HomeMy WebLinkAboutPZ2023-138DATE: April lO.2823
TO: Historic Landmark Commission
FROM: Elayna Luckey, Planner I
SUBJECT: Arequest for aCertificate ofAppropriateness toreplace windows.
F|LE. P22023-138
STAFF REPORT
Jennifer SDrnnmei on behalf ofShirley Boone, seeks permission to replace twenty (20)
windows on the VV)ess house located at GlS North Fifth Street. The request is to remove
the grids from the windows on the second story, or to match the grids 1othe first floor of
the structure.
This home is categorized as a Prairie house. Examples for this style of home are located in
AField Guide bo/\nnericonHouses (McAlester eteLpgs.444'45l). The request toremove
the grids seems inappropriate with the examples given. The request to match the first
floor grids appears appropriate as a number of examples provide matching windows
throughout the structure.
Staff recommends approval ofthe request tomatch the first floor gridswith the following
1. Shall obtain all necessary building permits from the Building Codes.
2. Any replacement of trim shall match existing color scheme of the structure.
This house isininthe l99QSPARE Beaumont Survey. SPARE states the house was built c
1912. The buildings significance is listed as, the house is the only example of Prairie style
architecture in Beaumont. The house was originally owned by Harry \miess founder of
Humble QH and Refining Company (now Exxon Corporation). The house has H[
designation- The house was built by a prote"' of Frank Lloyd Wright at H.C. Banker and
Exhibits are attached.
McAle5ter, Virginia & Lee. A Field Guide to Ameritan Houses. Alfred A. Knopf, Inc., 1984. Print.
BEAVMONT
Planning & C0111111LInity Development
Case Type:Planning and Zoning
Case Sub Type: Certificate of Appropriateness
Case #: PZ2023-138
Location: 6155TH ST, BEAUMONT, 77701
Individuals listed on the record.,
Applicant
Shirley Boone
615 N 5th Street
Beaumont, TX 77�01
Agent
Jennifer Stirnmel- Statewide
2209 A Rutland Dr STE 100
Austin, TX 78758
Property Owner
Shirley Boone
615 N 5th Street
Beaumont, TX 77701
Applicant
Jennifer Stimmel- Statewide
100 Northpark Central Or Suite 450
Houston., TX 77073
Property Owner
Shirley Boone
615 N 5th St
Beaumont, TX 77701
Reason for Request of a Certificate of
Appropriateness
Paint
New Construction
Demo
Fencing
Miscellaneous
Has request been made before?
If yes, date:
Case Type: Planning and Zoning
Case #. PZ2023-138
Case Status: REVIEW
Tag Name: Window replacement
Initiated On.- 3/23/2023 1:39:18PM
Home Phone: 8432260424
Work Phone:
Cell Phone, 8432260424
E-Mail- e.shirley74@gmail.com
Home Phone: 469-480-1392
Work Phone:
Cell Phone- 512-289-8303
E-Mail- istimmel@statowideremodeling.com
Home Phone, 8432260424
Work Phone -
Cell Phone-
E-Mail- e.shirley74@gmall.com
Home Phone: 469-480-1392
Work Phone:
Cell Phone- 512-289-8303
E-Mail- jstimmel@statewideremodeling.com
Home Phone: 843-226/0424
Work Phone:
Cell Phone-
E-Mail* e.shir1ey74@0rnajI.com
Replacement windows to Vinyl windows
N
N
N
N
Y
N
Page 1 of 2
Printed On: 3/27/2023
ILI
4
I d
41
4
4p
p
If
lr
Amp"
d
.61 911111
all- I FL k
awlll�
SWAM
a I
of
Le
u
99
In
I
a
e
q-7--
3
* *' r
It
dr
IJ
it-
f -
e-4V—
r
------------f-,--- = --- - -_ -tea.- - rt `,w ■ 1
To
.rt
4 R
••� x •,
BEAUMONT, TEXAS HISTORIC SITES INVENTORY FORM - BEAUMONT HISTORICAL LANDMARK COMMISSION
1 County JEFFERSON JEF 5. 'USGS Quad No. 3094-111 Site No. 769
City/Rural BEAUMONT BMT
6. Date: Factual Est. c. 1912
2. Name Gene Alford & Assoc. Insurance Agency_
Address 615 North Fifth Street 7. Architect/BuiLder H.C. Baker and Company
Contractor
3. owner Alford, Gene et ux 8. Style 'Type --Prairie Style
Address 615 North Fifth Street, Beaumont 77702-1512
9. Original Use [DOMESTIC /Site gte DweLting
4. Block/Lot McFaddin 2 Lot 1 Block 25 SE 2-3 Present Use COMMERCS/1RADElProfessional
10. Description:
Two story frame structure. Hip roof with overhanging eaves. one eyelid dormer with Louvered vent. Two sets of three
eight -beside -eight -beside -one -pane sash. One two -over -two sash beside a wood and glass pan door with cement,
bannister. Shed roof wraparound porch supported by seven square stucco columns. One single -pane sash with multi
pane transom. Off -center wood and glass panel door with multi -pane sidelights and transom. Wing has one set of
three singte-pane sash with transom Lights. Wood porch. Cemnt steps and foundation. Two story frame garage with
stucco veneer. Flat roof with cornice brackets. Four interior capped chimneys. Six nine -over -one sash. Two wood
pane[ garage doors. One set of two doors with nine tights each. Bannister on roof with diamond pattern over single
story wing of structure.
11. Present Condition Excellent. The building is structurally sound and weLL-maintained,
12. Significance:.
The house is the only exampLe of Priarie Style arq .itecture in Beaumont. The'hous e was.originally owned %by Harry dies ,
4
founder of H urnb I e 0 i L and Ref i n i ng Company (now 5kkon Corpora t i on) . The house has HC designation. MTh house was built
by a protege of Frank Lloyd Wright at H. C. Banker and Company, Architects.
13. Relationship to Site: original Moved Date (D_escrit>e Original Site)
14. Bibliography 15. Informant Archite-eture-fiLe at McFaddin-Ward House Museum
16. Recorder S. Skarbowski Date . 06-12-90
PHOTO DATA
Black: and White 35 mm negative
YEAR DRWR ROLL FRKE ROLL FR14E
90 08 28 to .08 30
J
A. V1 Eft
RECORDED BY:
DATE:
S. -Skarbowski
coot -
PPER41pr-