The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink AboutPZ2023-392DATE: October 9, 2023 TO: Historic Landmark Commission FROM: 8aynaLuckey, Planner | SUBJECT: Request for a Certificate of Appropriateness to enclose and res ze windows and change the front door. FILE: PZ2023-382 STAFF REPORT Alberto Perez is requesting a Certificate of Appropriateness to enclose and res|ne windows and changethe frontdoor tothe honnelocated atl9S5LonoAvenue.Helntendsto changethe front windows on the north side of the home from one large window into two 32x6O four (4) pane windows that are side by side. He intends to enclose two (2) windows on the west side of the structure, three (3) on the east and two (2) on the south side making for a total of seven (7) windows to be enclosed. The windows would be closed with alike slding to match the home. Lastly, Mr. Perez intends to change the front door from the existing solid craftsman style door toacraftsman style door with atransomn light. The home could be classified as a National style home with its gable front and wing. This style was extremely popular in the south and typically featured a hall and parlor type entry. Most homes feature a large number of windows with prominent windows and shudders along the front gable and wing. Examples of National architecture details can be seen in Fie/dGu/de to American Houses (McAlester et al., pgs. 92-93). The request to eliminate a number of windows on the sides of the home will substantially change the design, of this structure. The request to change from one large window to two individual windows side by side would change the appearance of this structure, however, seems appropriate based on the National architecture. The request to change the front door seems appropriate, with the design ofthe home. Staff recommends denial of the request to eliminate the windows on the east and west sides of south of the homel change the front two (2) widows into four (4) individual windows, and to change the front door with the following conditions: 1. Removal of the windows to the south of the home shall be replaced with alike siding to match the home. 2. The shutters on the north side of the home sharll be reinstalled after the alteration is 3. 'The front door shall be approved by Planning Staff before installation. 4. All applicable pernnits and inspections shall be obtained through the Building Codes The home is not listed in the SPARE Beaumont Survey. Exhibits are attached. B EAV IrAC3 NT Planning & Community Development Case Type:Planning and Zoning Case Status: REVIEW Case Sub Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Tag Name: alterations to 1955 Long ST Case #: PZ2023-392 Initiated On: 9/20/2023 3:39:17PM Location: 1955 LONG AVE, BEAUMONT, 77701 Individuals listed on the record. - Applicant alberto perez Home Phone-, 1955 long ave Work Phone: Beaumont, TX 77701 Cell Phone, 4092847785 E-Mail: albertop70l@gmail.com Reason for Request of a Certificate of close 7 windows, replace 9 windows with 1/1 to match size, change Appropriateness the front windows to two 32x6O instead of 1 large window, replace siding, change front door, level structure Paint N New Construction N Demo N Fencing N Miscellaneous Y Has request been made before? N If yes, data: Notes: This is not a building permit, additional permits may be required for the proposed scope of work. Case Type- Planning and Zoning Page 1 of 1 Case #. PZ2023-392 Printed On: 9/2212023 L ��a r � 1 �� if a � l �iJ ! � �� e � f f f } 1 e� �,� � � . _ � _ _ e r • �i �� µ +;kf� ti � ,. Ajjjj _ I 1 # • 1 4 � a y j` ' i [ I I It . I s - X k t 6 a ` V)F% 0 IL p -4- • IN, d' A NL k mmmmw� 17 T" I�A J A p 7!—A -I f-X -A $7-11. , 4P %-J-k -.ddr kv— L Ly 5d dk, Ot .L 'd FI k AIA 'X1 • J p F d - z IL P 4F 4 • e 416{'t Y;M - J. L ILI, fA 4 VIVA 4L' j 1 - % " %� " t..k : , N - - .k � ;� . ji 3 "M A 3 Avi p yf A t 4 4 -ZI.Am I .) , �� PINT k, r A YNf 1 11% 1 IN t. - r Wj rkW1 1, ir 'y 1 -4 1, lip 0 4 .0 X-x 4L I Fiji Hai �, � r � �o / 1 � -�- ■ \.� ' 4 �4i.0 I IL. A , k N -J1 tT ;f,k Ir Ilk- a s Z, p 71 01 ko 4L t r Ps p AA i �t*°y f•�� f' 4 b3a �+C�S �Y� �,■ - - t ! � I r ,I Y, p .l .x#� ��i�F ��l ■a {{Ply' . r. - F'_ , �� + a ,. JL -* " , r 1 a • , � ' - _ � y�7 P � ��,, ` �. �1 f�� x+, i.T .�_%� ,�� / 1 �.�f��•y �11 ,� i � �,. r •. � _ ° i yt�' 5 ��i `« �'�e�':.i4 .��4 y�� . �j� fJae{.fti� f.. ��+ �� . ,. y*ds�.•. 'y �. � a f " �. - rt.a,r ' w�� ;. ��, �fF� �:� �_'►�'`P". � 7 .: �• �F ,F, e r _ � � i �� ' z .y 5 70� , i• yk � i rat f a. p �k M • a r '• i ., _r-' � �� ? tr 5 k • ■,�y ` ;,a ,��.. 11. �? 4.�r__..�s +{ �, i n-y ' f"'� � # y:r rt.' � r � , `�+• _ � *w i �e i r'�* � •`�� '►. , y s «� y ��' 1_' r, -��-�� +il��#��.�'1.�C�*�_'�•��.+'i .% �*�L*� a.lr *-i� ;+ +.�� .i' a I. r , _ . •a �, �"1{ �. r�..��<_� 4 '� t"}� #*a,, ■ +Fi }% f` "(� at /� r¥V ? + ?�„ti� f i , l 1 ; .yt+ i gyp. s a t _ _ s a ; I �,' � � ,��' w p �"ta �� ' 4 � , r F r r* 'r `;�' ., ,1i{ �. I _ � • _ +'i _ � _ S �� i+':�-w � �� it "#ir+°#"� �". `�ti' ■ •+�. .?.* •'I' �r• *r-��t +� « ,lrr 6 j "e# ,4 r. °� �� r �1 r -:at}*lira# }�1;�«Jr fY 't+` �_,�',-•'rf °r ,,.may' .,.��°-.T�',,•4.7• � « r�'r ,,�� [dl:.••i 'w-is�� , • Jr a F. � � - , �..i.... I t� r�,i- �' Y'A ��;. '1f. .� �. ■ ,' _,. c-. ,s *I�i t�� *'Y ro ir Ik =' 'a a,r - dr �°�'•F`! a r - 4 L �I'-}# Sy_ "'�° a -a° ,�. ' !;'.e`er' •i r .i ' • l y ' it t � r � in f • ' �Y�,' � �j* 1 � 'y� y` + - r r rp IFW �: �' I _ a :. � f1" �-- by � i � - � • S � l..,I $� .. I F �4 ! y. � � -Y � � � . ''�4 i IN + "4 pe. Nit 114r a JL t " do IL I AN I IL W4 IN I Op lk IF �� NV ,tq dr an Folk Houses. I , ational While AVI FAMILY GABLE -FRONT -AND urban fold�urldYng to the northeast, re � ile two—story gable -front louses dominated styled Greek e��ial ��+��, became commonin rural laced shape, also descended from I i ' 'i- orr7 an additional side -gabled ping was added at right angle t the gable-- . areas. In this f , G° give a compound, gable-front--and-wing shape. A she l-roofed porch ► as front plan t g + .' typically placed Within the i� grade by tile two wings. Beeaus these ��e�•e relatively large must 'iltn tine pre-�rail�-oad era had �r+eel dial detailing and and ample hou , per not folk houses. With the corning of the railroads, how r, abundant lumber end i balloon framing led to an expansion of uns.tyled folk houses with this form. Sorne ► 1�� g two front -gabled wing were added to simple hall -arid -parlor and 1-house- stages :. a t� � g e were t icall t ppe l in shape —that is, the roof ridge of the gable --front plans. 'rh s p portion was higher than tlle adjacent wing. More commonly, the enure structure was built s a unit with a roof ridge of uniform height. .` - house: of gable -front -and plan. became common only in the north Two-story g 'n the youth, however, traditional one-story, hall -and - eastern eastern and n�rd��resterl� states, s were frequentlybuilt with an added one-story, gable -front wing. These - parlor plan I; I ° on-stCI y, gable -front -and -wing houses had more flexible interior spaces than tile- typical southern hall -and -parlor an, arior lwhich they steadily replaced during the early decades of ° this century. These one-story form also became common, along with larger y distory . i areas of the expanding Midget and are the most �v�dely distrib- h e�cal�ls, �n adjacent �` j uted of the gable -front -and -win g family of shapes. I hj I I ° i . IG 1 S . .�_. I r lep II . I f I� I Yi I �y j I 92 National 0 i rc, Al F inn I GABLE -FRONT -AND -WING FAMILY 1. Plartwick, New York; late 19th century, photo 1914. Gardner House. Stepped example. Note the small attic windows, common on Greck Re- ,ival houses, on the right-hand wing, which was probably built first, with the gable -front portion added later. 2. North Collins, New York-, late 19th century. Stepped example. 3. Lawtons, New York, vicinityi late 19th century. 4. Belmont, New York; ca. igoo. 5. Fayetteville, Arkansas; ca. igio. 6. Seaford, Delaware; ca. 1947- Temple House. Late example inspired by t1le Minimal Traditional style of the 1940rs- 7. Chicago, Illinois; ca, ig5o. Late example inspired by the H-anch style of the 195O-S. z fi A" �} r I A .4 A 7 iL .4 —11'_'! `-A �-Ya L"A:' National 93