Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout04/21/2020 MINBEAVM�ONT MINUTES OF THE CITY OF BEUAMONT VIRTUAL - COUNCIL MEETING W.L. Pate, Jr., Mayor Pro Tem BECKY AMES, MAYOR Randy Feldschau., At -Large Taylor Neild, Ward I VIRTUAL - CITY COUNCIL MEETING Michael D. Getz, Ward II Audwin Samuel, Ward III APRIL 21, 2020 Robin Mouton, Ward IV Tyrone E. Cooper, City Attorney Kyle Hayes, City Manager Tina Broussard, City Clerk The City Council of the City of Beaumont, Texas, met in a virtual meeting, in strict compliance with the Texas Open Meetings Act, Texas Government Code, Chapter 551 on April 21, 2020, at 1:30 p.m. to consider the following: OPENING Invocation Pledge of Allegiance Roll Call Presentation and Recognition Public Comment: Persons may speak on scheduled agenda items 1-3/Consent Agenda * Consent Agenda Mayor Ames called the council meeting to order at 1:30 p.m. Councilmember Samuel gave the invocation, Mayor Ames led the Pledge of Allegiance. Roll call was made by Tina Broussard, City Clerk. Present for the virtual meeting were Mayor Ames, Mayor Pro Tem Pate, Councilmembers Neild, Getz, Feldschau, Mouton and Samuel. Also present were Kyle Hayes, City Manager; Tyrone Cooper, City Attorney; Tina Broussard, City Clerk. Proclamations, Presentation, Recognitions None Public Comment: Persons may speak on scheduled agenda items 1-3/Consent Agenda None CONSENT AGENDA Approval of minutes — April 3, 2020 and April 7, 2020 * Confirmation of board and commission member appointments - None. A) Authorize the City Manager to accept maintenance -and authorize a final payment to DBS Constructors, LLC d/b/a MK Constructors for the Stoneleigh on Major -Sewer Emergency Repairs Project - Resolution 20-080 Minutes —April 20, 2020 B) Authorize the Chief Financial Officer to execute all documents necessary to accept funding from the Texas Department of State Health Services (DSHS) awarded to the Beaumont Public Health Department — Resolution 20-081 C) Approve a lease agreement with Ricoh USA, Inc. of Houston, for photocopiers used by various City departments — Resolution 20-082 D) Approve a payment to Motorola for a maintenance agreement to support the 800 MHz radio system — Resolution 20-083 E) . Approve the renewal of an annual. maintenance agreement with WatchGuard Video for use in the Police Department — Resolution 20-084 F) Approve a contract with Higginbotham Insurance Agency, Inc. for insurance brokerage services — Resolution 20-085 G) Authorize the City Manager to apply for and receive funds from the United States Department of Justice (Coronavirus Emergency Supplemental Funding) — Resolution 20-086 Councilmember Samuel moved to approve the Consent Agenda. Councilmember Mouton seconded the motion. AYES: MAYOR AMES, MAYOR PRO TEM PATE, COUNCILMEMBERS NEILD, GETZ, FELDSCHAU, SAMUEL AND MOUTON NAYS: NONE MOTION PASSED GENERAL BUSINESS Consider a resolution authorizing a one-year contract with Blue Cross Blue Shield of Texas with an option for four additional years effective January 1, 2021 for third party administration of the City's self-funded Preferred Provider Organization (PPO) medical and dental plans. The. City currently offers medical and dental benefits to 1,244 full-time employees and medical benefits to 201 retirees. The FY 2020 estimated cost of providing a PPO Plan and dental benefits is $16,456,000. As medical costs continue to rise, the City faces a challenge in providing the same level of medical benefits as in previous years. A Request for Proposal (RFP) was solicited and publicly opened on February 27, 2020. Holmes Murphy is the City's benefits consultant and has assisted the City in the evaluation of the responses. Two medical and two dental proposals were received and City staff along with Holmes Murphy staff reviewed the responses from BCBSTX and United Healthcare. After analyzing and negotiating with the finalists,. City staff and Holmes Murphy concluded that BCBSTX, the incumbent carrier, offered the most cost-effective plan with an extensive provider network and deep provider _discounts. Renewal administrative rates projected by BCBSTX for the PPO Plan increased 2% for years 2021-2023. Administrative costs for years 2024 and 2025 were negotiated to increase 3%. Minutes —April 20, 2020 . The final negotiated rates are lower than the projected industry trend of 8% and the projected increase could be higher depending on the impact of the Covid-19 outbreak. The PPO Medical plan consists of the following benefits: Plan Design PPO Plan Deductible $500 Primary Care Doctor $10 Specialist $30 Staff recommends implementation of the following rates to be paid by the City for PPO and Dental administration effective January 1, 2021: Funds will come from the Employee Benefits Fund. Approval of the resolution. Councilmember Neild moved to APPROVE A RESOLUTION THAT THE CITY MANAGER BE AND HE IS HEREBY AUTHORIZED TO ENTER INTO A ONE-YEAR CONTRACT WITH BLUE CROSS BLUE SHIELD OF TEXAS (BCBSTX) WITH AN OPTION FOR. FOUR (4) ADDITIONAL YEARS, AT THE NEGOTIATED RATES, FOR THIRD PARTY ADMINISTRATION OF THE CITY'S SELF-FUNDED PREFERRED PROVIDER Minutes — April 20, 2020 2021-2023 Monthly PPO 2024/2025 Monthly PPO Administration Rates Administration Rates BCBS BCBS United BCBS United Employee $47.49 $51.83 $48.91/$50.38 $54.52/$57.14 Only $3.14 Employee + Family $3.10 $3.14 Employee + 1 $47.49 $51.83 $48.91/$50.38 $54.52/$57.14 Dependent Employee + $47.49 $51.83 $48.91/$50.38 $54.42/$57.14 Family Funds will come from the Employee Benefits Fund. Approval of the resolution. Councilmember Neild moved to APPROVE A RESOLUTION THAT THE CITY MANAGER BE AND HE IS HEREBY AUTHORIZED TO ENTER INTO A ONE-YEAR CONTRACT WITH BLUE CROSS BLUE SHIELD OF TEXAS (BCBSTX) WITH AN OPTION FOR. FOUR (4) ADDITIONAL YEARS, AT THE NEGOTIATED RATES, FOR THIRD PARTY ADMINISTRATION OF THE CITY'S SELF-FUNDED PREFERRED PROVIDER Minutes — April 20, 2020 2021 Monthly Dental Administration Rates 2022-2025 Monthly Dental Administration Rates BCBS United BCBS United Employee Only $3.10 $3.14 $3.25 $3.14 Employee + 1 Dependent $3.10 $3.14 $3.25 $3.14 Employee + Family $3.10 $3.14 $3.25 $3.14 Funds will come from the Employee Benefits Fund. Approval of the resolution. Councilmember Neild moved to APPROVE A RESOLUTION THAT THE CITY MANAGER BE AND HE IS HEREBY AUTHORIZED TO ENTER INTO A ONE-YEAR CONTRACT WITH BLUE CROSS BLUE SHIELD OF TEXAS (BCBSTX) WITH AN OPTION FOR. FOUR (4) ADDITIONAL YEARS, AT THE NEGOTIATED RATES, FOR THIRD PARTY ADMINISTRATION OF THE CITY'S SELF-FUNDED PREFERRED PROVIDER Minutes — April 20, 2020 ORGANIZATION (PPO) MEDICAL PLAN AND SELF-FUNDED DENTAL PLAN EFFECTIVE JANUARY 1, 2021. Councilmember Feldschau seconded the motion. AYES: MAYOR AMES, MAYOR PRO TEM PATE, COUNCILMEMBERS NEILD, GETZ, FELDSCHAU, SAMUEL AND MOUTON NAYS: NONE MOTION PASSED Resolution 20-087 2. Consider amending Section 20.03.003 of the Code of Ordinances that would change the speed zone boundaries and the speed limit on one section of College Street (U.S. Highway 90). The Texas Department of Transportation (TxDOT) performed a traffic survey of College Street (U.S. Highway 90) from the western city limits (Keith Road) to FM 364 (Major Drive). The average crash rate over the past three (3) years for this section of road is 364, nearly double the statewide average of 160 for similar roadways. Administration and TxDOT propose the speed zone boundaries and speed limit for these sections of College Street (U.S. Highway 90) be amended under the schedule Chapter 20 Section 20.03.003 to read as follows: Street Limits of Zones College (c) From a point 60 feet Street (U.S. west of the centerline of 23rd Hwy 90) Street to a point 60 feet east of the centerline of Wescalder. (d) From a point 60 feet east of the centerline of Wescalder to the west city limits. Approval of the ordinance. Direction of Speed In Miles Per Travel Hour Max. Min. East and West 50 East and West 55 Councilmember Samuel moved to ADOPT AN ORDINANCE ENTITLED AN ORDINANCE AMENDING CHAPTER 20, ARTICLE 20.03, SECTION 20.03.003 OF THE CODE -OF ORDINANCES OF BEAUMONT, TEXAS BY CHANGING AND AMENDING SPEED LIMITS AND SPEED ZONE BOUNDARIES TO THE SCHEDULE FOR COLLEGE STREET (U.S. HWY 90); DELETING CHAPTER 20, ARTICLE 20.03, SECTION 20.03.00 (E) OF THE SCHEDULE FOR COLLEGE STREET (U.S. HWY 90); PROVIDING FOR SEVERABILITY; PROVIDING FOR REPEAL; AND PROVIDING A PENALTY. Mayor Pro Tem Pate seconded the motion. AYES: MAYOR AMES, MAYOR PRO TEM PATE, COUNCILMEMBERS NEILD, GETZ, FELDSCHAU, SAMUEL AND MOUTON NAYS: NONE Minutes — April 20, 2020 MOTION PASSED Ordinance 20-016 3. Consider an ordinance denying the Entergy Texas, Inc. application for a Distribution Cost Recovery Factor rate increase on file with the City of Beaumont. On March 31, 2020 Entergy Texas, Inc. filed an application with the cities in its service area and at the same time with the Public Utility Commission of Texas (PUCT) to amend its Distribution Cost Recovery Factor (DCRF). The DCRF filing allows the company to make adjustments to an existing non -fuel rate based upon changes in its distribution related investment capital. The scope of a DCRF proceeding is limited and the timeline for addressing these cases is shorter than the typical rate case. Cities have sixty (60) days to either accept, modify, or reject the DCRF application. The existing tariff approved in 2019 allows $3.2 million in annual revenue. The application before you is requesting to collect an additional $20.4 million in annual revenue, making a total of $23.6 million in annual revenue.. As a result, residential customers would incur $14.6 million or (62%) of the increase. This translates into approximately $2.09 per month for an average residential customer using 1000 kWh per month. The Cities utility attorneys and consultants are reviewing the application to determine the propriety of the calculations, class billing determinants, and resulting rates. In the past, DCRF applications were resolved with Entergy receiving less than the requested amounts. It is the recommendation that the application be denied. A denial will allow for an appeal of the decision which will be joined with the already existing case before the PUCT for a full review. The reasonable expenses associated with rate cases are reimbursable by the company as provided for in the Public Utility Regulatory Act. Approval of ordinance. Councilmember Mouton moved to ADOPT AN ORDINANCE BY THE CITY OF BEAUMONT, TEXAS ("CITY") DENYING THE DISTRIBUTION COST RECOVERY FACTOR RATE INCREASE REQUEST OF ENTERGY TEXAS, INC. FILED ON MARCH 31, 2020; SETTING JUST AND REASONABLE RATES FOR ENTERGY TEXAS, INC. FOR SERVICE WITHIN THE MUNICIPAL LIMITS. Mayor Pro Tem Pate seconded the motion. AYES: MAYOR AMES, MAYOR PRO TEM PATE, COUNCILMEMBERS GETZ, FELDSCHAU, SAMUEL AND MOUTON NAYS: NONE ABSTAIN: COUNCILMEMBER NEILD MOTION PASSED Ordinance 20-017 Minutes—April 20, 2020 PUBLIC HEARING Receive comments on the proposed mandatory payment rate related to the Local Provider Participation Fund for FY 2020 Public Hearing Open: 1:53 p.m. Gary Troutman 3080 College St. Beaumont TX Thanked Council on behalf of Baptist Hospital, the Board of Directors and frontline providers for placing this item on the agenda, would like to emphasize the critical nature and action for hospitals to carry on their operations and to care for victims during this terrible virus as well as to maintain their capacity as safety net hospital providers Public Hearing Close: 1:53 p.m. 4. Consider setting the mandatory payment rate related to the Local Provider Participation Fund for FY 2020. On June 9, 2015, the City Council authorized the City's participation in a municipal health care provider participation program to support the payment of Medicaid supplemental hospital payments to Safety -Net Hospitals in the City. At the same time, the City Council authorized the execution of indigent care affiliation agreements with Baptist Hospitals of Southeast Texas and Christus Hospital. In addition, on July 28, 2015, the City Council approved model rules and procedures related to the City of Beaumont's facilitation of the program. The City of Beaumont is required to set the amount of the mandatory payments required to be paid by the hospitals. The mandatory payment must be uniformly proportionate with the amount of net patient revenue generated by each paying hospital in the municipality. The mandatory rate for the fiscal year ending 2020 will be 3.46%. Funds will come from the local Safety -Net Hospitals, they will make mandatory payments into the Beaumont Municipal Health Care Provider Participation Fund. Approval of the resolution. Mayor Pro Tem Pate moved to APPROVE A RESOLUTION SETTING THE MANDATORY PAYMENT RATE FOR THE FISCAL YEAR 2020 FOR THE LOCAL PROVIDER PARTICIPATION FUND IN THE MUNICIPAL HEALTH CARE PROVIDER PARTICIPATION PROGRAM. Councilmember Feldschau seconded the motion. AYES: - MAYOR AMES, MAYOR PRO TEM PATE, COUNCILMEMBERS NEILD, GETZ, FELDSCHAU, SAMUEL AND MOUTON NAYS: NONE MOTION PASSED Resolution 20-088 Minutes — April 20, 2020 WORK SESSION Review and discuss the CenterPoint Energy 2019 Base Rate Increase Mr. Dan Lawton reviewed and discussed the CenterPoint Energy 2019 Base Rate Increase. Mr. Lawton stated that there were (3) three cities that joined this action, they were Beaumont and the East Texas area, as well as a group called the Alliance of CenterPoint Municipalities. The (3) three groups divided the work to avoid duplication. One group looked at investment, another at expenses and another at profits. After completing the entire analysis of hiring consultants and working with the company they were able to negotiate a solution to the case and negotiating down the proposed rate increase of $7.1 million down to $4 million. Had the City of Beaumont not agreed with the other cities, Beaumont would have had to go through the litigation alone. Mr. Lawton stated that he recommended to the City Attorney, Tyrone Cooper that a settlement at'this point would be a good idea and would reduce rate case expenses. Mr. Lawton also stated that the other two groups expended approximately $140,000.00 each. The Lawton Law Firm on behalf of the City of Beaumont expended $16,000.00, had the city wanted to go through litigation their cost would have been much higher. Mr. Lawton asked Council to pay attention to the outline of the. settlement that he provided to them prior to the meeting, the entire $4 million increase does go to the residential class, the other two classes which are small and large commercial will have no rate change, the only class of customers that will be impacted by this are the residential customers. COMMENTS Public Comments (Persons are limited to three minutes) None Councilmembers/City Manager/City Attorney comments on various matters COUNCILMEMBER COMMENTS MAYOR PRO TEM PATE - ENCOURAGED CITIZENS TO CONTINUE DOING WHAT THEY ARE DOING, EVERYONE WILL BE BETTER OFF AT THE END OF THIS COUNCILMEMBER FELDSCHAU - ENCOURAGED EVERYONE TO PLEASE BE PATIENT, CONTINUE SOCIAL DISTANCING, STATED THAT THE CITY IS DOING EVERYTHING IT CAN TO PROVIDE A SAFE AND HEALTHY ENVIRONMENT FOR EVERYBODY, KNOWS THAT EVERYONE IS WANTING TO REOPEN THE NATION AND GET BACK TO WORK AND THEY ARE TRYING TO FIND A PATHWAY THAT IS SAFE, HEALTHY AND WISE, LET'S WORK TOGETHER TO PROTECT OURSELVES AND OTHERS COUNCILMEMBER SAMUEL - ASKED IF HE COULD GET AN IDEA OF ALL THOSE THAT HAVE BEEN TESTED, HE'S SURE THAT THERE ARE SOME DEMOGRAPHIC INFORMATION ABOUT THE BREAKDOWN OF THE DESPAIRED COMMUNITIES, STATED THAT THIS IS HIS CONCERN AS AN EXIT STRATEGY TO REOPEN OUR CITY WILL BE COMING, ONE OF THE THINGS THAT IS CERTAIN IS WHAT PERCENTAGE OF THE POPULATION HAS ACTUALLY BEEN TESTED, THE CITY COULD FIND THAT THERE IS A LARGE PERCENTAGE OF THE Minutes — April 20, 2020 COMMUNITY THAT HAS NOT BEEN TESTED, UNDERSTANDS THAT THERE ARE REGULAR TEST FOR ANYONE IN SOME PARTS OF SOUTH COUNTY BUT ISN'T CERTAIN THAT ANYONE THAT WANTS TO BE TESTED CAN BE TESTED IN THE NORTHERN PART OF THE COUNTY, THAT'S ONE OF THE CONCERNS THAT HE HAS, IT APPEARS THAT COMMUNITIES OF COLOR HAS HAD AN IMPACT FROM THE VIRUS WHICH IS ONE OF THE THINGS THAT HE'S CONCERNED WITH, STATED THAT AS WE MOVE FORWARD AND TRY TO REOPEN WOULD LIKE TO SEE EVERYONE TESTED COUNCILMEMBER MOUTON - STATED THAT SHE'S BEEN ASKED ABOUT THE CITY'S NUMBERS, IF AT ALL POSSIBLE, COULD THE CITY KEEP UP WITH OR EITHER HAVE A MORE ACCURATE COUNT ON A DAILY OR WEEKLY BASIS, A LOT OF CITIZENS ARE STATING THAT THEY DON'T FEEL THAT THE INFORMATION IS BEING PUT OUT TO THE PUBLIC IN A TIMELY MANNER, ASKED THAT EVEN AFTER THE CITY IS OPEN TO CONTINUE TO PRACTICE SOCIAL DISTANCING BECAUSE THE CITY STILL DOESN'T KNOW WHERE THE PEAK IS AND WHO'S WALKING AROUND THAT COULD BE STILL CARRYING THE VIRUS COUNCILMEMBER GETZ - COMMENTED ON THE TRAGEDY THAT OCCURRED ON LAST WEEK AT THE EVENT CENTRE, STATED THAT THIS IS THE FIRST PERSON THAT HAS DROWNED BUT NOT THE FIRST CHILD THAT HAS FALLEN IN THE LAKE AND THERE WILL PROBABLY BE MORE, STATED THAT THE CITY SHOULD LOOK AT PUTTING INTO EFFECT SOME SORT OF SAFETY MEASURES IN THE FORM OF A BARRIER OR SOME SORT OF DESIGN THAT COULD BE HELPFUL IN SLOWING DOWN A CHILD THAT MIGHT BE RUNNING TOWARDS THE POND, FOR THAT REASON WOULD LIKE TO ASK FOR A WORKSESSION TO DISCUSS OPTIONS, STATED THAT HE'S NOT IN FAVOR OF FILLING IN THE POND AS SOME CITIZENS HAVE SUGGESTED AND NOT IN FAVOR OF PUTTING UP A SIX FOOT FENCE, THINKS THAT THERE ARE SOME THINGS THAT COULD PROBABLY BE DONE THAT ARE COST EFFECTIVE AND MAINTAIN THE AESTHETICS OF THE POND, IF THERE IS ANOTHER COUNCILMEMBER THAT IS IN FAVOR OF HAVING THE WORKSESSION TO LET THE CITY MANAGER KNOW, ANNOUNCED A VIRTUAL DOWLEN/WEST NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATION MEETING ON TUESDAY, APRIL 23, 2020, AT 4:30 P.M., IT WILL BE AUDIO ONLY, IN ORDER TO PARTICIPATE CITIZENS NEEDS TO CALL 1-888-476-4499, THE MEETING ID IS 470963218, THE MEETING PASSWORD IS 316916, WISHED HIS WIFE A HAPPY BIRTHDAY COUNCILMEMBER NEILD - THOUGHTS AND PRAYERS GO OUT TO THE FAMILY OF THE CHILD THAT HAD THE INCIDENT AT THE EVENT CENTRE, STATED THAT HE'S NOT A 100% CONVINCED THAT A FENCE AROUND THE POND IS A SOLUTION, THERE ARE DITCHES, LAKES AND POOLS AND ANYTHING ELSE IN OUR AREA WITH WATER, ONE OF THE THINGS THAT HE DOES WANT TO TAKE THE Minutes —April 20, 2020 OPPORTUNITY TO MENTION IS FOR PARENTS, GUARDIANS AND' GRANDPARENTS TO START TAKING THE WATER SERIOUS AS WE APPROACH SUMMER TIME, STATED THAT ACCIDENTS AND INCIDENTS CAN HAPPEN AROUND THE WATER, DON'T EVER UNDERESTIMATE THE POWER OF WATER, COMPLIMENTED CHIEF SINGLET_ ARYAND CHIEF WHITE AND EVERYONE AT THE EOC FOR THE JOB THAT THEY ARE DOING CITY ATTORNEY COOPER - NONE CITY MANAGER HAYES - NONE MAYOR AMES - STATED THAT ALL COUNCILMEMBERS SHOULD HAVE GOTTEN A LIST OF ALL NEIGHBORHOOD ASSOCIATIONS WITH DIAL IN INFORMATION FOR VIRTUAL MEETINGS, IF. ANY MEMBER OF AN ASSOCIATION NEEDS TO GET THE DIAL IN INFORMATION THEY CAN CALL THE EXECUTIVE OFFICE AT CITY HALL, COMMENTED ON THE COVID-19 NUMBERS„ STATED THAT THERE IS A REPORT THAT SHE HAS BEEN PUTTING OUT EVERY DAY THAT IS . VERY DETAILED, STATED THAT IT DOESN'T HAVE ETHNICITY ON IT BUT THAT CAN EASILY BE ADDED, THE REPORT DOES HAVE AGE RANGE, TOTAL NUMBER OF DEATHS AS WELL AS HOW MANY PEOPLE IN THE CITY HAVE BEEN TESTED, IT ALSO HAS THE NUMBER OF CITIZENS THAT HAVE RECOVERED, THE NUMBER OF CITIZENS THAT HAVE TESTED POSITIVE AS WELL AS 'THOSE THAT TESTED NEGATIVE, AT THE TOP OF THE REPORT IN RED IT WILL SHOW THE AMOUNT THAT TESTED POSITIVE FOR THAT DAY, ALSO STATED' THAT AT THE BOTTOM OF THE REPORT IS WHERE NEW ITEMS ARE ADDED, AS OF YESTERDAY A NUMBER WAS ADDED FOR CITIZENS THAT WOULD LIKE TO MAKE AN APPOINTMENT TO GET TESTED, THEY CAN CALL THE EMERGENCY OPERATIONS CENTER COVID-19 HOTLINE AT 409-550-2536, THE ONLY TESTING LOCATION RIGHT NOW IS AT THE .LACK BROOKS REGIONAL AIRPORT, IF AND WHEN ANOTHER SIGHT IS ADDED OF COURSE CITIZENS WILL BE INFORMED OF THE LOCATION, MADE ADDITIONAL COMMENTS REGARDING COVID-19 Mayor Ames read the announcement regarding Executive Session being held at the conclusion of the General Business portion of the meeting. Open session of meeting recessed at 2:48 p.m. EXECUTIVE SESSION * Consider matters related to contemplated or pending litigation in accordance with Section 551.071 of the Government Code: Claim of Shirley Allen Minutes — April 20, 2020 1 re beipg no action taken in Executive Session, Council adjourned. BeAy Ames, na Broussard, City Clerk r� U I.� Minutes —April 20, 2020 ABSTENTION AFFIDAVIT THE STATE OF TEXAS § COUNTY OF JEFFERSON § I, ar l , as a member of the �G, tl. nq 0 n� Cit Council, Commission, or Board) ake this affidavit and hereby on oath state the following: I, and/or a person or persons related to me, have a substantial interest in a business entity that would be peculiarly affected by a vote or decision of the f3C.CA1AYV rjV1- - (City Council, Commission, or Board) as those terms are defined in V.T.C.A., Local Government Code, § 171.002. The business entity is: E-rj-1-k>,Y as _ T a t" u At Wk 4 ' Qj (Address) ("I," or name of relative and relationship) have/has a substantial interest in this business entity for the following reasons: (check all of which are applicable.) Ownership of 10 percent or more of the voting stock or shares of the business entity. Ownership of either 10 percent or more or $15,000 or more of the fair market value of the business entity. Funds received from the. business entity exceed 10 percent of (my, her, his). gross income for the previous year. Real property is involved, and (I, he, she) have an interest which is an equitable or legal ownership with a fair market value of at least $2,500. . A relative of mine, within the first or second degree by blood or marriage, has a substantial interest in the business entity or property that would be affected by a decision of the public body of which I am a member. Upon filing of this affidavit with the City Clerk, I affirm that I will abstain from voting on any decision involving this business entity and from any further participation on this matter whatsoever. Signed this the D�day of , 20 a b ure of Official Coun•�►� menrtib�,r- V�.ard 1 Title BEFORE ME, the undersigned authority, on this day personally appeared IG and on oath stated that the facts hereinabove stated rrare true to the best : ""of his/h4 knowledge or belief SWORN to and subscribed before me ,= his the 0� day of 'w( , 20ao . &4 No±an, pj 1h_ c ;►, and_for the Sate of Texas TINA GAIL BRO SSARD Notary Public, State of Texas �•. ,,'� Comm. Expires 01-12-2023 Notary ID 11435119