fl-pi fiG�-°L1 y ,Z°, y#.•- i ..'4 .,q M r tiA...IrHIP a•E �` � • .r � �•�F i�w; e+'•-+"y:fsf „''� •c. E� `'`{ .}' t4��r■ + f i :, �'f : I -• , .�-• y } � - r * • ; J� � s `ram'.'' P rr�: �I, �k: E-PvES-* �q;}.k`�• • .5, ,1 F �¢.��#�°�' �`+i'!'+�" F t q t Cr kt; •r4' j�Tlkr 3. it L I I•'f_ {+ I 'fir.r'�{+, A � _i';i �'�j�' _ ,�:J}{��,�- -'.� t�• - ! 9� #rl*I s .-, ,a• t" Y� 6.' 11F'I- AN 41 'T Pk`V'al'i'�d�Ar i ,, e -- i6 4, , e # ! r - r - .,,,•+ 4 .a.ti_ ki ��R;� !* �R�} ` •. t.�_°_:, -. * .� i, ;. - ��.. +��, t F i'.F� 4 � � - '-i r. �° , - _ '}r ��. LL.� y4��._+.r . + Y �'s- I+� a k J. F' •fLf'.•.'1'�il'_;5• r }j•■ g3�41Ts''1�' - . cc'.1i f*3. as �T f -% .4L tl�t _ 5'� -r ►• :�r v ik+r {. ati" f P P +�-• ti ° i *' 4 r try` ��. ,k "i��i� - - �- � r+j" - � �� ■ T#�' ��F � � F ra +� On 'RLWF�,4F r Ji`� - ' ,• s�..5_ ,.;� Y.-fi '.�i �+. �l .�v`.',ia}".t "F d �.-r- %� i i ..; ? `-- f - J-7" ,db• - .1 ' ^h aR'.' v y3-�� - r 4JWy i_Y �•?+� - 4�t #� s�}:n air T T w -�;a 1"�'i .r, `. a}- 4'q4 + _ a it PL ° t N rq'.1 4:'#�t ?r .� yl � - : tlr a �,` � i -� • } S y�. '� � .q� � P '1 � !`+F 7�� '� I� ' �-•� 'kid' '•=�,'� 'a �� •t 4 .�Y{, y_7 +r[..- rat _, K {.x.'•�I"}a ..u_� a M1 , �iV _ fid ]S ,y$_ _ _ _i•r +�r��`'��'-a54��x;�x. , J�_+ °i.`_ ,M1 i4 ,t{,..lR •ti yr.r� Y c r .tit IL y•x f' ri �NNW�.. t "� 1 �1_ 5 1 }' �5a- ~ ♦ 1'•y�`d' .P-• "' + ~r€'i,.; SR: `t •r• •'�-,•,�s" }�,�. � i-y ,c �i k�'' ALy r � 4 i i eP. 3A -� � � i � --.��: -�4 4�� '#��;?� •�,�, "f:�� F�+��,�g� 'I, �'' `#' �'r 1 � �' �;.' � �.�x 4�+ per# t�,a a �r�=!'r,4+��f lr, .{ " �d "! j� !}!�1}5`*y�h-`s �+a�' -' _ MJh ".,�`r� i � �sP�a. w�l�}l�I-rti .�� '��- � i , e � � y • tl '� t ' � t � l , a. i , � r 4 4 tFI,`4. I� i.• d"�.1� �; r#yz"f -_ewy� _"•��y-ryj1'��p1.11-�4�`_a .51:'"'ta d d ' y �'"f/i1 y� F. } a tl JAMp[-.1 11 'L.r + * �r a p , `E' if .y lfiM�i lliR ''*\•''=-tR ■,s• t,�-ii`ss . sa3a' .P _ 4_ ,k� ., y `;+�fi' ,�.`f `'_. 's,!•:i• •, '},t,... i'S.'F t.M1u ,5 i r� '`1 {.-�, +„.a1e-; tl 9 'A'tT,� � i� 2y14 ■/.r r • � r �' l `■ .,"J'k �'' ''r5 • a F�� # .� r� d G i f '�7�a s� - � • "/ . `� ■ ° .. 1 a R � � M1 f ---�i�P` r rIF '�i"~44. f1V bt fA �•i�l err �'r.ry.�' 1 - .�q'� ��JP V1tl6 I` P L° _ s' s}}do- .� .'d y •t p`f��i'� �1..FtaR it i,' ;�.ial,�S. �j+14}° _ - • 1�. .'�,'a'" 1ix�}� jai Pr rya cx `i It F. • ; `` Lf 7 i47 '' rl {,;'i F. _+ k' -ate ��,�v� L _ y+F �; ;{ R�'1f\� 1�� R` 5S' �•k � + ' �� Y �i` " r-� •�� 4 w��' �j�i� �; �� •�- '�, F 1 F, _ �f-� � ` ter+ ��. }t ` "i_� °• *" .�° „�:�,' [. �[a'_y+4. Yea. s+.'+� - tqq a 1Y1�'►ii4�/t j i tliryy-•• y, tl fs .10 IV ■ b 1 #`'' `1.y 'f y��l ••Lr-�f�i�i 51:'#_ _ " �_f w..�[, '' f[Pi i��k�+�Y -k�a�'•J�'�' P ' F ,�•, F :9 5 � w y'1' ,� #* � t R 1+, }��1 - Vie- ak��,,+y� �'' �.�.+fri +{•'`er y1Ys4Lf .14:y:}#y-i�a R'i. i�-• .�� #`�1 �'t'Iti. k�54 � fT'� r{ 1 - t "F�" �P�+ �,�.t �11 � -�x?�� ..•;#�b'-""�y��.4 � , I �r� i a:�-,Cl :eF_Ikk AI .v'`+,`.A -f f •; k {, }fit ,►. _k �'' :�; a�F t�.`'Ivy5� I'�` ��' -,k ►+•,"'P '1i[,�7,�� •J�.� ;��{j��:,,�P+,.P;.4. ; ',"j�,�'Ja .f f y +'tl� , ��y'1�+} • r ` •fad'. �4'� 4' °�"L! P � I�FI} 1 # 4��4.'FiF 1'4' - # 5 ' "� •1' f .i ar"#i_ °FIN ' 1 P.. i �`,• +F�* i.•i _ . a, •. f �� F.�°' i ar, _ •' Zll At sMY`tl i 5 - - } :r ' 1 r . . � �*#.�, •" • � � :'k ' .'�` S � �l a ;�.54 r [ f: -+% � r � + __ �=�[�',e�•~ • nip '�`. w • L�t r'L 'tft r e PFF ill � �P t I# h leIL �' k -ii1�' ._, ' `' . �� ii � �� ,� lri,�,,.,, rK�`�'��++•1��`��x, �'}f ° �1 -ifF # � '� + _ 7 •'}�,". � �� '�' .+'" ' " y'' M1;'►'F•w.�F�.ti,y a : 4 ° �1. P' �r.# Je, � � �' y _ � �� , �.4 , #.'7 5i 4+1# �� F. k,.eL� • f '� ti i Y _Ap#'" 5 y' �`,. 4 y y•�� '� 'i L# q F i ! 5 t ■ 'i� * ' 61 '#e tlj 5 '•asiid``� Fi i��I DATE: November 13, 2023 TO: Historic Landmark Commission FROM: Elayna Luckey, Planner I SUBJECT: Request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to expand a driveway. FILE: PZ2023-438 STAFF REPORT Ricky Pinkston, is requesting a Certificate of Appropriateness to expand the driveway at 2255 Harrison Avenue. The expansion would make the driveway twelve (12) feet in width starting at the property line extending to the rear of the structure, where the pavement would expand to 28' in width. The expansion would not extend in front of the main structure. Staff recommends approval of the request with the following conditions: 1. The new pavement shall comply with Section 28.03.024(18) District area and height regulations of the City of Beaumont Code of Ordinances by maintaining a 2' offset from the side property line. 2. All applicable permits and inspections shall be obtained through the Building Codes Department. The home is not listed in the SPARE Beaumont Survey. Exhibits are attached. B EAV 1V1C3 N T Planning & Community Development Case Type: Planning and Zoning Case Status: REVIEW Case Sub Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Tag Name: replace windows, paint exterior, replace Case #: PZ2023-438 damaged siding Location: 2255 HARRISON AVE, BEAUMONT, 77701 Initiated On: 10120/2023 4:05:25PM Individuals listed on the record: Applicant Ricky Pinkston 2293 North St Beaumont, TX 77701 Agent Ricky Pinkston 2293 North St Beaumont, TX 77701 Property Owner Home Phone: 8322294445 Work Phone* Cell Phone: 8322294445 E-Mail: rickypinkston@aol.com Home Phone: 8322294445 Work Phone: Cell Phone: 8322294445 E-Mail: rickypinkston@aol.com Ricky Pinkston Home Phone: 8322294445 2293 North St Work Phone: Beaumont, TX 77701 Cell Phone: 8322294445 E-Mail- rickypinkston@aol.com Reason for Request of a Certificate of 1. replace 15 windows with same style white vinyl windows. 2. paint Appropriateness exterior same body and door color and change trim to white. 2. replace damaged siding w/same sized wood siding 3. expand driveway to 12' Paint Y New Construction N Demo N Fencing N Miscellaneous Y Has request been made before? N If yes, date: Notes: This is not a building permit, additional permits may be required for the proposed scope of work* Case Type: Planning and Zoning Page I of i Case #: PZ2023-438 Printed On: 10/31/2023 2255 Harrison Driveway Sketch Concrete driveway will replace same area as old driveway but will b e 4'wider. 2255 Harrison Window Sketch 0 15 windows total 3 windows : I lite fixed style north side of house lower floor 12 remaining windows : 6/6 lies style Color :. white Placement; same as existing Style: same as existing Upper Floor X X X A Main Floor X X X