HomeMy WebLinkAboutPZ2023-366DATE: September 11, 2023
TO: Historic Landmark Commission
FROM: BaynaLuckey, Planner |
SUBJECT: Request for a Certificate of Appropriateness for a driveway.
F I_E` PZ2023-366
STAFF REPORT
Christy Williams is requesting permission to construct a driveway at her home located at 2485
Liberty Avenue. Included in your packet is a letter from Ms. Williams and a number of examples
of other drives within the district, along with her proposed plans B, C and Z.
Plan B` is a proposed circle drive that would be eight (8) feet wide with a small landscaping strip
separating it from the existing four (4)foot sidewalk located along Liberty. Speaking with our
Engineering department, they do not feel Plan B is feasible for construction with the space
available inthe front yard.
Plan C, is a proposed second drive to the property that features a hammer head in front of the
previously approved new entry, which would allow for a vehicle 1oturn exiting the property in a
forward motion. Speaking with our Engineering department this plan is feasible for
Plan Zisaproposed hammerhead, d|rectly off the existinOdhveway with ewa|kway tyinglnto
the previously approved entry and existing City sidewalk. This would allow for a vehicle to make
a turn exiting the property in a forward motion. Speaking with our Engineering department this
plan is also feasible for construction.
While it should be noted that Liberty and Laurel are one-way and tend to have high speed
traffic, most, if not all, circular drives predate the ordinance. In the last ten (10) years, the
commission has heard six (6) requests for circular drives. All were denied except for one on
structure. Additionally, a number of hammer heads have been requested in the past most
recently 1n2Ol7onUbe[ty thatwas denledfor iheproposedpad be1ng infrontofthehonme.
Staff recommends approval ofthe proposed driveway plan Casthe proposed driveway and
hammer head, could meet the requirements of engineering and the existing landscaping on the
property would screen the hammer head from the right-of-way rnln\rnaUy disturbing the
visibility of the property with the following conditions:
1. All applicable permits and inspections be obtained through the Building Codes
Department.
The house is not listed in the SPARE Beaumont Survey.
Exhibits are attached.
BEAVMC3NT
Planning & Community Development
Case Type: Planning and Zoning Case Status: REVIEW
Case Sub Type: Certificate of Appropriateness Tag Name: Addition of driveway to my property
Case #: PZ2023-366 Initiated On: 8/24/2023 8:05:49AM
Location: 2485 LIBERTY AVE, BEAU MONT, 77702
Individuals listed on the record:
Applicant
Christy Williams Home Phone,
2485 Liberty Ave for Phone:
Beaumont, Tx 77702 Cell Phone- 409 782-8086
E-Mail- Christybnit@yahoo.com
Reason for Request of a Certificate of
Appropriateness
Paint
New Construction
Demo
Fencing
Miscellaneous
Has request been made before?
If yes, date:
Notes.,
medical need to have second driveway to enter the street safely
N
N
N
N
y
N
This is not a building permit, additional permits may be required
for the proposed scope of work.
Case Type: Planning and Zoning Page 1 of I
Case #: PZ2023-366 Printed On: 8/25/2023
August 23, 2023
TO: Historic Landmark Commission
Request for: Certificate of Appropriateness
Address: 2485 Liberty Ave/St
Owner: Christy Williams
Chzist bmt ahoo.com
(409) 782-8086
FILE: PZ2023-
Reason for Change:
Due to medical reasons and my growing older, I know that I need to exit my property
its a foi-vcrard motion. Liberty Ave has increased it"s volume of vehicles incredibly since
the 1997 ordinance was passed that has limited adding these circle drives. z no longer
feel safe to back out into Liberty traffic. Perhaps now is the time, to consider changes
needed for current Historic Oaks residents, due to the increase in Liberty St. traffic,
At last month's board meeting, T requested (Plan A) a circular drive connected to the
sidewalk which was denied. I also presented (Plan B) an arched circular drive that is
separated from the sidewalk. This plan was not voted upon then. Plan B would allow
total forward movement as I enter Liberty Ave. T'he sidewalk would not be obstructed &
this drive would be used to leave the, property. Will the board today consider this Plan B
as the easiest and feast costly solution,
A Plan Z was presented by a board member, to add a "turn out" in front of my home
connected to my existing driveway. Upon considering "turn out" as an approvable
option, then I am requesting approval of Plan C, instead of Plan Z.
`Plan C will add a "turn out" as suggested, but on the left side of the home instead of
the right side. This left drive would connect to the approved deck off the legit front door
and connect to the street on the left side of my property. 1 could pull into this drive and
use the "turn out" to position my car to move forward off the propeity, The "turn out"
will be behind and to the left of the Tulip tree, in front of the Magnolia tree. I plan to
add more landscaping to camoflago the "turn out",
This Plan C will function as I need to exit the property safely.
I will price Plan C upon approval by this Board. If it is just too prohibited in cost, I
would like the Plan Z to be another option for me, as well as Plan B, of course.
Let -us please find the best solution.
Thank you kindly for your help! z plain to live here another 25 + years.
Sincerely,
Christy Williams
s
C Y+ T9
C +
f• ft /
!' 'r 5 '.
i
j 6 �#
fP,4l4
_
.7jqlg Xj1Rjyg5V
l kIlr
rovt oc�I r "'
V/vq
From
-- `�'' ��--� _� •tee--��- � • ,F.�
• OF
F,k+-r,4'-S/vv'
.sue..-• .--.-._,. �.�e-, .�,...,-: - -��.�
• .
r er OD r Q"'T471 JI
bd
....�� C. N 0"
LJENT-
�L20
J .10
I.
l
y 14 144
Y
Mot
ttr
c- "i
i jX
fir'/ r~ �' "� ...,
��.�..
CRT
(00,
T -A F`
DESCRIMOR OF SERVICM REUMFb;
Vi ce,,r"WWA4 P,
PEN
LUM
LA
4 IJlr +
if
• i
•4 _ Y ,
Y� �#Y 4�i ri' f F ' • � Y '+ , a «�
y�#
,Jrt�
.i r � i■��r�`-•'r j, Fa + i°� �1 �,fir�tf� T r. �' S l r���•" �r�•/��•��r•�1p'€� +�- '� • r1+
#f' 1� '
r Ol
3
IL
i. r+r*' #• ofagf ,' ! ■ 5' "' �k �c y I{.i , y �'fy MN •' -
tom• ,r5', +*y ,*`,.R• r�« • Al,
�ane+i . {�' '��+�,�..� �l/'-F iL j"'►.F ,a+ - r ! ,
a ,
a • ay..�.' A 1; d f" '` ;+ +_ . 4 Fr ! r s+rA r _ 1' - !R �'if
'~ • t a g 1 r � .i, +t ii� 1 _f.4t
'ia, ,,irt- 1. l �.`Je F=' `..a +.' �.:�+ r �fAa
r■ '} - r•I "..,++` , _ +f +. rr+ it 'I '+" e
•�� : .` •i°r .�+ - '}1 *' '! �
' +• ' � ! �I �rtyr.'�}° t, � `+ _ r �� Y ° ' � ,,�. ' ` F=�, tide * ��[�'Y•
d I'�,r _1 '•'. a r . tiF++
%
ti s,f err' Ial 1if 31! tiYR, 4*4 {r*!�� P �+r.,jy e 1
NP
Yll
_ I� ! --r°, f� *{r�4 '�� �*��5 {1 rye*�y�"* -F +�* i��. �r.� 7R �l�� ,i{ :r r " • 4 i ! �� �
" �J�7«� i.w � � ' Y�{F ir{ , r. �e + � + f '� x . rR � a kI +�' 'Y+-•I1 i
" #� .ilt el • s�fi a,S:;}. �°� 1 R, a� „r. }-
•„ 3i� }lr { , " I • }1�
�
n ,
,
in
40
h Ap
Ex—+ ir- 13
1 � `
f R'
fJ i
. _ "
,
r5 a 4 , t A _i R •" + i f,#''''�j �► rf-r,l'". yY. d ,'5 +T +,
lk
• �: *'4 r'r +}« ! . w. el fire + .-l- •r, * a.
a + _
wt-
! - k k +, f-, - r A T t - .. 'a^ •� i " _.'K�i r • #'+f _ 5 ` r „ y # Y
17
i«S"..i• 1 y. ` � - - ' " �.�� '{I ~T�'.,� - --. �-'-- Ft�'f-s rr'•��t p�-s - - e + _� ,r f ,.
° •' - 'I' ,•+ .*. - r` F V_i_. ti +c"i,rfR, i h ?I:� a. i'•s r
k�e44
. .�"`Rf _ # _ • I._,fi:. �� ♦ _"` - Yy,.+.R' ti- ! f �i'6.. r ..f� _ # rt
Sq _ -� a R.'a,.-. y`♦ ,+.� " rr''-y a'f r#r'. `y. 5r�..*EyF . r
�4 - y = r. �,r'yl •( JI J, •` �a� +
_ •.1 4.- a i, r7R a', Y
r I f
i���I ►. R# e , r{,t # �� —a;' .timlfc
J Pr�1 jjj +L" yI4� •Y '' . y - a f '!
- `_ � ���-I .T.�y i _ i r Jf !. "*3� JrJr'{; + _ f'r* fs Y , f *� ' +- �,�y •4Y} .�5, +ay.�� �,'� �"�+1_ e � _.
It
1� y'
_� iy+ f� 'f+ fit• ►`' +x"" }j'+, '
`.7'1/t*, r 1 ° { i' ', " 'V '• E."'*' _ .
�. _
y�1i�� *��-f'r��{s} . •��� �i;G}�y `l,�y •� - �1'
q f _13 ,!' } (+4 r'f f7 Tiff r
YY J + 'qk
W ;4% J.
r{•t y�Y �
'. �Y
? F 4
r
ZIF
•-v f`rL40.. r I
� *• + � ,.
r � y
'6pns._'_ -
M" J'r sP. �# `! T'{''it:`�:Y• A# .a —" �sL #* •`Ir' •iV►1�jy" a'i,Y *'. ,
�4
•, + '°-� �'� Wit,-+ "'�#, �*P!
rxw M.r 4- ye 4�?
y t
ti. k r ti
F JX`] f• yea yi,+-` li wJy ', - t. 'y + `.ef,`1.'
�. � •.l � a. _; � +�a
..j(#r � 9. -.s � .. ��fa���y � r' �` ice, `� /�- •�J`�1 � � � �~ � •+
7lk
r1, #art
`!_
�r"/ 1 .`i#}',�•`";�;'�*=,~`. i « ,'�}` ,1 ,{ e '
i7` _ rF ;
#r R ` r•e b a+�' * �Aw N
la�..
. ' # f �a _ y r+ Ir+•� f + y �t�,a i _;j -yif •,y .y y #J' •F�'t
a4 e. 1* I , 1 'A�, Y � i;3G� � Y� +�,y � a i : 4• � :7+- s' if ��� . �!� s� � �T
!
* i'a ,M t , kY+ + w�. n
16
,f+.1 , `{ Y lyk I'e ! . ,
'Y� +i'4 ,•j "y �.R F'r •rd .i �. F d i' 'r !` .. f _1•.1 l`} 'r y"'� '�#.', a.a, ' `!'+r .
. ! a .�a,rli � •�~ 61 •F = t �
1. r " " ,y ,' I.+ .. . - • . • * + e .rJ: *Y ,
LL
°ti*.'7- . 1 � { _ ' Y , �JF},y � a'«I a �� •�• ,' � r � F� +�, � *. � '{ a
-mom 0
r ice" ��• ■ ', � y4 � ,. �} R ���
�^ 1+1. +'L y— '. �'�,�� , ` '' r ! ° - ` �' i t., �` `� 4•" ' 4+'�F ,!•' �rl��rl��� It+ �� F' 1
' S r# y _
- •�e T` , { ! r 1 1 X •R •.Ji'
• "'1-•I a# '.4 y+w. , +.. '+'. '#' 4�t; , - 1 .-1ili #.�++ -� 1 = r
ttl� y '"""f 1 ei
ti +'� • �. r
rfY,r��r+
s `JF* ti r, r
; _ il.-r•7', .. ��._*,� i� + r!':.•'-�+ �r i- �R
.'. 7�R , �' �, ^�.t = r iil, j�-r,'h1�7'/ }5y• ,F 4 •,. !�
T . •� } ,=T
�'-,�, j r, ` • ,a 4„rr-' " .;,�` ' - _ ii ;Jet a l� f ,
Ar
., , _ .rA "ti T- • i++^��lj -A i'
Y I r �+y l,�Y, rir a + !�•F.. fy_, '�;L+'i ti.,t,L�i *iy r\
*,�� y-Iyy • T✓ 1L «
r.'4F41�. L-',l`� /1r4 '4i, h-4,l R,•� G'. 1. r�7f5,'+- rXI +1' �• ;_
lY1 #,a 1 a :*T, `r,rr S .*T ■ '7h } j
I�Fy.#•".fir 4. ` "! .'. + ' :. rAh, �i ► 4 *' fi� "zra ' ,
y1 •� 1
r ,
y�F �� 4 � t � rF � � ',i 'y�- - ti� a Y y ■ r
I 1 � A �, 1 r• e YIJ r ,_TIj ,+Y.fr '� �'r' F IX+ R ; 1 1L5 yxLA 1 Fa ih*,.}'rr'..YRF�`, '' 1',"i ,.1 '�4• y++ { „ A.
�l„ �.� r, l i y * i '' e+' 4kf i77• +U ..
.
�' y i
of /
� N c
r +
a
N 1
,
I foil
� t
ip
jA4P
e
f
S it,y i* ,
MAL
7
rd
'OVA I
Ef
It
TWW
vp
jq
r
OL
AO
`
" ' 4 +^ pr~' ' `� y.. �' LL , rf� "4."++ ` ��.' � ��. � _. � _. � `� •p .P y as # � ya '. �.� �• � �., ,f� 4 • i j "{
IL `f"1 •
y fl �pi -' �, '. �,� r�"'F �i 1�+��•- +; r "��. i��� � •# gr+ 'R►F# w � `'+— y �J} t�� r� _ '� R
RON
1fA .+�'�.�� Ff J4 s r L - t
� ' • tl" }` AE. -LIB y, , t k ytll l .,. y — r '#
'Citlbi • �.�' ;psi ° `~;f.''
rE _ . , y � . a� .% R',y, � ,. � p � �* "•4 p � a ��+y�r �: i y°� � - � i.
!A � 1�Ni' i � pe aa�� +RRR""�{`�'e �. pis .s• rr�
. , I
Y.N
r
jtl
Ok . 1 '' . w�+l 1 _ y R iN s � s y 1 ,,� ` -+ • � � � "'� � �'' V r �y �.
Y r� .. • { f .. , �'�. ,I ..^ �. , f l {., + T y'ap w ` • i� � '�� IIL
12
IL
x '
r 5
'r V
ar rf Ya i _tF- a _ t,� tl
f da Y "' i,
Id '
• iy* ,j,i IM iY hx '- i.• �.TI
F, y r 'a4_ r •'s� J�p/ ,"A41Y �.,Sf,lfp R+rt�, •- F.' + 1r l p � , � �„ rt * • � �I . 'Y 'i l " }�'LP w•
{. -.. f.tl e � is r Lr 4w �a , ., ,.� �+�,,.- ',.4. Y i' + .a* - •.. ,
+
ry
'a
f}{� °' 'sue '{'*•{ �'��.� ti� _ �ry { a -� ;4; s "�y�� �" �j '' y � ,,� ,'� "�'#Y ��•-�;�� p}a
e = #•`„ ra_.L' �[�rF , 4 ��,
, p
� It
�l " "■ � �.����a ,t � "''F" a Aa i � JF „i
�� 'I
ao y'�t, ",��4+• �f
1 {', 1 `�' Lria*. titi1f '� V� f '� air 1\•F1� a r", E T• IL16
fl Lra+•T�1•+ /+ "/ M• R 5�"Ir 1'f•/ `���a alb y + �'��e �ieY
, t S .. i 1 I - •a � / r ! � r l ° f Y F ' � � _ � ' ' '� { ./ 1 "' . +
1 ,
" _ :ra °{..� I �. -ry 'A Y.r.1 .i , r a e ^� j '41} - M �. • , �; i
may, � ,� .k' " x"+.c ti' ,� � " ,+ y �� "�. h '"'ft `i'ia• A
Yx r' +l ,_r ''} y+, -ep`I+ , 'L-r - i�r +l ,+� '11.t �� 4 a,. �i* ■ ! i # *� .i ' ap e
Y' ` -°�+# _ ,.i, ,A �', :6+� +fi�'�} {4 { ■' '¢ , F. hYy_*• ,N I /
JO
rr° � � +�'y�� i 'F+ tea' tl. I .i '`,t,��'� p � i '+ !� }N F•t �L
1'[� � ���-'� "F i �y }' 4r IF;1 F
M
, r
ti
,
+`+ 'rti$,0 ,,ly ry' ,ati i ". '! -*'�y`�iM1 4 .ia' �a 1 y ;ai'
,
IV
ff
� 's. "i �
i
�� , �t�..'��' ,_�e'-rP'�'.�° � .: .1�,�� may. 4+'� ...1 • a ' {�� Ik'+�,��'.. � ", `„ __77a,y 5+,' I5 � _.. 1 •�"�
x"N
tl' ''k# ) 1' 4Jiyy;, (1"Ilf• �w * a "i
�aFlj• Y� fp"��',, �� ly, +' 4"�. Ys'+ ■ " r i+ tl�l ��+���✓� ��4 {1 p 7 . M ����i �� ��`�M,4 � . � �� .
�.., 1 ', �. ¢I�7 f. F ° f� !' +N5 s e tlL {,..y� �f�'# �,''t �� y IN ' i + 1'�-`a•I' �� � � % i� ''� �� • t �.�
�5 Y Yee t + e "! " Ike
f i�
',� �Jf� . p { • 1,; L*'• +e a "�s7 -� a
t4., Lw'• „? F rALIF r
1• L ' 1 ', d ,11 ii - n +"F WI
7'._ r, l
f
If dr
F *� Y � d � t w� � J F r, +`i ++L f '� �'a. �/5 i � . J� * +'■ } + 'tl '!,�"� �Y* '} �, J i��a � �• rep
`y 4 e
a
44 I , - __ +' a r . 1 , �, '} l Lr •� 'y�} ' — "�'f a4,
•,tl:�
i Y
'' _°, e r �� i !' ` YES .4�•' "� -
,
,
JP
iA td�r
L
f �. q u .+ r I !" ' f i� � ►'F. • a � � . �yj � �� � +i � ' g,. w� r+ � � %�*��,F. _ � - ■ #, �, r � e ,
f e ' ' ' b ` ' y�' r a+. `, R, x + -� r.'�'/ �'i, i, d. f ` a'i aa' �f •'i/ f ` i
F � tl �' � a ■ e #r,! tiT _,.a' + f y *_�„�� ra �� a YJr
��� �•y��e r Ip
r i. a /' a .t* r� [J% / i•"IFj�'f �,. e' F
Ailed
04
+i I I" '� d +- ! II�I� I� "4 �"�•' lasj �! �i" 1# xi �a � !.'� tn,� R i .i
-ey - ,�#.'e• � ' a ' -
f 0
x
'r• 1 1^ ti x . I e i r
e, a a a� � 4 � � ', � r* ,. L .■..
_ � ,� `k''' a {,�■J� � ee� }t x * 'e d � �F�Fr,
a
+
1 , •
1 '
'� a I 71it 'r. .a • of ' #
b m - r
• 'f 1. �' - NON l I , ' :. L.Y ' • r , a # I tq-
Lieqk
r
+15 { I
"
M
w # �r e. 4 ie i ,fs f "r.' ` r ,f- •Y tea-5.y f +/
i 1
' - , � � � � EE � awl ��, � T''�t•].e �` ' 4 a i' , I �► l f: � a�
IL
Al
10
All
.p i'
If 4,
P1 iIsm { N
` 1 1
F
, 1
r
r'
AAM-17% 'L
IF
.1 4
fr �l• i '� #. �}lr' n r I 'J . a P .
lf'. All
m
Z Fb
I NROMW 2 q..th st
"Wom
- - ------------------ --
/*
�f�j'
It# xt {r }/l ,,"{ak' "d' //jJ 1�1 y fit, 5 �,, ,�,�«'k a`* ,x'f
2—a •!/� ���� � �S�i �l � �1 LV► ��r 0 IC ne-Ayn -
�t� l-�t max. �.tbek��/ o�xtid� ���-e�.
TOP- th St 360
1 i 1110 ilk
� �tia cis e.����' � C�rau�nd a�� �rher t � �lr►e.r
t'Q�'t�
befit ��.+r� �AWQLAyg 11�c]CJ��.c�i«��
^� r 40i,
t " r' - t +�* •' dI i w "+ * P + Jf '� '' •'4 I,; 4 #' ` y+ " '.. ar�R r1 '; *�
a
t., Y
14
+
1
Oj
" A
"
t " {
1�T ■ fi
,r -� A 4-. n 4 ■. � � � � s rL� �'- 'pPe . -/ ' ;' yam'' r
��iwi y J r ,.. *. + � P', � P � � � F s ; y ,4 f '" `F ' ''� �. n f■ `1 * ,
lile
OT
it
qk
-'`y'�# ,,,,, .'',IOr
�4• g+ ;T " ;^ . + F ,, 'y P ;+ i� L 5` '1� , r+" d --Y -' . /.'' ', 'P�,",1r If . - •L- +Y'r - "1.*i�-•
9 1• 11
i1 f T
•
IPA
1 IF
- 1
j� � � ! id i y P ■ �: r
. , � „� 4 � � " �l , I - 'r '� " , of * �ld . ?� , . ° ' �#,r • ' �'
p " "
, a
+
tij
W
p , . ,- i� �� P- � w " ' �' -Jr a■ f�. ,*�,P- j,
y }•
" ice" . • ,,,.*, _ k R r��'+,+d �� a ' # r.
1,
w
1 j , !
r 4 r 'may'•,!} ,+r Fy. w11 - [ +
e`� !!1 + *y • y/' [f 1 u ,� ,,♦, 7. .77 # - �Y' r ,�'', ' -,y! - .r a� r
- ! kr '°1 i• •,r� f� [, �i. #
�i. r �-f �`+'i .-� i"
1'}A. r"�r�" + s}L+,�[+ • [t' �N[J# JU
i�,F+ "- Ir ,#'''
jr
t
P
l r rAe
4_ -- • M + ^. , '!'. i } w '+ ' " r a - -
��,1t+�s-� �v +T R � �� �, � n
F_ r'r,+a� aF ai w^e{}Y1 "A'� p8^ "' `
dr
Y Jf r � f,
L if
.4
5 • 1
i a
� r
rY j # '
•-�• .•y .. h _ .v lv , + �. P .. , ri t'. #am
1 t• _ " ' fryf , , ._� +
,
r
9 y 9
-
A
IT
1-7 e
ej
7
' 1 T • i
}� T
1 .P
IF
w• s
S
a -tea
iv
of
"
' F
• x' Wv,a l
� x r a
IL
,
77
wpF�-
a .[ ,et i . R ' r ♦ r. �� . t y :. - , + A ear l':�'Yti,$AC
1 1 1
a t
ya7F ,•�P '�' - .� ���� -yJ - + � •1 � °bti "� * ��'� , Ln`
t r• r -�
y
,i j
yR.1 V�+-
: ,
iL
r 4� f r C1 i ' e • 1'i � iP ' , - T �__ * '�,' , 44'F�,y.�f � .�+ ■ w' w _ 1{ P d ,
R r � f I � " - •[ _ -' t *'" r �.�1 wit+ `ate 't •� � [ kr� �'; ' + + �, , " , y ,
k. �n/F 1'�! e4lk,.
r
F
r w ,
+ 1
.'�.
/ J I's' f.Pn C!""' P •
x w<
e
r
S L ■�
1 tiP-•i' + • r -J.. y " 'L ,[e,V t- ,�' e 4 '� Y - 'S
VIA
h
+
,' 4 ail �' ,`^ [t �� ' r
,
If
i
Pt
e y 4k-
"
' i
-„Ww.
� � ,. _ � ,.� �f ��1� �1 � �iF+ 1 Ye r ! - ". I ' I ' ' ' 4 y,4n,F-y ,. '.L � .5 S .. - � +t•- , �.
2539
LIBERTY t .f/' ` IjJ y)I i1 4'
Y F p M Y d f � '. § �p • •s A ' '4 .' 4
., • , ' - .• !l � _ f r ' f ,r � + �7 �0 ! F ! � � 1 � ni 5 �, 4 '� , �� 'Y4 X, 4 "..��' �• ky,.. r �,� `• � ,���
IL
e +
- _
. _ , - � •� r'. {. �.�� a° � ,,� a a r f} f° � .r � � / f _l � } F; �' � � � � � 1 � �I . �'1 'S �� �. .. k ; 'S, "` �' �k ��3,
- -. a' , r ff• � p Y"I f''r. ,%+ e / ,� ,r � � + i ` �1} � F I � i � � '�� � �k �
' •'{ lf #. /!rA�
/ • p
—--�•t.A�r� ®r ,� � r ti , J � - - — - l' � .� / % f 1� �..�r,f Jf /�} %� i i }� • f � � 1 " ti x �
aj } ram.• "'�"�_ — . — .a ` .— r — - _ - - _— � � .f J .d J' # J6 # Jf -/" a % �` r � �. i. o
r j J f!J A
..._+ .' ,� °"- ra n A F'_ r ..� +{drr•d� }� A^A.�:'�F ,r A� ! i +�} % r + r '•� _ !°� 5� I .� _♦ 1 \�+s_ � � , ., %'"
,
�, r " rf r r - ,. I +' � ° r A , d' I � +r � � � r � � � J t � � f� � li � 1 ' � � 5 � •y � � � �,
4 r. " - _ f . F Y A •r �" 'f o YA' A P J + f _ .. Y r S i t y {
,
, 777
- , r a r - J f r + � r •A , 1, - - ° r ° t �r+a + . . . � _ + , +t � -, 4 _ _ a� �,5� h I ._ r e �' } - JA �. " %' ° I.4 , ' • Y - , r _ °� `,I .I { I p ° ' {' - j" ` � � A , A. 1 i r � 4 � �' .'� � 1 * ,,� 9ry -. 1
it
. r °
- r rr. f.� r .°,^° ,r. � � • b+ .+ .J I , � , . + �, . ,. fy 1 F ",� +� M F. `i � .' �f � � F S e F' � � ; L t .� � �4 1 '- .�.
�'�•" " l r. % r - � � r _ Y�f�+ '^ �,• yr r I � 4. ' � � " � u I �4
LLL
1 - " .' - , r p I + r -, 4 5 • r r P n Y Y - � Y ' , a x .5
k.
,
{• J r ,r,r`,, r , � r + { �.. r � , / f .. p •1 �+ rf ,}.. z , f '7 I ��* r } �r A �Y I, 4 4}P _ , � 1 ..° ` "p __+. 4 ,
r
s- rr + - r r A _ i + + - e ' r . _ - � ` ,• ! — l� .` f j �, ° � � " . ;. "� ' � ., � • ` ° l - r �, ' ' ^ �'� '1�r�'C � 1y *� ,5 r ``
o , , f - + °+L f { .. , A • 5 '" , , ! ' " + ° S Y f 1 M ° I p fl ,. , i '} {- 4 5 4 - "Y, I
"r
r
r " _
ri .n r' .+ y ' d , " d i -�, , ' A�'' rr , ,r_1 ,•� _ + °FL PI"{ J _ } I r - `�� ' 3 ' " �.4°
,
,
' f ,
� i �.-AA: � - _° ++.�- + A" r,+ ,�_ 4 � - I r M +�. � -y � • ,, } �'3 " 5 " � ^- � 1 *, -��5
r . -
i r 1 d
rA - + ^ / - _ + - '•+ • r rP .. " % '. M { _ r ° I + �` , P11� ' +1 ' I 1 u ° YL p „ d ° 1
• 1 _
r °
, +
_ aOf
.A mp. f '" '� ra d • + Yr " +r , r '+`' r A r .1 .. ^, ,r 7 ., �° r , ` i L 1 # [•, �' L 4 iL f.•j . 1 " 9` �1, .